3 ms·
If you have 2 self-reported studies 5/10 years apart, it's still valid to compare them. The article even discusses the possibility of changes in self-reporting
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
If you have 2 self-reported studies 5/10 years apart, it's still valid to compare them.
The article even discusses the possibility of changes in self-reporting behavior, e.g. that young people today are more comfortable labelling themselves as asexual than they were 15 years ago.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoHow so? Social norms change. White-lie X 10 years ago might be replaced with White-lie Y today. That doesn't make comparing X to Y valid. As mentioned, before you do the comparison, you *must* make an effort to understand the changing social norms and how that might impact a *known* flawed data source (i.e., self reported). Then once you come up with a theory about the impact of social norms, you can try to test your theory... Condom sales? Up or down? Other birth control prescriptions, up or down? STDs, up or down? Preg-test sales, up or down? What about associated / related Google search data*? The bottom line...accepting self-reported data at face value is a true fool's errand. The Science is clear on this. Let's just leave it at that for today. * "Everybody Lies: Big Data, New Data, and what the internet can tell us about who we really are" by Seth Stephens-Davidowitz (a Harvard-trained economist, former Google data scientist) http://sethsd.com/everybodylies/ http://sethsd.com/everybodylies/