2 ms·
I've read a few technical specifications for automotive stuff... And this spec seems severely lacking. There are plenty of things here that need specifying
by londons_explore 4y ago
I've read a few technical specifications for automotive stuff... And this spec seems severely lacking.
There are plenty of things here that need specifying before this is a standard that everyone could use.
For example, is it the connector or the socket which should be measuring the temperature of the pins? In case of an unacceptable temperature rise (for example due to corrosion), how fast should current be stopped? Is there a minimal thermal mass for a pin to limit how fast the temperature can rise? Remember that if you dump just 1% of the rated 900kW charging energy into a 10 gram bit of copper, it starts melting plastic in just 16 milliseconds... Will your temperature sensor respond that fast? Will there be voltage monitoring on both sides of the link to detect voltage drop across a corroded connector? How will that be communicated?
Without all this stuff decided ahead of time, each engineering team will make their own solutions to these problems, and you'll end up with certain combinations of car and plug that won't work (his temperature sensor isn't fast enough to prevent damage to my port, so I refuse to charge). Or other combinations that melt (his dirty connector generated too much heat, and by the time I detected that and powered off, parts of his plug were at 1000C and welded themself onto me)
And before you reply that it should be designed to not corrode ... Well the spec requires unplated copper... Which corrodes given time and humidity, something you won't manage to keep out of a connector.
- nomel 4y agoFor the unplated copper, doesn’t the low resistance come from sacrificing a bit of the material each insertion? I know this is the case for most other high powered plugs. Also, much of your concerns are addressed in the charging system. There are sanity checks in place, with initial and continuous resistance measurement. It’s not just a relay flipping. So, welding together in 16ms is impossible. Maybe a bit longer than that. ;) Plastic melting together definitely is though.
- londons_explore 4y ago> much of your concerns are addressed in the charging system. Unless I missed it... That doesn't appear in the spec.
- nomel 4y agoThe control protocol spec wouldn't be part of the physical connector spec, other than setting some minimum requirements so the connector meets the control protocols assumptions. The control protocol is, necessarily as your concerns point out, made so that things like resistance, water, dirt, and bad connections, all things that are expected states of connectors, don't pose a significant safety hazard.