3 ms·
I reject your Jevons argument. No, it would not be unusual for them to use less energy overall. Whether they do or not is dependent on specifics of the situat
by pfdietz 4y ago
I reject your Jevons argument. No, it would not be unusual for them to use less energy overall. Whether they do or not is dependent on specifics of the situation.
I think you are misled by historical contingency. When moving from "not mechanized" to "mechanized", energy use increases. People didn't have air conditioning, or refrigeration, or TVs, etc. and then they did. Energy use went up because new use cases were being created. But once they have them, at some point the satisfaction those produce saturates, and the natural progression of efficiency pulls the energy use back down again. We don't eat ever increasing quantities of food just because agriculture has become more efficient. We don't scale the number of TVs we watch because their power use has declined.
Your argument is depending on the existence of ever increasing numbers of new activities to consume the energy, that produce sufficient value to justify them. I am skeptical that such exist, or could exist.
- roenxi 4y ago> Your argument is depending on the existence of ever increasing numbers of new activities to consume the energy There are literally an infinite number of useful activities that consume energy. The only limit is at some point we transform so much energy that the earth becomes unlivable because we can't vent it fast enough. At that point we'd have to give up and ... oh wait, no. We'd use the energy to move off the planet. Energy solves that problem too! If we could work with them cost effectively humanity could probably find a use for every joule of energy in the universe. Every single one. Because in the limit, energy can basically fabricate new mass out of nothing and make a universe perfectly hospitable to a very large number of humans - a race that grows exponentially. Whatever the limits are we're nowhere near reaching them with what we have right now. > No, it would not be unusual for them to use less energy overall In that case we'd see a country somewhere with steady electricity prices and shrinking demand. I don't think that country exists. Do you have some examples in mind? Because the countries I've seen that use less energy tend to have massively spiking energy prices, usually because they just ran out of available fossil fuels. You are taking a bold stance. Jevon came up with the paradox after observing that this specific effect applies in energy markets. They observed the effect contemporary to the Watt being named the Watt. You're going to need a stronger argument than "I reject..." and "I think...". Because the Jevons' argument is an "Economists have observed and come up with a theory to explain...".