3 ms·
The Roman Catholic Church openly claims to be the one true religion, and that all other religions might have elements of the truth, but not the fullness of the
by silent_cal 4y ago
The Roman Catholic Church openly claims to be the one true religion, and that all other religions might have elements of the truth, but not the fullness of the Truth. So Catholicism doesn't fit into this framework.
- tinco 4y agoWhy would it not fit in this framework because of something they claim?
- silent_cal 4y agoBecause the framework supposes that the claims of each religion are basically the same, and Roman Catholicism explicitly rejects this.
- tinco 4y agoYes, that they reject the framework doesn't really matter does it?
- silent_cal 4y agoOf course it does, it makes it incompatible. If one claim explicitly rejects another claim, then the two claims aren't compatible.
- tinco 4y agoThe claims inside the framework don't need to be compatible, they're just religions.
- silent_cal 4y agoSo none of the exclusive claims of any religion to have the full truth are true, but your personal opinion about all of them is fully true? Your arrogance is unbearable.
- tinco 4y agoUm no. I am saying one of those claims might be true. I'm trying to make a logical argument about their commonality, not give a personal opinion.