3 ms·
Can anyone explain how an “NFT domain” compares to Namecoin? I’m very interested in decentralised and censorship resistant hosting but it really feels like ver
by Gigachad 4y ago
Can anyone explain how an “NFT domain” compares to Namecoin?
I’m very interested in decentralised and censorship resistant hosting but it really feels like very little progress has been made here. It still seems like the best setup is a tor hidden service. It’s not decentralised but it’s a whole lot more practical and private from what I can see.
I assume IPFS is using some kind of torrent like DHT where it’s trivial to see what files people are accessing.
From my perspective, completely decentralised hosting is not actually very important. A website typically has a central owner who adds content and maintains it, they can often also host some software on a computer somewhere. The hard part is the transport between the owner and the user.
As we have seen, networking infrastructure is widely weaponised for censorship. Tor services avoid this but the accessibility massively drops so you won’t have much of a user base if you rely on tor.
- mrshadow 4y agoThere are max. 2 millions TOR users, but everybody can access the website hosted on IPFS (7 billions). TOR is sensitive to DDoS attack, IPFS; it is not. Ipfs is permanent web. BTW. Onion sites are not private. Law enforcement can access the onion sites in the same way as others. It just appears private. A cop in undercover can appear like an ordinary citizen and purchase dope from a dealer.
- Gigachad 4y agoWhat does max 2 million tor users mean? Anyone can install the Tor browser or view it through Brave browser. I assume you mean the existence of IPFS http gateways? Well there is nothing preventing a tor gateway from exisiting in exactly the same way. I assume the only reason it’s not common is the gateways would receive too many abuse reports due to the content typically hosted on onion sites. This has nothing to do with tech though. DDoS resistance is an issue on Tor but it has been shown that you can mitigate it. That’s one thing IPFS should win by default. And for privacy, Tor is pretty much the best you can get. It’s not bullet proof but it is the safest tech in existence. For DHT based technologies you can literally query the DHT and get the ip address of every single person who has a copy of the files. This is way way less private than tor, it’s less private than a standard clearnet website.
- mrshadow 4y agoI am not advocating for IPFS gateways. Gateways are centralized, I already mentioned somewhere. You can access the website directly via its CID (ipfs://CID), or via its decentralized domain (domain.eth, domain.x). But of course, you will need a browser with native support for IPFS (Opera, Brave). Currently for other browsers you need an extension called ipfs companion.
- crtasm 4y agoand anyone that can get that working is also capable of installing Tor Browser.
- iudqnolq 4y ago> There are max. 2 millions TOR users, everybody can access the website hosted on IPFS (7 billion) Only via a centralized relay, giving up the other nice properties. > TOR is sensitive to DDoS attack, IPFS; it is not. To DDoS a ToR website you'd need to overload the server(s) the website owner set up. To DDoS IPFS you'd need to overload the whole network. Harder, but not impossible. See [1]. > Ipfs is permanent web. Sort of, but you have to address pinning. > Law enforcement can access the onion sites in the same way as others ... A cop in undercover can appear like an ordinary citizen and purchase dope from a dealer Yes. Solving this would require implementing an evil bit[2]. I don't think IPFS has solved that problem? [1]: https://github.com/ipfs-inactive/faq/issues/171#issuecomment-265292941 https://github.com/ipfs-inactive/faq/issues/171#issuecomment... [2]: https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc3514.txt https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc3514.txt