7 ms·
Nobody makes you live in a bigger house or buy an expensive vehicle. I bought my truck used 30 years ago, and used it daily up until last year when it finally
by WalterBright 4y ago
Nobody makes you live in a bigger house or buy an expensive vehicle.
I bought my truck used 30 years ago, and used it daily up until last year when it finally expired. It cost me very little money.
> they just hoard the money and put it towards whatever satisfies their ego.
Your sentence contradicts itself.
BTW, some years ago a luxury tax was placed on yacht building, based on the notion that millionaires were jerks for spending their money on yachts. Then the local economy of one of the yacht building companies collapsed, because the millionaires went elsewhere to spend money building their yachts.
So the tax was rescinded.
- _carbyau_ 4y agoI don't gel with all of GP's views. Human-to-human competition is the driver of woe. But when it comes to: > they just hoard the money and put it towards whatever satisfies their ego. Not a contradiction. Billionaires have wealth that easily makes both sides of this statement true.
- WalterBright 4y agoOnly if you replace "and" with "or". Besides, nobody hoards wealth. It's all invested.
- mandmandam 4y agoYour just-so story is fine when thinking on a local and small-scale level. On a holistic level, "but the millionaires will move if we offend them by asking for taxes" is a race to the bottom; a tragedy of the commoners. It's long term utterly and unfathomably destructive. Also, yacht building is one of the least morally defensible industries on the planet. If the industry crashed to 1% of its current level it would be a net boon to the Earth and humanity. Your insistence that hoarding money and spending egotistically are mutually exclusive is kinda weird. Can you explain why it's not possible to do both? Are you just being unreasonably pedantic? ...
- nickpp 4y ago> is a race to the bottom; a tragedy of the commoners And here I was thinking it was kind of a free market of governments helping keep politicians honest and competitive. You know, less like the two wolves and a sheep voting what to have for dinner. > yacht building is one of the least morally defensible industries Please enlighten us: in what “moral” way do you think people should be allowed to spend their own money? There is a wonderful little story in Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged in which an highly productive essential worker kept receiving the smallest salary in the factory because his expenses (music records were his guilty pleasure) were deemed unimportant compared to the other workers' issues - until he just quit and the factory ran out of business.
- mandmandam 4y ago> Please enlighten us: in what “moral” way do you think people should be allowed to spend their own money? However they like - if it doesn't harm others. > There is a wonderful little story in Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged ... Ewww. So, tax-avoiding billionaires spending their ill gotten gains on giant sinkholes of money reminds you of a productive factory worker in a fictional story by a world renowned hypocrite? I'm very confused why you think there's a connection, but I'd encourage you to think a little deeper and broader.
- nickpp 4y ago> ill gotten gains That's an interesting mindset making you immediately assume that about billionaires. > Ewww > hypocrite Again, your mindset. How is it working for you? Are you happy with your life so far? > I'm very confused why you think there's a connection If you don't see the connection, it's you who should think deeper and broader.
- mandmandam 4y ago> That's an interesting mindset making you immediately assume that about billionaires. Yes. I do assume that. It's one of the most clear and unambiguous assumptions that could possibly be made. Ask Warren Buffett; he'll tell you - it's outright outrageous how little tax he pays. Ask Trump - he'll tell you all about how he navigates a rigged system, and how the entrenched political types will never allow that to change. Ask people who study inequality at the highest levels, like Rutger Bregman or Hans Rosling. It's basically impossible to become a billionaire without massive exploitation and damage. > Again, your mindset. How is it working for you? Are you happy with your life so far? Ayn Rand being a hypocrite has nothing to do with mindset; it's just a fact. You can look up the details of her life yourself, and how radically it diverged from her written work. Perhaps you've hung your conscience on her just-so stories, as many of the world's most destructive people have before you. > If you don't see the connection, it's you who should think deeper and broader. Happy to - if you can explain to me how underpaying a productive factory worker is like preventing a billionaire buying a yacht. Because it seems to me that you're making the comparison without accounting for scale, without accounting for negative externalities, and without an ounce of discernment of your own. Please, explain it to me - I can be slow.