5 ms·
How the War Was Won
- chasil 4y agoI had an argument with family members yesterday on these quotes from Stalin and his agents, on the impact of U.S. industrial output on Russia's effort. '"I want to tell you what, from the Russian point of view, the president and the United States have done for victory in this war," Stalin said. "The most important things in this war are the machines.... The United States is a country of machines. Without the machines we received through Lend-Lease, we would have lost the war."... '"If the United States had not helped us, we would not have won the war," [Nikita Khrushchev] wrote in his memoirs. "One-on-one against Hitler's Germany, we would not have withstood its onslaught and would have lost the war. No one talks about this officially, and Stalin never, I think, left any written traces of his opinion, but I can say that he expressed this view several times in conversations with me."... 'In 1963, KGB monitoring recorded Soviet Marshal Georgy Zhukov saying: "People say that the allies didn't help us. But it cannot be denied that the Americans sent us materiel without which we could not have formed our reserves or continued the war. The Americans provided vital explosives and gunpowder. And how much steel! Could we really have set up the production of our tanks without American steel? And now they are saying that we had plenty of everything on our own."' The counter-argument was that this was propaganda, but I don't accept that. https://www.rferl.org/a/did-us-lend-lease-aid-tip-the-balance-in-soviet-fight-against-nazi-germany/30599486.html https://www.rferl.org/a/did-us-lend-lease-aid-tip-the-balanc...
- throw0101c 4y ago> The counter-argument was that this was propaganda, but I don't accept that. Research seems to indicate that over one-third of the tanks used by the Russians in defence around Moscow during Barbarossa (in Dec 1941) were British: * https://www.historynet.com/did-russia-really-go-it-alone-how-lend-lease-helped-the-soviets-defeat-the-germans.htm https://www.historynet.com/did-russia-really-go-it-alone-how... * https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13518040600697811 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/1351804060069781... * https://twitter.com/adam_tooze/status/1344630636296818690 https://twitter.com/adam_tooze/status/1344630636296818690 (via) More from the 2013 Kursk presentation at the [US] National WWII Museum: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N6xLMUifbxQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N6xLMUifbxQ I've heard the expression: Word War Two [in Europe] was won by British intelligence, Russian blood, and American steel.
- nl 4y ago> Research seems to indicate that over one-third of the tanks used by the Russians in defence around Moscow during Barbarossa (in Dec 1941) were British: I didn't know this, but I don't find it astonishing. This was when Russia was losing and the defense of Moscow was pretty desperate. It's likely a lot of those British tanks were lost during that battle (as noted, they weren't very good) and replaced with T-34s. It's worth noting that most of the recorded losses of tanks by the Germans were in battles against T-34s.
- throw0101c 4y ago> It's worth noting that most of the recorded losses of tanks by the Germans were in battles against T-34s. Russia had to first survive long enough to get things turned around so they could take the offensive. On the T-34s: > To the Deputy People's Commissar of Medium Machinebuilding, comrade Goreglyad 8a Ryazanskaya St. > In response to your letter #16/2291 on March 18th, 1941 > The GABTU considers it necessary to deliver the V-2-34 engine together with the main clutch for the following reasons: > The warranty period of the main clutch is seldom higher than the lifespan of the engine: the engine's guaranteed lifespan is 150 hours, the tank travels 2000-2250 km in this time. The existing main clutch needs replacing after this time. > The existing design of the main clutch on factory #183 T-34 tanks requires the following changes to be compatible with diesel engines received from factory #75: […] * https://www.tankarchives.ca/2020/12/weakest-link.html https://www.tankarchives.ca/2020/12/weakest-link.html * https://twitter.com/Tank_Archives/status/1344342553911582722 https://twitter.com/Tank_Archives/status/1344342553911582722 (see thread on Kursk) When the average lifespan in battle was ~14 hours, the stated 150 hours sounds pretty good.
- nl 4y agoWorth noting that (again) logistics are the important factor. Tanks might survive 14 hours in battle, but spend much longer getting there (and there weren't often tank transports available outside railways).
- pencilguin 4y agoBritish intelligence, Bletchley Park aside, was amazingly ham-handed and ineffective, by accounts of those involved. (See Leo Marks, "Between Silk and Cyanide".) The US, incidentally, was able to decrypt Enigma traffic independently of Bletchley using ordinary cryptanalysis.
- Gunax 4y agoLikewise, most westerners know that the war was mostly between Germany and Soviet Union. The other theatres were conparitively small. Americans may have given their steel, but Soviets gave their blood.
- JackFr 4y agoThe Soviets enabled the Third Reich by providing facilities to build and train an air force sand a tank corps when Germany was treaty bound not to have one. Additionally, they were happy to partition Poland following the Nazi invasion. Stalin was a criminal and reaped what he sowed.
- the_af 4y agoThat's some revision of history. The Soviets didn't "enable" the Third Reich, since they knew well enough war with Nazi Germany was inevitable in the long run. Why they cooperated with each other is complex, and all powers back then engaged in some questionable strategies that, in hindsight, backfired. Poland is more complicated than a "partition". It's an inconvenient truth, now, to remember the Soviets did most of the fighting against Nazi Germany.
- ztrww 4y agoIt does not change the fact that the USSR and Nazi Germany were allies in 1939 and through 1940. They cooperated in Poland, signed a treaty to partition eastern Europe and were clearly considered as such when Britain and France were planning their intervention in Finland and bombing the oil fields in Azerbaijan. Yes it was short term alliance of convenience and both sides didn’t really trust each other but it does not change the fact that without material, political and military support from the USSR Germany’s position early in the war would have been much weaker.
- justsomehnguy 4y agoWhat is your opinion on Munich Agreement then?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pencilguin 4y agoThe key fact about US involvement is that most of it did not arrive until the Axis had been driven far back from its initial takings. Actually occupying territory was crucial, and as the Germans were driven back, transportation to the front got harder even as the Germans' transport task shrank. A great waste in the war was ineffective strategic ("Norden") bombing, using up untold bombers, crews, and ordinance. Another was expending skilled ex-pat pilots on direct combat while rotating experienced own pilots back to training.
- macanchex 4y agoThe historical consensus is that Germany had no way of ending the war on their own terms even without the aid. The impacts of Lend-Lease materialized mostly after 1942/Stalingrad. You might want to look into the history of Radio Free Europe and the sources they link to.
- chasil 4y agoI do read elsewhere that the participation of U.S. industrialists in the years before the war had profound impact on Soviet industrialization. "The Communist party translated and published [Fredrick W.] Taylor’s book The Principles of Scientific Management, and high authorities brought over Walter Polakov, an American follower of Henry L. Gantt, one of Taylor’s most fervent disciples, to provide a liaison with American scientific-management experts and to prepare production charts for the entire First Five-Year Plan... "By 1928, when the Soviets inaugurated the First Five-Year Plan, Henry Ford had become an even greater hero to the Soviets than Frederick Taylor. An emotional cult grew up around Ford’s methods and even his person. By 1925 his autobiography, My Life and Work, had had four printings in the Soviet Union, and one American in Russia reported that plant managers were studying Ford with as much enthusiasm as they had had for Lenin." https://www.americanheritage.com/how-america-helped-build-soviet-machine https://www.americanheritage.com/how-america-helped-build-so...
- ahartmetz 4y agoFunny thing, I watched a video about Russian command style yesterday. They are still trying to do scientific management in the army, which works horribly in the uncertainties of war, especially when lies flow up the chain of command.
- jcranmer 4y agoThere are two factors that I think cloud the story somewhat. The first is there's a time aspect to it. In 1941, after Operation Barbarossa, the Soviets shut down their factories and shipped them east, which meant there was about a 6 month period where production was more or less nonexistent. This is a critical juncture where resupply and refit essentially has to rely on Lend-Lease. The other factor is that Lend-Lease to the USSR was primarily not about the big headline weapons: Soviets were mostly using Soviet-designed and Soviet-built weapons to fight and win the war. Rather, it was about providing the equipment that keeps the infrastructure ticking over. The US wasn't building the tanks for the USSR as much as it was building the things that built the tanks.
- the_af 4y agoI think it's more or less understood today that while lend-lease was a big deal, Hitler had no real way of winning the war against the Soviet Union. It was logistically impossible. Even taking Moscow wouldn't have helped. Nazi Germany sealed its fate with Barbarossa. And it made it even worse by making it a war of extermination (unlike in other theaters of the war), a fight so barbaric and racially charged it forced a desperate defense on the Soviets, because surrender truly wasn't possible; and for the same reason, they ensured the revenge would be terrible.
- nl 4y ago> Even taking Moscow wouldn't have helped. I don't think that's widely accepted. There's a reasonable argument that Moscow formed such a communication and transport hub that losing it would have been a significant blow. If Moscow fell it seems likely Russia would have been cut off completely from the West and had to rely on Western aid over the Pacific to the East and then via undeveloped transport networks to new industrial bases. Unclear if this would have worked. Also worth noting that the loss of Moscow would have meant the loss of the manpower that was there defending it.
- the_af 4y agoI don't mean it wouldn't have been a huge loss. I mean that in a war of total extermination, the stakes are different. Remember that surrender wasn't an option. And in any case, Nazi Germany played their hands pretty badly with Moscow, too.
- hirundo 4y agoI had no idea how asymmetrical naval production was in the Pacific theater of WWII until I watched this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9ag2x3CS9M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9ag2x3CS9M With these numbers the relative merits of the actual warfighters had little effect on the outcome. The war with Japan was won in U.S. shipyards.
- throw0101c 4y ago> I had no idea how asymmetrical naval production was in the Pacific theater of WWII until I watched this: All production was asymmetrical: > The real measure of Japan as an industrial power in WW2 wasn't it's battleships, so much as it's lack of bulldozers [to, e.g., build airfields]. > A single field in England [see photo] in the summer of 1944 held more Allied earthmoving bulldozer capability than the Japanese built from 1937 - 1945. * https://twitter.com/TrentTelenko/status/1403756475995066373 https://twitter.com/TrentTelenko/status/1403756475995066373
- nl 4y ago> so much as it's lack of bulldozers [to, e.g., build airfields] The Japanese didn't need bulldozers. They had conscripted local labor and their planes could take off and land on dirt strips.
- throw0101c 4y agoThe Imperial Japanese Navy thought otherwise, given that they commissioned Komatsu to build a whole bunch: * https://www.kenkenkikki.jp/museum/bulldozer/e_bull1930-04.html https://www.kenkenkikki.jp/museum/bulldozer/e_bull1930-04.ht... * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Komatsu_Limited https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Komatsu_Limited
- Arrath 4y agohttp://www.combinedfleet.com/economic.htm http://www.combinedfleet.com/economic.htm has always been my go to for this aspect of the Pacific theater. > "The United States built more merchant shipping in the first four and a half months of 1943 than Japan put in the water in seven years."
- GiorgioG 4y agoGood thing the US has outsourced most industrial production overseas /s
- gramie 4y agoIn the podcast We Have Ways of Making You Talk, James Holland and Al Murray repeatedly make the point that differences in production of weapons, fuel, and everything else (including penicillin) made the outcome of the war inevitable. A very entertaining podcast, and well worth listening to!
- nl 4y agoIt's true that US production enabled the allies to win the war. But it's a mistake to think that the country with more economic resources will inevitably win. There's too many counter examples for that to be the case. Some include: Korean War 1967 Arab/Israeli war (Note that this was before mass support of Israel by the US) Vietnam War US/Taliban conflict
- yazantapuz 4y agoSoviet-Afghan War.
- beckingz 4y agoUS-Afghan War.
- nl 4y agoListed: > US/Taliban conflict
- nl 4y agoI deliberately left that out because it was to a large extent a proxy conflict once the US started delivering weapons to the Muhajirin in large numbers. (Or at least there's a reasonable argument for that case and I didn't want it to distract from the key point).
- robbiep 4y agoI heard this argument the other day around the Ukraine conflict being a US - Russia proxy war and the person promoting this view was vigorously rebutted - saying that it can’t be a proxy war because even though Ukraine is being significantly supplied by western allies (and Russia itself), it is Russia that is actually fighting. And that made sense to me definitionally. So I’ll make the same point here about the Soviet-Afghan war. Yes the US pumped in supplies, but it wasn’t a proxy war because one of the powers was actually one of the forces. So, I think I understand better now and maybe no historians will yell at us for mis describing proxy fights
- enkid 4y agoO'Brien's book of the same name is great. I've been following his commentary through the (most recent) Russian invasion of Ukraine, and it's been impressive. He's been consistently one of the voice saying this wasn't going to go well for Russia because they didn't have the logistics to support their aims.
- pencilguin 4y ago"No Simple Victory", by Norman Davies used material released only after the USSR fell in the early 90s.
- the_af 4y agoSame with David Glantz. Though unlike the author of this article, he acknowledges it was pretty much the Soviet Union which defeated Nazi Germany.
- pencilguin 4y agoTwo dictators' totalitarian despotries slugging it out while the US and Britain mostly watch, and chip in materiel when the marginally preferred one runs low; and then move in to mop up before western Europe gets engulfed by the winner, leaving eastern Europe to suffer under them for another almost 50 years. Promoting industrial production is a way of taking away credit from the millions of soldiers who actually went and died using it. The US did do a fair bit of naval work in the second half. And Russia was always openly appreciative of the Hormel SPAM.
- InTheArena 4y agoThe reason a euro-centric, Russia-centric view doesn’t work here is: 1( A huge portion of Russian casualties came not because of Nazi, but total and complete ineptitude on the part of the Russian commanders, and later in the war, casual disregard of strategy in favor of brute force, no matter the casualties. 2) it completely ignores the pacific theaters which the United States, Australia and New Zealand took on, but the rest of the allied and axis powers could not physically do anything in, until the very last minutes of the war. 3) Once you dig into the numbers, the American aid to both GB and Russia kept both countries in the war in 1942. the Americans where literally disassembling their power plants, steel mills, and entire classes of aircraft and shipping them to Russia. Sean McMeekin’s breaks the numbers down pretty well. Russias own industrial renaissance was enabled by the exporting of American industrialization and equipment.
- nl 4y agoTL;DR: "Amateurs talk strategy. Professionals talk logistics." - General Bradley. Quote from article: Overall, by 1944 the Axis could deploy only a small fraction of their potential military capacity into combat—it was being destroyed in a multi-layered campaign long before it could be used against their enemies. This was the true battlefield of WWII, a massive air-sea super battlefield that stretched for thousands of miles not only of traditional front but of depth and height
- AlbertCory 4y agoI was going to use that quote, but you beat me to it. The only thing I'd add to this article and the comments is: the Germans failed to realize that when they'd gone hundreds of miles into Russia over bad roads, with hostiles in their rear, they'd have a real serious problem supplying all those troops. The Russians call those "generals" of theirs General Distance (along with General Mud and General Winter).
- the_af 4y agoMy problem with these explanations is that they (much like TFA of this post) seem devised to downplay the sacrifice and tenacious resistance of the Soviet Army. "They didn't win the war, General Winter did!". But that's shortsighted. Jonathan House has an interesting lecture, avaliable on YouTube, refuting that narrow view, as well as others. He does make a big deal of how bad German logistics and planning for Barbarossa were -- he claims German logistics guys predicted accurately when Barbarossa would run out of steam, but were ignored -- but he also stresses how the Soviets resisted and ultimately outmaneuvered the Germans in WW2. This is a tough pill to swallow for the German-influenced American view that the Soviets were useless and won just because of large numbers, General Winter and of course American help.
- AlbertCory 4y agoI don't subscribe to the view that "They didn't win the war, General Winter did!" Maybe there are people who think the Soviets were useless, but I'm not one of them. We can't separate the problems any Russian invader would have from the tenacious resistance to this invasion. They were both essential. As was all the American help; particularly the trucks.
- throw0101c 4y agoFor some of the details on how production was organized and ramped up, see Freedom's forge: how American business produced victory in World War II by Arthur Herman: * https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13152691-freedom-s-forge https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13152691-freedom-s-forge It focuses on the efforts of two individuals: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_S._Knudsen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_S._Knudsen * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_J._Kaiser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_J._Kaiser Note that the books publication was sponsored/supported by the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), a very right-leaning, pro-business think tank: anytime the word 'union' comes up you can sense the author doing a *hock* *spit*.
- dragon-hn 4y agoI enjoyed this book, but the slant against unions was pretty off putting. I had no idea it was from AEI!
- throw0101c 4y ago> I had no idea it was from AEI! "From" may be a bit strong: in the acknowledgements the authors mentions that the AEI gave him a grant so that he could afford to spend the time doing research. The author is/was also a fellow at: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hudson_Institute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hudson_Institute This doesn't invalidate the outline of events that the book goes over, it just means that anything shown in a positive light may have been "too/more positive" and anything shown in a negative light could have been "too/more negative". Everyone has their biases.
- neural_thing 4y agoThat book tells some good stories and raises industrialist animal spirits, but IDK if it's the most objective book out there. Wrote a review of it here https://sergey.substack.com/p/forging-a-narrative https://sergey.substack.com/p/forging-a-narrative
- macanchex 4y agoThe article doesn't address Gosplan and the rapid industrialization of the Soviet Union.
- pfdietz 4y ago"Between 1940 and 1943, Britain tripled its war production; Germany and Russia doubled theirs; and Japan increased its war production fourfold. In that three-year period, the United States multiplied its war production by twenty-five times." Ian W. Toll, Pacific Crucible (2012)
- saghm 4y agoI'm not sure exactly how "war production" is defined, but I imagine that the war production of the US would not have been nearly as high as the other countries mentioned in 1940 given that the others had already been at war for a year, whereas the US wouldn't enter until 1942.
- helloworld11 4y agoGermany and Russia were already immensely increasing their war production and military preparedness before 1940, throughout the 1930s. These amounts need to be taken into account when comparing to the UK, which really only started to take war production seriously as the war was pretty much starting. The lead time of the former was larger, and the dates above paint a skewed picture. As for the USA, yes, holy shit, but it was also a country almost uniquely capable of achieving such a feat. Even more incredible is that it did that without even severely affecting the standard of living of its citizens, unlike the other countries, which all introduced very intense civil production rationing to pull off their more modest increases. In the case of the USSR, fighting for its life and already an economy that barely focused on civil well-being, the doubling of war production and associated war expenses caused a gigantic famine in the immediate post-war years, while also causing massive suffering during the war years, and this aside from the brutalities introduced by the German invasion.
- helloworld11 4y agoBy late 1944, U.S war production was so absurdly huge that Hitler (admittedly, hardly a man known by that point for a realistic worldview or an open mind) was flatly unable to believe it when told that the best estimates of U.S military aircraft production were somewhere in the neighborhood of 100,000 planes of all types for the year. Also, I strongly recommend a couple books here: First: "The Wages of Destruction: The Making and Breaking of the Nazi Economy" by Adam Tooze Second (truly a unique book that looks at the world's biggest war with a focus entirely on how people in different parts of the fighting countries ate and avoided starvation) "The Taste of War: World War Two and the Battle for Food " by Lizzie Collingham.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoWWII was won with American Steel, Russian Blood, and British Intelligence.
- the_af 4y agoI find this explanation doubtful. I mean, I agree that the focus on "big battles" is misleading, but any analysis that sidelines the men (and women) who shed their blood and did the fighting is naive. Or at worst, it tries to downplay who actually won the war, inconvenient as it may seem these days. The focus on materiel losses instead of human lives is puzzling.
- _carbyau_ 4y agoAs with everything in life, there can be many perspectives on things. The sacrifices made should be remembered. But lessons should be learned too. In this case, the focus on material losses tries to show lessons to be learned for this aspect of the war. They do not argue that all else should be forgotten.
- the_af 4y agoYes, of course. My opinion is that this article's take is trying to downplay the major contribution of the USSR in defeating Nazi Germany. It's not another take; they seem to imply it's the main take besides which all other contributions pale. And that's not true. Yes, economy and industrial output was a major deal and I don't think anybody [1] ignores this. But all of that would have been for naught if there hadn't been actual bodies on the ground, bleeding and defending or capturing ground. So it's true that Germany's war was doomed because its economy and industry couldn't compete (even with their vast use of slave labor) but still, had the Soviets not resisted them, they probably would have ended the war without catastrophic defeat but with a treaty, and possibly Hitler and some of the leadership would have survived. You know what seems petty? With the Cold War finally past us [and Putin's latest adventures notwithstanding] it's finally becoming understood [again, see 1] that the USSR was the major factor in Germany's defeat. It wasn't the Americans saving the day in Normandy or whatnot, pop culture notwithstanding. And so of course, some think tank will strive to prove that if America wasn't the decisive factor in battle, then battle wasn't all that important after all. I call this way of thinking "sour grapes". ---- [1] anybody outside mainstream pop culture, that is, which still claims America "won" WW2 and that the major battles were in North Africa and Normandy. And which is puzzled when the Soviet Union is mentioned at all, except they "know" thanks to fiction like Enemy at the Gates, that the Soviets major "contribution" to the war was commissars busily gunning down their own troops, and maybe a sniper or two.