3 ms·
Has anybody ever paid reparations to anybody? Inter-Generational debt just isn’t a thing.
by rayiner 4y ago
Has anybody ever paid reparations to anybody? Inter-Generational debt just isn’t a thing.
- skyyler 4y agoThis kind of stuff can easily be searched for. Here's a low-mid quality article: https://www.vox.com/2014/5/23/5741352/six-times-victims-have-received-reparations-including-four-in-the-us https://www.vox.com/2014/5/23/5741352/six-times-victims-have...
- akavi 4y agoAll but the last of those examples only paid out to the living survivors of the atrocity, and the last only earmarked 5% for descendants. So it does seem that inter-generational reparations are indeed very rare.
- skyyler 4y ago>$10 million out of court settlement with the victims and their families >$2.4 million today would be set aside to compensate the 11 or so remaining survivors of the incident, $800,000 to compensate those who were forced to flee the town, and $160,000 would go to college scholarships primarily aimed at descendants. Inter-generational reparations exist explicitly in two of the six examples in that article. Japanese interns that didn't collect their payment from the US left it up to their heirs to collect it, so I'll even add that as a technicality of inter-generational reparations. Also I'm rather sure Israel is still getting payments for what happened in the 1940s... But I could be wrong there. Inter-generational reparations are indeed rare if you don't look very hard for examples of it happening.
- rayiner 4y agoNow compare that to all the instances where people committed atrocities against other people. It seems like you’re talking about something vanishingly rare.
- jacobr1 4y agoWar reparations from the conquered/losing side appear in history now and then.
- zasdffaa 4y agoAssuming your reparations claim was correct, injustice becomes ok if it happens often enough.
- rayiner 4y agoWho said that? Stuff can be “not okay” but also “not the problem of anyone currently alive.” We have a concept of a statute of limitations in law, for example.
- bilbo0s 4y agoJust being pedantic here, but there's not limitation on, say, homicide. Whether or not there is a statute of limitations is generally dependent on the severity of the offense. But again, just a nit-pick. To my mind, the mistake is in paying any sort of reparations to anyone, ever. As a nation state, unfortunately, some things you have to go all in on. Not paying reparations is one of those things. I am OK with forcing state and local governments to pay out for egregious acts taken in explicit contravention of Constitutional rights. But that's because as a nation state we should also go all in on defending the constitutional rights of our citizens. I know that's talking out of both sides of my mouth, but the reality is that nation states can incur far larger obligations than state and local governments can. A nation state could end up with an obligation that realistically simply can't be paid.
- jacobr1 4y ago> Just being pedantic here, but there's not limitation on, say, homicide. There is though ... the lifetime of perpetrator.
- rhino369 4y ago>Just being pedantic here, but there's not limitation on, say, homicide. Right, but sons aren't held responsible for their father's crimes. And while the Father's estate can be liable for wrongful death, that is generally limited in time. Certainly, you can't just go after all descendants decades later. It's not just a slippery slope, but fair compensation is essentially impossible to determine. The average Japanese America is far richer than the average American--significantly so. Should you discount for that? Doesn't seem fair to penalize them for being successful. But the other hand, maybe that shows that the lasting harm wasn't that bad. A lot easier to just let the past be the past and to police our actions going forward.
- sorokod 4y agoYes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reparations_Agreement_between_Israel_and_the_Federal_Republic_of_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reparations_Agreement_between_...