4 ms·
> FWIW, I still think cryptocurrencies will outlast all existing government-backed fiat currencies. The difference is that I don’t think it’s going to happen on
by astrange 4y ago
> FWIW, I still think cryptocurrencies will outlast all existing government-backed fiat currencies. The difference is that I don’t think it’s going to happen on any predictable timeframe.
Nothing about this prediction gives Bitcoin any value. If you/early buyers hoard it all, that means starting a new chain is less effort than buying it from you. There isn’t scarcity here, let alone use value.
(Read “blockchain” as “Google Docs spreadsheet” and “Bitcoin wallet” as “spreadsheet cell”.)
- cowtools 4y agoI agree with your first statement about hoarding by early buyers. However, the smug "write-only database meme" is getting a bit old. Cryptocurrencies, and even other crypto-payment systems (e.g. chaumian cash) obviously have different characteristics than centralized money. Come to think of it, you could just mockingly describe any computer program that has structured data as a database. Cryptocurrency has almost nothing to do with databases or storing data. At its core, cryptocurrency is a system of distributing signed transactions that uses hashcash as a sybil-resistance and (order) synchronisation mechanism. Google spreadsheets need not apply. The whole point is that you don't require a single party to sign transactions. The problem that cryptocurrency deals with concerns co-operation between adversarial parties. Centralization leaves you hopping from platform to platform forever.
- xwolfi 4y agoBut this resistance is against a problem it creates: yes if all your stakeholders are anonymous and distributed you cannot trust them, but why not make a network of licensed operators you can trust ? Like I dunno, a savings account with international bank transfers...
- mkleczek 4y agoThe need for trust increases risk. Higher risk is higher cost.
- astrange 4y agoA blockchain is a kind of transaction log, but if you evaluate all the transactions you get a database at the end. A Google Docs spreadsheet also has a transaction log (a CRDT) while you have it open to do the updates. (Well, I assume it does, anyway.) Of course the security models are different, but you could say the log is a dual of the database.
- germandiago 4y agoBitcoin will have value as long as it is exchanged. For example overseas transfers are often abusive.