3 ms·
I would say yes to "is it tangible" for a dragon, but TFA implies that the author would say no. Thoughts?
by aidenn0 4y ago
I would say yes to "is it tangible" for a dragon, but TFA implies that the author would say no. Thoughts?
- tgv 4y agoThere's a school of language philosophy that says that the existence of a dragon is a false premise, and thus that every predicate is true for it. Others would claim that such sentence aren't true nor false. The archetypical example is "The king of France is bald". However ... no theory of (natural) language has been consistent with human judgement, so all these attempts to formalize semantics should be take with a large grain of salt. They are attempts, not even theories.
- blowski 4y agoAn episode of the BBC Radio programme "In Our Time" discussed this. https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04v59gz https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04v59gz
- philwelch 4y ago> Others would claim that such sentence aren't true nor false. The archetypical example is "The king of France is bald". This depends on whether you’re a Legitimist or an Orleanist. And even then, the Orleanist claimant is only “balding”, looks to be around 4 or so on the Norwood scale.
- tgv 4y agoOut-of-touchists, more likely. Imagine squabbling about the legitimacy of the Treaty of Utrecht.
- jamiek88 4y agoIs anything fictional tangible?
- MiddleEndian 4y agoIs the ghost of a human a mammal?
- bandie91 4y agounder Thomistic philosophy, yes.
- Sprocklem 4y agoI don't think human ghosts are mammals, but for some reason that surprises me. I guess maybe my instinct is that mammals are a class of physical creatures, but mammal-ness seems simultaneously an inherent part of human-ness. I'm not sure what to do with this information.
- aidenn0 4y agoLet's say there's an apple in a biography from the 19th century. That apple has long since biodegraded. Is it somehow more tangible than an apple from a novel?
- Kiro 4y agoThat's why it's a bad question that only works in group of friends where it has been established what tangible means.
- jobigoud 4y agoCan you touch one? No because they don't exist, so not tangible.
- Kiro 4y agoStill very much open to different interpretations. Again, very bad question overall that shows that the author only plays this with the same group of friends where rules are predefined.
- aidenn0 4y agoThe thing that I imagine in my head when someone says "dragon" is something that I could touch (just as much as the thing I imagine in my head when someone says "apple" is something that I could touch). I can't touch the Colossus of Rhodes as it no longer exists, but that doesn't make it tangible, so it need not exist right now. If someone genetically engineers a dragon in the future, does that retroactively make dragons tangible today?