4 ms·
You pay $3/month for the privilege of allowing them to front you cash for up to a month. If you are late, they charge you $5. No broken legs, no threats, just $
by latchkey 15y ago
You pay $3/month for the privilege of allowing them to front you cash for up to a month. If you are late, they charge you $5. No broken legs, no threats, just $5.
According to one of the images 'simple terms apply'. What are those terms and why aren't they listed right now? That seems shady to make a big announcement and not clearly list all the terms.
I've got a few questions: How much cash can I borrow? What happens if I'm late multiple months? What prevents me from closing my account and just walking away?
I don't know, this seems like an awful idea to me. Rife for abuse. Dwolla will be one the receiving end of a lot of fraud really quickly and will be spending all their time and resources chasing down deadbeats.
UPDATE: A 3rd party has more details than their own site [1]. Up to $500. Still seems rife for fraud to me because now they are going to have to chase down a lot of people for only $500.
If my credit is good and my money management is sound, why would I need to pay $3 a month for the privilege of allowing me to get a loan for up to $500?
[1] http://www.siliconprairienews.com/2011/12/dwolla-introduces-instant-gives-users-instant-access-to-line-of-credit http://www.siliconprairienews.com/2011/12/dwolla-introduces-...
- colinsidoti 15y agoBecause they're avoiding "credit" entirely. I suspect this is the start of their own implementation of "credit", and they're comfortable with losing some money at the beginning. In the long run, the traction they gain from the good customers could/should be worth more than the money they lose. For the consumer, $3 on $500 is incredibly low interest.
- gojomo 15y ago$3/month on $500 isn't 'incredibly' low: it's $36/year, on a net carried balance that's probably close to zero at least as often as it's close to the maximum $500. If you could time it just right, so that your balance was $499 29 days of every month, and $0 the one day that it needs to be, the effective rate would be around 7%, a fair but not great consumer credit rate. But if your balance is often closer to zero, and you ever trigger the late fee, the effective rate becomes much, much higher. It does compare favorably to foreign-ATM access fees.
- aidenn0 15y agoFind a charge card (not a credit card) that has an annual fee of less than $36 and a late fee of $5 or less. Now consider that Dwolla charges less to merchants as well.
- encoderer 15y agoactually, if you have good credit, that's not a problem. I don't have any cards with an annual fee. in fact, they pay me, on average about 1.9% cash back per year. on the late fee, you're right. but the answer there is to pay in time. not really an issue.
- nestlequ1k 15y agoThe financial industry runs on the fact that a tiny fraction of people have good credit. They love people like you who morally justify gouging poor people by saying "well, it's your own damn fault for having bad credit". See also: http://www.cracked.com/blog/5-things-nobody-tells-you-about-being-poor/ http://www.cracked.com/blog/5-things-nobody-tells-you-about-...
- encoderer 15y agoThat conveniently glosses over the fact that it is your fault if you have bad credit. There are systemic causes of poverty. But nobody forces you to take credit you can't repay. More importantly, your premise is wrong: The average credit score in the US is just below 700 (690ish iirc.) And the median is above 700. This comes from numbers from the CRAs and is supported by the stats reported by CreditKarma.com. That is not bad credit.
- anamax 15y ago> I don't have any cards with an annual fee. in fact, they pay me, on average about 1.9% cash back per year. How are you still getting that much? My 2% for everything and 5% gas/groceries cards went away after Dodd-Frank. I've still got 3% Gas and dining and 2% travel with the occasional special but the rest, the majority, is only getting me 1%.
- kfcm 15y agoIt is essentially a line of credit, sort of a cross between a term and demand loan I would guess (without more details of repayment terms). Many banks have something similar, only it's called "overdraft protection". Of course, as someone else has commented, with good money management, you don't need this.
- kfcm 15y agoI was coming up with the exact same questions--and conclusion--as you while reading the post.
- frankydp 15y agoThey should have focused on the merchant benefit and not the customer side of this launch. This change in my eyes is specifically to address the concerns of merchants that will not use Dwolla with the delayed payment system in place now. I give them credit for trying to solve a merchant faith problem with a customer credit line. Someone that cant wait 2-3 days for money to be deposited in their account will probably not be the kind of person you would lend 500 bucks too, hence the 3 dollar fee, just sayin.