4 ms·
I liked the chapter in Nate Sivers' Signal and the Noise when he talks about how hard it is to know if you're a good professional poker player. Been a while si
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
I liked the chapter in Nate Sivers' Signal and the Noise when he talks about how hard it is to know if you're a good professional poker player.
Been a while since I read it but feel like even after a couple of years of winning games and tracking his own performance, he had enough stats knowledge to realise that he didn't actually know if he was good or just lucky. The noise swamped the signal.
This feels relevant to many of these trading things where people start to believe their own BS.
If you've flipped a coin and it's came up heads 10 times in a row, why wouldn't you bet everything on it happening again? You're really good at getting heads when you flip. Humans aren't really built for that kind of thing.
- bambax 4y agoIn Midnight Run (1988) when Marvin finds the Duke and Jack in the sandstone of Red Rock Country he exclaims "Am I lucky or am I just good?": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gokkl2br7G8&t=152s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gokkl2br7G8&t=152s Later in the movie, when Marvin decides to ask for more money and takes a Polaroid of the Duke in the bathroom of the motel, he comments to himself: "I amaze myself... I'm always thinking." The thing is, the character of Marvin is quite dumb, not a nice person and above all someone who never grasps the full picture -- but at the same time he has good instincts and is, in fact, a fairly good hunter. It's a dangerous combination.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- blitzar 4y agoIn crypto as in wall street bets. If your sample is "a bull market when every single week the price is higher than the previous" - then the signal and the noise confirm; if you lose money on monday buy the dip with your client funds - because you cant possibly lose.
- pge 4y agoThe same is very true in VC investing. Because any individual partner does not make that many bets per year, and the time frame to exit is long, it is very difficult to distinguish skill from luck (including being in a long-term bull market like the last decade).
- Naga 4y agoAnother book in this vein is Taleb's Fooled By Randomness.