5 ms·
> Maybe I'm just a cynic, but I find the community's pursuit of this individual's identity pretty interesting given the pro-privacy stance of crypto. This seem
by gruez 4y ago
> Maybe I'm just a cynic, but I find the community's pursuit of this individual's identity pretty interesting given the pro-privacy stance of crypto.
This seems like a strawman to me. Are there any privacy advocates out there who don't believe investigations should happen after a crime has been committed, because investigations are anti-privacy?
- coliveira 4y agoThe stated goal of privacy in money exchange is that we should not know who makes a transaction. The assumption is that people should themselves policy their money matters, independent of banks or governments. However, when a scam occurs everybody is asking police to to figure out who made these transactions, effectively supporting the identification of the people behind the funds.
- throwup 4y agoPrivacy is not incompatible with good old-fashioned detective work or police work. I use encrypted messaging, but if I decide to commit a crime I'm under no delusion that encryption will save me. Why can't the same be true for money?
- scoofy 4y agoRight, but the idea is that sensible people should want to willingly give up some of their privacy to participate in a transparent market. When you don't, and the crime is 10,000x harder (if not impossible by design) to solve (and more likely due to the moral hazard this brings), the sensibility of operating in a less private marketplace becomes apparent. Typically the markets can afford to compensate people on a day-to-day basis for small crime, but the entire reason bizarre concepts like clearing houses exist is that, from time to time, once every 10-30 years, an entire market can be destroyed overnight because of liquidity or counter-party risk or a combination, or some other situation like fraud. These things happen, and will continue to happen, which is why we should always look to the past when designing markets, and not fall for the folks telling about the wonders of their utopian future.
- gruez 4y ago1. I'm not sure why you're talking about fraud in markets, when that's not what happened here. This isn't a case of market participant A ripping market participant B off, it's some insider abusing his trust to enrich himself. 2. You talk about markets "can afford to compensate people [...] for small crime", but I see no reason why that would be applicable to exchanges. Given that both sides of a trade has to put up money before they can make the trade, the risk that either side can commit any sort of fraud/crime is virtually zero. You can still get hacked/scammed by the exchange itself, I'm not aware of any crypto privacy advocates who think that centralized exchanges should have the right to be anonymous. 3. You talk as if the "utopian future" is vaporware or something, but it does exist in the form of decentralized exchanges. Sure, they're not as good as centralized exchanges when it comes to fees/spreads/execution time, but they do exist and allow you to transact anonymously.
- scoofy 4y ago>I'm not sure why you're talking about fraud in markets, when that's not what happened here. This isn't a case of market participant A ripping market participant B off, it's some insider abusing his trust to enrich himself. You're describing fraud in a market. >I see no reason why that would be applicable to exchanges Anomalous and/or suspicious trades are regularly undone by exchanges.
- gruez 4y ago>You're describing fraud in a market. That's addressed my be later in the comment: >You can still get hacked/scammed by the exchange itself, I'm not aware of any crypto privacy advocates who think that centralized exchanges should have the right to be anonymous.
- MrMan 4y ago"bizarre concepts like clearing-houses" what planet do you come from? you ask questions that seem like you have an interest in finance but cant accept the emergent capital markets structures that follow from the practice of finance?
- kortilla 4y agoYes, the same thing happens with cash based crimes. There isn’t really the conflict here that you think.
- cyanydeez 4y agoMost libertarian beliefs basically edge on anarchy via corporations. Much of the crypto bros want "law is code" which basically means nothing is illegal.
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoThat's not true at all
- gruez 4y ago>Much of the crypto bros want "law is code" which basically means nothing is illegal. As other commenters have mentioned, this isn't some DiFi smart contract hack, it's just a regular centralized exchange hack. "law is code" doesn't apply here, unless there's some other group of "crypto bros" that I'm not aware of who think that laws should only be enforced via the blockchain. The version of "law is code" that I'm aware of only applies insofar as smart contracts are concerned (eg. anything that a smart contract allows for is fair game).
- cyanydeez 4y agoRight and the only way cryptocurrency had value was via, you guessed it, centralization.
- dibt 4y agoYour use of the phrase "crypto bros" and stereotypical generalization suggest you have an agenda. You are not looking to have a "curious conversation" as the HN guidelines encourage.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]