4 ms·
"Eli Lilly" did effectively join Mastodon, in 2018, except that it was Wil Wheaton, and ... things went poorly. Wil joined what was at the time my own home ins
by dredmorbius 4y ago
"Eli Lilly" did effectively join Mastodon, in 2018, except that it was Wil Wheaton, and ... things went poorly.
Wil joined what was at the time my own home instance, following something of a flameout on Twitter, itself caused by 1) people harassing him there, 2) Wil employing a shared, user-generated blocklist which 3) by both its own size and celeb-driven adoption rendered many other Twitter accounts effectively blocked --- not by Twitter, but as a result of individual adoptions of that blocklist. How legitimate inclusions were, and/or how feasible it was to get off the blocklist, I really can't say. That said, Wil arrived on Mastodon with both a large fan and foe base.
Harassment of Wil began on Mastodon.
<https://www.theglobaldispatch.com/mastadon-shuts-down-wil-wheaton-after-attacks-from-sjw-mobs-trolls-as-they-win-again-11877/ https://www.theglobaldispatch.com/mastadon-shuts-down-wil-wh...>
The admin/moderator was ... less than transparent or capable, and responded to a case of "this profile is causing me problems" by banning that profile rather than seeking out the root cause of the griefers who'd in fact triggered the problem.
<https://mastodon.cloud/@wilw/100635779449174251 https://mastodon.cloud/@wilw/100635779449174251>
Ultimate, Wil left Mastodon as well, writing his own account of the matter:
<https://wilwheaton.net/2018/08/the-world-is-a-terrible-place-right-now-and-thats-largely-because-it-is-what-we-make-it/ https://wilwheaton.net/2018/08/the-world-is-a-terrible-place...>
Mastodon's evolved its own tools and practices (both technically and as a community, including a community of admins), and should perform better in future, though much engineering progress emerges through pain, suffering, or worse.
Wil is, in the world of celebrity, fairly modest stakes. I've heard tales of Twitter that there was a point where it could only handle a tweet from one major celeb (e.g., Justin Bieber, Katy Perry, or one of the 'dashians) at a time, and effectively had servers dedicated to sufficiently large accounts. Celebrities proved an interesting stress-testing mechanism.
Mastodon ... has not yet experienced this, and I've my concerns with how well it might handle such scaling, or what specific elements of scaling (users, instances, posts, interactions, ...) will prove most problematic. I've certainly seen and heard of numerous cases of growing pains over the past few weeks, though nothing insurmountable.
But:
1. Celebs and brands are profile types that should be considered.
2. Mastodon's had some experience and performed poorly, both technically and culturally.
3. Adding very-high-profile profiles to the network needs some consideration. It's quite likely that there will be poorly-thought-through adoptions in future, however.
- jameshart 4y agoRight, the issue here is like if Wil Wheaton starts hanging out at a café, and it's just a small café, and the owner at first thinks it's pretty cool that a celeb is hanging out there, and some trekkies start coming by, which increases the vibe of the place... ... but then a bunch of guys in stormtrooper outfits start showing up every day and the trekkies start fighting with them and the cops are getting called out and pretty much eventually the owner is going to ask Mr. Wheaton to stop coming by. And because it's just someone else's café, he pretty much has to do that. The good news is, going to that café is not the only way for him to participate in the fediverse. He is the proud owner and operator of wilwheaton.net, and he can point that at his own activitypub server, that nobody can kick him off. He can bulk block all stormtroopers, interact with the trekkies in the café, and handle his own bandwidth and compute bills for delivering his content to all his fans. Bonus: the fact he's posting from @wil@wilwheaton.net acts as a pretty solid cast iron guarantee of authenticity, that you are dealing with the one and only actual Wil Wheaton. Meanwhile, Stephen King is sat at the café down the road trying to figure out why the new owner there wants him to pay him $8 a month to have the owner keep telling people who walk in 'yep, that's the real Stephen King over there'.
- dredmorbius 4y agoIf the cafe advertises itself for all, and as a kinder, gentler, happier, more ethical, and safer place than BigCafe, then ... at least some of the onus is on the cafe owner(s), creator(s), and operator(s). I've been on Mastodon since 2016. I enjoy and appreciate it. I admire the goals. But much of the "it's intrinsically better / safe / scalable" talk seems based on little more than hope and faith, rather than evidence and engineering. And given the Fediverse's own protocols, operating out of MyCafe rather than SafeCafe or BigCafe ... only provides modest additional protections. Yes, it helps assert identity more effectively (as I've previously noted: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33512169 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33512169>), but it only solves a small portion of the abuse, trust, and safety concerns. Mechanisms simply are not yet sufficiently robust for a large-scale (100m -- billions of MAU) social network. Some of that will come in time, though I've concerns that there are weaknesses that have already been baked into the underlying architecture and assumptions.