6 ms·
Does anyone know what regulatory / legal hurdles they may be facing? Relevant Wikipedia article [0] is strangely silent on the topic, though my guess would be,
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
Does anyone know what regulatory / legal hurdles they may be facing? Relevant Wikipedia article [0] is strangely silent on the topic, though my guess would be, this might be classified as military technology.
--
[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_radar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_radar
- dmw_ng 4y agoITAR according to Twitter https://twitter.com/vk5qi/status/1591628725141270528 https://twitter.com/vk5qi/status/1591628725141270528 https://spectrum.ieee.org/passive-radar-with-sdr https://spectrum.ieee.org/passive-radar-with-sdr
- sneak 4y agoCould it be time for another Bernstein v US sort of case? The idea that source code publication can be restricted (prior restraint) by classifying it as “arms” seems like an attempt at an end run around the bill of rights.
- rtpg 4y agoWe spent a lot of years with export controls on a lot of things, and continue to have them on many pieces of software. Trying to do legal jujitsu to say “the code is speech”, especially given SCOTUSs current makeup, and the context of this being components of literal weapons systems… you’re not gonna get far IMO
- netr0ute 4y agoThis doesn't hold up if the software is baked into things that are undoubtedly protected by the 1st Amendment. What's going to happen if a music album uses ITAR technology?
- some_random 4y agoHow is a music album free speechier than a github repo?
- netr0ute 4y agoMusic has always been protected from the beginning of the Constitution and there have been zero (0) efforts to prevent its protection, while online code repos have only existed for about 30 years and don't have that same cachet yet.
- DaiPlusPlus 4y ago> Music has always been protected from the beginning of the Constitution and there have been zero (0) efforts to prevent its protection Tipper Gore?
- netr0ute 4y agoThe music labels never actually got rid of anything in a technical sense, only added information in the form of a sticker.
- dandelany 4y agoThis is a strange legal take. There is nothing about music that makes it special in the eyes of the law, it is speech like any other, subject to the same protections and restrictions as publishing a book. If you release an album containing nuclear secrets on Spotify, an injunction, removal and arrest will follow.
- netr0ute 4y agoWe don't actually know that this is true, because if you don't take the law literally like a lot of coders do, then that scenario isn't known to be possible because the format is a more explicit from of protected speech
- 4y ago
- wnoise 4y agoThat just means it's covered by both the first and second amendments.
- michaelt 4y agoThe krakensdr folks could take this fight for code-as-free-speech all the way to the supreme court. Or they could delete the code, spend their time engineering instead of lawyering, secure in the knowledge a copy of the code is almost certain to end up hosted somewhere outside the US anyway.
- q-big 4y agoSince the code is open source, any other person could publish the latest code dump as a book and attempt to go with the "free speech" arguments through the courts.
- bananapub 4y agoLots of speech is illegal or defacto illegal in the US , though, why would this particular one get undone?
- irjustin 4y agoThis is an interesting concept and thanks for bringing it to my attention. I wasn't aware of the case. My take is it will be significantly more nuanced if it goes to a fight. Bernstein v US is too blanket of a ruling to say "all code is 100% protected under free speech". It's like trying to argue "all speech is protected under free speech" - this is a gross misunderstanding. There are clear examples of things you cannot freely say - one of them being classified information[0]. Otherwise Snowden wouldn't have to fear anything (he absolutely does). Like wise, saying all code is free speech is too obtuse. If my code was open source "puts classified_information_str" I'd be in lots of trouble. Where this falls isn't up to me to decide - I'm not smart enough, but it's just not so clear cut. [0] https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/859/classified-documents https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/859/classified-...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- butlerm 4y agoThere is (generally speaking) no prior restraint against publishing classified information in the United States. Snowden is in trouble for disclosing classified information that he didn't have a right to disclose by virtue of his employment. Anyone not so restricted can (generally speaking) publish any classified information they get a hold of, although they might be strongly discouraged from doing so for a variety of reasons. It is like the situation with trade secrets - anyone can publish trade secrets except those who have a duty not to disclose them, and often they can as well once the secret becomes public knowledge. There are, however, statutory exceptions for national defense information like plans to a military base or plans and specifications for certain weapons. In those cases it doesn't matter how you came into possession of the related documents you can't legally publish it anyway.
- CuriousCosmic 4y agoTo add onto this, when it comes to "classified" information, it generally falls into two types: 1. Actual classified information (Secret, TS, SCI, SAP). This information is classified by people with clearances according to a set of guidelines and all information has to be more or less manually classified. If you were to independently produce this information (without knowledge or information from the classified project), you are legally in the clear to publish. 2. Restricted information (RD, FRD, SNM). Unlike with classified information, what is or isn't considered restricted is regulated by the DOE. Because of this, information can be "restricted at inception" which prevents it from being published regardless of how it was obtained or produced. Point being that just because information isn't classified and you may have acquired it through independent means, you can still be restricted from sharing it because the US has deemed it "inherently dangerous" to national security. Note: I don't think the code in question could by any stretch be considered RD or FRD.
- jakzurr 4y agoAnother interesting link: https://www.crowdsupply.com/krakenrf/krakensdr https://www.crowdsupply.com/krakenrf/krakensdr
- eternalban 4y agoVery informative. Thanks. [apparently can't up vote]
- ksidudwbw 4y agoWhy would you make something like this when you know all these open source tools are used by authoritarian governments...
- pythonguython 4y agoBecause people enjoy tinkering with radio and these sorts of projects have become possible in the amateur space now that high quality Radio hardware is so cheap. I doubt the people who work on this have nefarious intent.
- Sporktacular 4y agoWhy would you allow the production of smartphones knowing they are used by authoritarian governments.
- dzhiurgis 4y agoSmartphones are super useful for everyone, radar not so much. That said would be nice to someone like google just added a layer on google maps of all objects you can track. There are companies that do all sort of tracking, just not as cheaply as this.
- mcbits 4y agoAt a minimum, passive radar could be useful to augment more conventional types of cameras in a home security system, especially for someone with acres of land with a lot of trees, etc.
- NavinF 4y agoI'm pretty sure he asked because it's not uncommon to see mmwave radar on flagship smartphones, especially on devices that don't have lidar. Many cars also have radar for parking assist or automatic parking.
- Sporktacular 4y agoNo one knew how personally useful radio transmission could be when it was in the exclusive domain of inventors and governments. Radar is not very personally useful yet. It has lots of non-military and non-professional applications that will open up as it becomes cheaper and more accessible. Restricting code like this will make zero difference to governments or any motivated, well funded, capable group. It just hampers the rest of us.
- graderjs 4y agoWhen your open-source project accidentally reinvents classified military technology? Awkward...
- ISL 4y agoIt need not be classified to fall under ITAR.
- moffkalast 4y agoThat's sounds like nonsense. For transmitting signals I can understand that there needs to be some kind of order so the various low throughput bands can remain usable, but this is just receiving what anyone can read with an antenna and processing it a bit.
- nimish 4y agoITAR limits all kinds of things mostly arbitrarily. Fast high resolution ADCs, which anyone can simulate using fast enough low res sampling (any serdes for modern buses) and some math. Thermal cameras can be sold up to a certain refresh rate but not higher. It’s not really about the tech so much as it is about making it difficult and annoying to work around.
- jasonladuke0311 4y ago> ITAR limits all kinds of things mostly arbitrarily. Yep and it’s incredibly broad. I used to work in one of those shooting ranges in Vegas where tourists go to shoot machine guns. We were told that anything more than “barrel pointed this way, this is the trigger” with a foreign national (which were a LOT of customers) could be construed as “training” and thus a potential ITAR violation.