5 ms·
Why Elizabeth Holmes thinks she shouldn’t go to prison
- Ambolia 4y agoThis reads like her being a narcissist and having "main character symptom", which I assume most people who think they are above the law have to some degree unless it's passional crimes. Why they think this is a good defense, that is the interesting part.
- Apocryphon 4y agoIt also sounds very on-brand for Holmes, and perhaps speaks to how much control she’s exercising over her own defense team if they’re operating in her style.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoCould they be just so sick of her petulant entitled craziness?
- killingtime74 4y agoSorry I'm not defending Holmes but your attorneys literally have to follow your instructions or quit that is their job. Also if you quit you cannot say why. Trust me they know it's a bad idea. They see worse things everyday
- anotherman554 4y agoIf you look at the American Bar Association model rules they say "a lawyer shall abide by a client's decisions concerning the objectives of representation and, as required by Rule 1.4, shall consult with the client as to the means by which they are to be pursued. " This means there are situations where the attorney does not have to follow the client's instructions. The client determines the objectives and how to plead, but this doesn't mean the attorney is obligated to listen to the client's order about everything.
- killingtime74 4y agoYes that is looking at one rule in isolation. I am a lawyer and in ethics classes they expand on many rules and many situations in detail. Some other conflicting interests include duties to the court and legal professional privilege. Example client can tell you to do something that is against the interests of the administration of justice. when they insist you have to resign.
- avgDev 4y agoWow. So, the judge should forget about all the people who she fired and tried to silence who told her, "hey this is impossible". Pathetic. She needs prison time. We don't ask teenagers who commit serious crimes if they are immature, poor or were influenced by someone else.
- rendall 4y ago> "The document is laid out in sections that sound like something a high schooler would write on their college application..." I really miss the days when journalists would treat us readers as adults with the capacity to come to our own decisions about how to interpret a set of facts, rather than their feeling the need to drop clues like this so that we shall be lead carefully and safely to the proper conclusions. We know it's a weak defense. We don't need journalists to spell it out for us. Talk about sounding like a high-school essay. This sounds so much more professional, and skips the editorializing. The document includes sections such as “Deep Interest in Making the World a Better Place” and “Positive Impact on Others.” It opens with the hope that it will encourage the judge to “examine Ms. Holmes the human being” before bringing down the hammer.
- cashsterling 4y agoFrom all that I have read and understood... seems like Holmes is a full-tilt narcissist. I worked at a startup for a narcissist CEO (direct report) and some of the things I learned are: (1) you can't trust anything they say... and they will try to entirely rewrite history if you allow them, (2) they do NOT care about anyone that is not them... they will feign caring if they realize they need you, (3) they will use, discard, destroy anyone at anytime if it furthers their interest, (4) they are amazingly good at manipulating others, (5) when narcissist fuck up they really go "all out"... beyond mind boggling. I'm not 100% sure Holmes is a narcissist, but if she is... the court would be foolish if they listen to anything her defense may say at this point.