5 ms·
based on their academic services, I wouldn't be too worried because those services are crap. Their academic analytics stuff barely passes the test and is mostly
by seydor 4y ago
based on their academic services, I wouldn't be too worried because those services are crap. Their academic analytics stuff barely passes the test and is mostly used because nobody wants to make a competitor. Most academic metadata is openly available to anyone who wants to use it, but people know that academia is more about networking, PR, politics etc rather than the exactness of academic analytics. Then elsevier's own websites were pretty crap for the (pre-SciHub) times i used them , sometimes being offline, other times with stupid web design etc. They don't have a technical moat other than being so entrenched in academic politics.
I assume something similar is going on in the other spaces. They live in a legacy world that will be replaced with AI overnight.
- impendia 4y ago> people know that academia is more about networking, PR, politics etc rather than the exactness of academic analytics This is generally true, but academics (I am one) are at least vaguely worried that analytics will take over. Any good department chair will be prepared, at any time, to give their dean and provost an account of how our department is doing really fantastic work, despite how badly you underfund us, you should really direct more resources to us right away. Since academic work looks so different from discipline to discipline, administrators find it difficult to evaluate who is actually doing good work. And thus swoop in companies like Elsevier, Clarivate, Academic Analytics, etc. with bright shiny dashboards, with tables and bar graphs that purport to measure productivity. Sure, their measurement is shit but the alternative is often simply to take people at their word. As a working academic, I do not wish any of these companies well. But I wouldn't underestimate them.