3 ms·
> So it is “good” for a company to destroy the thing it spent 15 years building, put all employees out of a job, and harm society in the process, because “share
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> So it is “good” for a company to destroy the thing it spent 15 years building, put all employees out of a job, and harm society in the process, because “shareholder value”
Companies are legal fictions that exist as proxies for their shareholders. Is it good for the shareholders to do things that serve the shareholders shared financial interests? Sure.
Is it good for anyone else? Well, notionally its good for the purpose on the other end of the deal, in that person’s estimation, or the deal wouldn’t exist. “But Musk wanted out of the deal,” you say? Sure, and so maybe in this case it wasn’t good for the counterparty; but its good that we enforce contracts, because people expend resources based on agreements, so its good that people are discouraged from entering into them without due consideration, and enforcement is a key means to do that.
Is it good that we have a system where companies are basically just proxies for capital owners (in some systems, this is not the case, and either employee or public interests are directly represented in firm governance, not just capital ownership)? Maybe not, and that debate is worth having, but this is the system we have.