7 ms·
A new website backed by Al Gore tracks big polluters by name
- jarbus 4y agoI've always wondered if it would be possible to humiliate companies/elites into changing their behavior by maintaining well-publicied and well-informed directories of the most harmful entities to society
- mvdwoord 4y agoDefine harmful.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoCompanies that directly or indirectly most contribute to GHG, in _all_ their operations, including suppliers, manufacturing, logistics.
- socialismisok 4y agoWe can start with: is the top N% of pollution generators, independently tracking particulates, greenhouse gasses, plastic waste, pfas, fly ash, water pollutants, etc. Make N% approximately 10%. You've then got a pretty good start on "harmful".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jeffbee 4y agoThe "elites" in this situation are hundreds of millions of Americans driving trucks through the drive-thru at Hardees. It's not three guys you can browbeat into submission. It's an entire broken culture.
- mistrial9 4y agonice rant but no -- the data on the site shows that individual transportation is NOT at the top of emitters; rather it is industrial infrastructure that creates fuels and industrial infrastructure using fuels for heavy materials. https://climatetrace.org/explore https://climatetrace.org/explore
- gruez 4y agoGuess what "industrial infrastructure that creates fuels and industrial infrastructure using fuels for heavy materials" is overwhelmingly used for? Hint, it's not for mega yachts and Musk/Bezos rockets.
- dfxm12 4y agoEven if this was the only/biggest source, you can browbeat the automotive industry to stop making so many heavy, gas guzzling vehicles. You can browbeat politicians into prioritizing public transportation & vehicle regulations over lobbying efforts from the automotive industry. Our "broken culture" isn't innate in us, it was designed.
- bombcar 4y agoThe US government could overturn the "pickup war" instantly - just make vehicles under a certain (small) size entirely tax-free in various ways. The market would adapt quite quickly.
- jeffbee 4y agoOr states can adopt the minor and simple policies of California, where incrementally higher registration fees by weight, commercial registration for all pickups, and fuel taxes only slightly higher than other states and nowhere near as high as other developed nations have led to a private vehicle fleet with no trucks among the top-selling vehicles.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoAs 12 states have done: https://mde.maryland.gov/programs/air/mobilesources/pages/states.aspx https://mde.maryland.gov/programs/air/mobilesources/pages/st... No surprises, it's the "states you'd actually want to live in" overrepresented as per usual.
- jeffbee 4y agoThat's not even one of the measures that I mentioned, but yes!
- kcplate 4y agoIt most certainly is the fault of a bunch of blue collar working stiffs grabbing a sausage biscuit and a coffee on the way to a job that a bunch of sanctimonious SWEs rely on every day in a thousand different ways, but pretend like are unimportant dinosaurs in a digital world. I mean, all that electricity and raw materials mined for those 15 billion computing devices running all the shite social media code that SV SWEs have foisted upon the world doesn’t have any impact at all…it’s just that poor bastard in his F150 and his damned sandwich.
- gruez 4y agoElites: I think you're overestimating how much of a contribution "elites" add to co2 consumption. They might emit disproportionately higher co2 than the median citizen, but that's canceled out by the fact that they're so few of them. Companies: Works great in theory[1], not so well in practice[2]. Turns out most people only pay lip service to climate change/environment, and scatter at the prospect of paying out of pocket for it. [1] https://climatecommunication.yale.edu/visualizations-data/ycom-us-2018/ https://climatecommunication.yale.edu/visualizations-data/yc... [2] https://ballotpedia.org/Washington_Initiative_1631,_Carbon_Emissions_Fee_Measure_(2018) https://ballotpedia.org/Washington_Initiative_1631,_Carbon_E...
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoInterestingly, Washington State passed a carbon fee proposal that's basically the same as that, shortly after. It's a widely used tool, because it's efficient and therefore cheap. It's only really the US that lags on putting a price on emissions. Mostly because their legislation mechanisms are in the pocket of big oil.
- gruez 4y ago>Interestingly, Washington State passed a carbon fee proposal that's basically the same as that, shortly after Source? It took me a few minutes to find what the piece of legislation was called (Climate Commitment Act), but it's surprisingly hard to find what the bill actually does. The first result I found was a website from the state of washington[1], which only contains vague statements like "A market-based solution" and "Cleaner air for overburdened communities", without actual concrete measures. The second result from washington state university[2] isn't much better. It seems like the bill institutes some sort of cap and trade system with details to be hammered out later, which isn't the same as a straight carbon tax (as proposed in the ballot measure) and the financial impact is much less clear. I suspect the latter is why it was passed at all. [1] https://ecology.wa.gov/Air-Climate/Climate-Commitment-Act https://ecology.wa.gov/Air-Climate/Climate-Commitment-Act [2] https://csanr.wsu.edu/the-climate-commitment-act-is-coming/ https://csanr.wsu.edu/the-climate-commitment-act-is-coming/
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoTerrible headline but very interesting tech. AI and satelites to generate independant GHG monitoring systems, so you can check on countries you distrust or who don't release any data. The big reveal seems to be oil and gas production underestimating their contribution, which should have interesting repurcussions. I submitted the Press Release direct from the website with the data which has more on their methodology here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33587747 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33587747
- Y-bar 4y ago> Terrible headline It made sense to me, I think you read the headline like the abbreviation "AI" and not like name "AL" maybe?
- DoingIsLearning 4y agohttps://climatetrace.org/map https://climatetrace.org/map Saved you a click. Looking at Europe it is absolutely bewildering how DRAX stands out like a sore thumb. Absolutely criminal that that thing hasn't been shut down yet. Even more criminal that they get away with receiving 'green' funding. Also we in the EU should make a particularly large effort in funding the replacement of Coal plants in Poland. Insane how much they disproportionately contribute to emissions.
- ginko 4y ago>This tool is not available in mobile version, please switch to desktop. ..despite opening this on my desktop. I guess my browser window is taller than it is wide, but that doesn't make it a mobile browser.
- parski 4y agoWe should be doing everything in our power to close Drax, Polish coal plants and Norwegian oil fields in the North Sea. Instead we're subsidizing fossil fuels and filling up Putin's warchest along with our filthy cars. [0] [0]: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-022-01122-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-022-01122-6
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoPoles want to build nuclear power plants instead, Germans want to sue them for it. Really, you can't make this up. https://rmx.news/poland/german-minister-threatens-to-use-legal-tools-against-poland-for-developing-nuclear-energy/ https://rmx.news/poland/german-minister-threatens-to-use-leg...
- capableweb 4y agoOff-topic but does anyone have any guess to what map projection they are using?
- RugnirViking 4y agolooks like gall-peters to my eye
- stuckinhell 4y agoIf it doesn't track celebrities with their excess co2, I can't trust it.
- socialismisok 4y agoDo you have examples of celebrities rising to even a fractional percent of industry?
- stuckinhell 4y agohttps://highxtar.com/top-10-celebrities-who-pollute-the-most-with-their-private-jets/ https://highxtar.com/top-10-celebrities-who-pollute-the-most... Taylor Swift | 8.293,54 tonnes of CO2
- elil17 4y agoThose emissions would mostly be counted in the airports on this map.
- bombcar 4y agoThis is one of the things you have to be careful with data like this - pollution can be counted multiple times, especially if you are comparing different datasets.
- dymk 4y agoIs that a lot or a little compared to a high polluting company?
- elil17 4y agoIt's about 1/7,000,000 of global emissions. Less than any country I believe (except maybe Vatican City, but that's not listed on this map). Larger than many small towns and airports.
- parski 4y agoWould be cool to see how much of China's pollution is exported to other countries. In other words, how much of their pollution is for domestic activity and how much is for making stuff that we in the west consume.
- gruez 4y ago>In other words, how much of their pollution is for domestic activity and how much is for making stuff that we in the west consume. It's about 7.7%. In other words, if we factor in our imports, our co2 emissions would be 7.7% higher than our territorial emissions. https://ourworldindata.org/consumption-based-co2 https://ourworldindata.org/consumption-based-co2
- eastbound 4y agoSeems bewildering. Including transport? So, buying tons of consumerism stuff from China with awful pollution policies plus transport, only impacts for 7.7% of our emissions if we repatriated it here with China’s level of pollution? That’s can’t be right.
- gruez 4y agoThat's because you're only one side of the equation (ie. imports). 7.7% is the net effect, so you have to consider the other side (exports) as well. If each american is importing 5 co2e of cheap plastic shit from china, but you're also exporting 5 co2e of high tech shit to china, then the net result is 0.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoWhen you break it down most of the emission you are directly responsible for are 1) Energy production from Coal/Gas (household/office Heating, AC, electricity) 2) Road transport. [0] IMO all this discussion about meat consumption and trinkets from China distracts from the big picture. Which is: - We need to find a way to get rid of Coal/Gas energy production (i.e. solve the whole issue of Renewables intermitency). - We need to solve the problem of road transport without ICEs. The main barrier for those two is policy and funding. It has bugger all to do with consumer behaviour. Which is not to say that we shouldn't all curb individual GHG emissions. [0] https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2020/09/Emissions-by-sector-%E2%80%93-pie-charts.png https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2020/09/Emissions-by-sect...
- CWuestefeld 4y agoHow does the distribution actually break down? Are a smallish number of bigtime distinct sources the large portion of the problem? I don't really know, but my intuition is that it's more of a long tail thing, with many many players contributing similarly.
- dan_mctree 4y agoFrom what I can tell on the map, it indeed seems quite a heavy long tail, with what was surprising to me, particularly heavy emissions from midsized industrial sites. The top 50 emitters make up about 4% of the total, which is a lot, but perhaps not as much as you might think. They largely seem to consist of oil and gas fields. I would've expected the large cities, including the smaller companies without individual mentions within to form the bulk of emissions. However, you see things like megacities like London with only 4.4Mt of co2 emissions, while there's tons of random cement factories around with 1Mt of co2 emissions. Power plants also make up less of the emissions than I expected, except for those in China, which seem less efficient than those in the west (except you DRAX and Belchatow) It looks like if we found ways to significantly reduce emissions of: oil/gas fields, cement plants, steel plant, coal mines, airports and Chinese power plants, that'd make a huge impact.
- jeffbee 4y agoI was prepared with all the skepticism I can muster, but I am pleasantly surprised. It correctly identifies the streets of Los Angeles as a top-20 emitter. Really getting to the heart of things, the opposite of "100 corporations cause climate change" B.S.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- photochemsyn 4y agoThis is mostly just political posturing on the part of the Democratic Party, which as far as I can tell is not any more interested in halting US fossil fuel production than the Republican party is. In fact, not a single country with large oil and gas reserves and an active export industry wants to see their revenue collapse due to something like an international ban on the trade in fossil fuels - and this is true regardless of their political ideology, i.e. capitalism vs socialism or authoritarian theocracy or whatever. Venezuela, the United States, Norway, Iran, Russia, Saudi & UAE, etc. all want to keep running their export programs for the next three decades at least. I mean, in the USA the Obama Administration oversaw the fracking boom for eight years and now that's the basis of the LNG exports to Europe. As far as tracking the big polluters, that's more misdirection. Yes, it'd be nice if oil refineries were run tightly enough that they had no local emissions, but those refined products are all going into the fuel tanks of jet planes, ships, trucks, power plants and personal vehicles, from whene they will be combusted to CO2 and injected into the atmosphere, so does it really matter where the emissions take place? This is not rocket science, just basic accounting. The end result is the same, here's a model of the yearly cycle: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1SgmFa0r04 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x1SgmFa0r04 If countries had really wanted to slow fossil-fueled global warming, they'd have started a 1% per year replacement program (renewables for fossil fuels) in the 1980s, and we'd be at a ~40% renewable ~60% fossil energy mix by now (at least). As it stands today, every single fossil fuel company and nation-state producer is looking to maintain current production levels for the next 30 years, if they can manage it. Enough with the hypocrisy and two-faced posturing at these 'global climate meetups', already. Finally, this 'hope' business is ridiculous. The tipping point has come and gone, there are numerous global carbon models and observational data showing that even with 100% renewables tomorrow, warming will steadily continue due to permafrost melt and carbon outgassing from marine sediments. The last time CO2 levels were this high was in the Pliocene, ~2-5 million years ago, and that's where the climate is heading. Hence, human civilization will just have to adapt to these new conditions, which will be difficult and expensive and disruptive. However, since noticeable changes in climate (i.e. clearly distinguishable from the noise in the data) only appear on a ~10 year running average, this could be accomplished, with massive infrastructure projects. However, making efforts to adapt to new conditions would require admitting that fossil fuels drive global warming, which would create more pressure to switch to renewables, and that would be resisted by entrenched economic interests... sort of a Catch-22 situation.
- hirundo 4y agoPollution has costs and benefits. This focuses on the costs, which is fine and useful. But what would a map look like that attempted to show both sides of the equation? Which polluters emit least per arbitrary-unit-of-human-flourishing? I don't know how to gather that data, so I don't know how to make that map. But it would display very differently a power plant that is mining for bitcoin with one that is keeping a lot of people from freezing in a region disrupted by war.
- mmcgaha 4y agoI only clicked on 15 or so from the areas that I have lived but they were all airports and land fills. That tells me that our personal consumption is a big problem and we as individuals can make a difference. Quick disclaimer though I have always thought that pollution is more an individual consumption problem so I am biased to that conclusion.
- dimitrios1 4y agoThis is always going to be the case. Corporations produce more to meet demands of consumers. If there was no demand, there would be no production and hence no subsequent pollution (if that consumption results in pollution). Why do your power plants need to generate more power? Because we need more power now since more of us have more gadgets and bullshit to power. Why does your local bottling company use so much plastic bottles? Because we think it's a genius idea to drink so much water out of single use plastic bottles. I could think of hundreds of examples, but yes, we drive so much more than we think. Everything is connected in a web of relationships. We blame the big corporations so much, but at the end of the day the [overwhelming majority of ] corporations are there because there are individuals giving them dollars. The problem, however, is this is effectively a truism, and doesn't really help to solve much in the immediate term. It takes generations to shape consumer habits.
- DoingIsLearning 4y ago> Corporations produce more to meet demands of consumers. Let me rephrase: Corporations produce more to meet demands of consumers....However corporations maximize GHG emissions in order to deliver at a lower cost and maximize their revenue. Corporations are continually allowed to externalize production costs with environmental impact because no one is stopping them from doing so either by regulation or supply-side shortage. The ability to deliver goods is dissociable from GHG emissions. This whole spin of making companies somehow victims of consumers is corporate bullshit.
- dimitrios1 4y agoNobody said victims, that's your own lens coming into play there. Everyone wants cheap, fast, convenient, and quick. Everyone. I suppose if you don't think this plays into corporate behavior then we don't have much of a chance of discussion here. Perhaps I misspoke by saying consumers, what I should say is, more broadly, people. Corporations get away with it because politicians, local or otherwise, don't hold them accountable, because the consumers (people) don't vote people in that will, or vote the people out that are not. For what reasons? Laziness? Too busy being poor (yes definitely some of this)? Indifference? Imperfect information? A little bit of this and that? God only knows. We can only presume. Either way, you cannot escape the web of relationships we all live in on this earth is my broader point.
- CH1jZci6jV 4y agoThe largest polluter in the world is the U.S. Government. Tracking ships and whatever is all fine but there is a reason why the U.S. Gov ops itself out of every piece of climate legislation. The insane pollution I saw in the military would send a whole lot of people to jail if a company did them.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoAre you prepared to deal with the effects if the US Military stopped all operations? I wonder what the climate impact would be?
- feet 4y agoOr the military could just act more responsibly when it comes to emissions?
- akagusu 4y agoWe need more sites like this to track slavery, child labor, employee abuse, financial fraud and more.
- xnx 4y agoA different list with similar meaning: https://www.forbes.com/billionaires/ https://www.forbes.com/billionaires/
- boplicity 4y agoI imagine a dystopian future where military might from a world superpower is deployed against oil extracting infrastructure -- this happening, of course, after such a superpower has mostly transitioned away from fossil fuel use. This, of course, is just imagination in my head, but it strikes me as somewhat possible. The future is bleak -- and it's easy to imagine drastic choices being made in a bleak future. In this context, this website almost looks like a target list for such a military endeavour. This behavior, of course, would result in severe famine for those still dependent on fossil fuels.
- DFHippie 4y agoOne can imagine all sorts of dystopian futures. Here's a much more realistic one: the climate goes to hell and there is war, famine, and mass extinction. Democratic governments are replaced with authoritarian governments in elections because populaces want protection from their neighbors and are willing to sacrifice their autonomy to someone who promises to shoot their enemies. International cooperation breaks down. Imagining the world not doing anything about climate change is a lot easier than imagining them doing too much. We can already see the former.
- dadjoker 4y agoI wonder if it tracks his own carbon footprint between his mansion and his private jet-setting.
- datavirtue 4y agoProbably not something he could have done 30 years ago (campaign financing woulddry up) but this is a looong time coming.
- ulnarkressty 4y agoI wish the mobility company headquarters would also be named, even though it would amount to double counting. For example the entire fleet of VW group emitted 364MtCO2[0] in 2019 which is equivalent to the entire country of Mexico[1] with some change. [0] - https://www.volkswagen-planet-better.com/en/mission.html https://www.volkswagen-planet-better.com/en/mission.html [1] - https://www.statista.com/statistics/270499/co2-emissions-in-selected-countries/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/270499/co2-emissions-in-...
- lakomen 4y agoThis tool is not available in mobile version, please switch to desktop. Just let me view it regardless?
- CobaltFire 4y agoInterestingly airports are listed, but military airfields are not. I know they are much harder to track, but I wonder how MCAS Miramar + NAS North Island + the LCAC's at Camp Pendleton contribute in comparison to SAN. Looking at about 150gph for H-60's, 1500gph for F-35's, and 1000gph for LCACs. I know the H-60 squadrons alone will push something north of 15k flight hours locally per year (maybe a lot more; I don't keep up on the numbers), and the LCACs push a couple thousand (again, not 100% sure). I have no idea on the F-35's. I can say that one running joke in the Navy that is actually true is that the fighters dump more fuel making trap weight than the helo's burn. That can't be good for the ocean either.
- JSON_bourne 4y agoFinally, the Al Gore Rithm we've been searching for
- RickJWagner 4y agoToo high-level. It needs to track individuals with multiple large, energy-sucking houses. Also, talking heads that travel by private jet.