6 ms·
Crypto is incompatible with regulation and institutions because it was designed to be, and is consistently a part of the ethos espoused by pretty much all crypt
by lazide 4y ago
Crypto is incompatible with regulation and institutions because it was designed to be, and is consistently a part of the ethos espoused by pretty much all crypto players?
Literally, the first sentence in the Bitcoin whitepaper (which arguably kicked off 'crypto' as a thing) is "A purely peer-to-peer version of electronic cash would allow online payments to be sent directly from one party to another without going through a financial institution".
[https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf]
I mean, seriously?
- stripedfish7 4y agoI don't understand your point. My grandfather tries to use only cash which allow 'payments to be sent directly from one party to another without going through a financial institution'.
- WontGetFooled 4y ago
- adastra22 4y agoAnd that is arguably the simplest explanation of what bitcoin is: digital cash.
- brk 4y agoWhich by definition is fundamentally impossible to do transfers without a middle man of some kind.
- adastra22 4y agoBitcoin has no middleman.
- salawat 4y agoCash doesn't announce your balance to the world...
- codehalo 4y agoTransaction broadcast is not the problem. Censorship is. However, if you want privacy, use Monero.
- lazide 4y agoIt’s a problem if you don’t want to have to worry about some third party deciding post-facto to come after you for the transaction! And since it’s global, that third party could even be some foreign gov’t or entrepreneurial individual.
- brk 4y agoHow you can transfer bitcoin between exactly two people with zero outside involvement from other entities? I suppose you might be able to have a bunch of pre-filled wallets of various amounts that you can transfer via thumb drive, but in a practical sense your transaction is going over various networks and through other machines.
- lazide 4y agoIn order for a balance to be transferred on the chain, it MUST be included in a mined block (the longest chain one/aka the primary blockchain). So there is always a middleman, unless you’re on your own chain. But it’s distributed, no one can reliably pick who is going to be the miner (or always be the miner) because of the POW algorithm, and everyone can trust the outcome because of the way everything is structured. There are very strong incentives for everyone to try to mine, for instance, and the more mining power there is, the more difficult it is for anyone to have a controlling interest or monopoly on mining, barring special economies of scale in mining hardware, anyway. (Which do exist, but not enough to make it doable to get a monopoly right now) Worst case, the miners can ignore your particular transaction indefinitely, but the counterparty can see that too, and it would require active collusion from a very large percentage of miners to even attempt that.
- lazide 4y agoI thought of a random analogy here - the block chain miners are the equivalent of a common carrier parcel service here (albeit with far stronger guarantees against tampering). So it’s not a middleman like a bank or a payment processor. Rather a bulk processor who moves a bunch of opaque chunks somewhere for money without any particular regard for who or what as long as they get paid for it.
- stripedfish7 4y agoCan you elaborate? When I give a cash payment to the babysitter, who is the middleman?
- wardedVibe 4y agoThat's monero. Because it's deflationary and has a completely open record of transactions, Bitcoin is digital gold.
- adastra22 4y agoI was talking about bitcoin as a reference class for digital currencies, as opposed to Apple Cash balances or whatever.
- sgt101 4y agoHang on, when did gold come with a transaction record?
- wardedVibe 4y agoIf you're buying gold these days, typically it just sits in fort Knox or wherever, and you're buying a record of ownership.
- lazide 4y agoThere is a very, very long history of that being a bad idea. There are some situations (commodity exchanges) it’s necessary, but they are heavily regulated and audited for that reason. They also have non trivial storage costs. Gold depositories have the same issues as crypto exchanges have typically had - it’s almost inevitable that someone absconds with the actual gold without telling anyone, or ‘prints’ extra without backing assets, etc. and until someone does an audit or everyone tries to withdraw their gold/tokens/whatever, no one knows. It also enables a lot of other scams. [https://www.cftc.gov/LearnAndProtect/AdvisoriesAndArticles/fraudadv_preciousmetals.html https://www.cftc.gov/LearnAndProtect/AdvisoriesAndArticles/f...] For anyone reading, educate yourself so you don’t get defrauded. Not all depositories are a bad idea in all situations - but be cautious. (Also, historical footnote - the last credible audit of the gold at Fort Knox was in 1974, hah - https://www.usmint.gov/learn/history/historical-documents/inspection-of-gold-at-fort-knox https://www.usmint.gov/learn/history/historical-documents/in...)
- lazide 4y agoWhich every financial institution and western government keeps trying to get rid of because it is essentially impossible to regulate or police? And which cops have a nasty tendency to seize on sight in the US if seen in any significant quantity (outside of an armored car) because ‘proceeds of crime’? And pretty much every drug transaction, illegal sexual transaction, whatever is done in cash? To the point most major crime shows and drama shows have scenes involving some massive pile or duffel bags or whatever of cash as a plot point? Cash on the barrel head is the textbook definition of ‘difficult to regulate’. Also, most people buying person to person used cars and doing yard sale transactions use it too, of course. It’s not a requirement that Cash transactions involve a crime at all. Same with crypto. If your transaction is illegal though, using Venmo seems pretty dumb.
- biztos 4y ago> …and western government keeps trying to get rid of… But then there’s China, right?[0] And arguably India?[1] I agree with your larger point, but I don’t think it’s “western” per se to dream of the surveillance state knowing our every spend. [0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/27/technology/alipay-china.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/27/technology/alipay-china.h... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Indian_banknote_demonetisation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Indian_banknote_demonetis...
- lazide 4y agoFor sure, but I wasn’t familiar enough with their efforts to say how vigorously or effectively they have been pursuing it. Thanks for the links!
- ohgodplsno 4y agoCash has serial numbers for traceability, and is emitted by a central bank. That's a big chunk of a financial institution right there. Additionally, if you pay for $50, the state won't give a damn, because it's $50. Pay a company $10k in cash and every alarm will go off and the transaction will have to be notified to a financial institution. Tracfin in Europe for example, etc. So, no, cash isn't entirely separated from financial institutions.
- lazide 4y agoI didn’t say cash didn’t require institutions somewhere. Cash creation (physical), and cash into and out of the system requires institutions. Cash transactions do not, so spending, receiving, and if one is crazy storage can be done without institutions. That hypothetical $10k transaction for instance only sets alarm bells off if it’s an abnormal transaction for an individual account. Someone doing a cash business is going to do stuff like that so much, it’s a drop in the bucket and no one cares. Coin shops, check cashing places, certain types of convenience stores and restaurants, etc. If they manage the cash themselves instead of a cash drop, such as if they are a dispensary and are unbanked, a given dollar bill can circulate a very long time before touching a bank, depending on which parts of the economy it touches. The reality is it isn’t super hard to launder funds apparently, so it ends up back in a bank somewhere soon, but with the intermediary transactions hidden.
- biztos 4y ago> Pay a company $10k in cash Do you mean bank transfer? Let’s say I buy a legal widget for $10K and I pay cash and I don’t plan to treat it as a business expense. On my side, I’m done, and any alarm that might be invoked is the problem of the seller, and probably dependent on their compliance with weakly enforced regulations. For some classes of widget I might want a receipt, but definitely not for all. You can easily spend that much on a birthday dinner with your friends, if that’s your thing. I don’t think anybody is arguing that cash is “entirely separated from financial institutions” but — even above $10K — it allows for the possibility (not the guarantee) of transaction privacy.
- adolph 4y ago
- iskander 4y agoThat's the underlying payment network, but a whole "industry" of institutions have grown on top of it. Those can be regulated.
- lazide 4y agoSure. The problem I’ve seen is there is zero value add (and significant costs and value loss) when that happens over a normal bank.
- iskander 4y agoLike, theoretical value add? Composable open source finance seems like a cool idea. Practical value add? Less clear. On-chain comes with "contract risk", off-chain is more or less unregulated and comes with these FTX-like collapse risks.
- lazide 4y agoIMO, Cool is ‘value add’ in that it makes it easier to part naive investors or customers from their cash, not in value add in the way that actually makes something hard easier and more efficient, or enables some new high value thing that was previously impossible.
- iskander 4y agoI mean it obviously enables things previously not possible: open experimentation with financial primitives which results in new ideas like automatic market makers. Nothing within the traditional financial world allows you, as a random tinkerer, to create algorithms for exchanging between pairs of assets along a curve defined by the relative amounts of reserves for each asset. However, whether this freedom to tinker and invent new primitives is worth all the extra risk from people trying to "invest" in this stuff, way less clear. Especially when the freedom is most often used to recreate traditional flavors of financial fraud dressed up as new technology. There needs to be some conceptual separation between the actual on-chain technology (used by a very smaller minority of people with some kind of financial stake in crypto) vs. buying tokens/coins off-chain. At the very least marketing and promotion of buying made-up crypto tokens should be illegal and probably every off-chain entity related to crypto should be heavily regulated to avoid using the cover of "new technology" to perpetuate scams.
- thewataccount 4y agoThe network was designed not to be regulatable. Businesses however are regulatable. The US has shown they can effectively enforce AML/KYC requirements across the vast majority of exchanges and businesses. Any exchange the average person tries to use to buy crypto will request your ID to do any meaningful transaction. Granted, there are exchanges you can use a VPN and access without KYC, and while it is difficult to manage billions of dollars in the dark, it's certainly possible. But they can regulate the vast majority that any regular user will find, and have shown they're willing to OFAC others. It is not going to be long before regulations are increased, and some exchanges/services will be known to be subject to them - and will likely lean on that as a selling point. The others will only be accessible to those going out of their way to use them.
- lazide 4y agoSure, but that’s building a giant industry around the tech to make it explicitly NOT what it was designed to be, or what the ethos has been - secure, point to point electronic cash with no one telling you who you can transact with or what you can spend it on. Aka electronic cash. No one needs a pile of paperwork to prove to the gov’t who they are to spend or get paid cash. No one needs to be on a list, and have their every transaction double checked to make sure it’s with a validated counterparty to pay in or get paid cash. Etc. At that point, it’s literally cheaper, easier, and safer to just use a normal bank. Which is I guess the point.
- thewataccount 4y ago> Sure, but that’s building a giant industry around the tech to make it explicitly NOT what it was designed to be, > No one needs a pile of paperwork to prove to the gov’t who they are to spend or get paid cash. To be clear there's different types of regulations, some we/I personally agree with more than others. Personally, I agree with you that kyc/aml laws are over the top. I think privacy and money laundering are two things people often conflate, and that privacy is something we should want. (Side tangent - the majority of crypto was not really designed for anonymity or privacy, although that's a whole different topic). People claiming "crypto is just for money laundering" as a reason it's bad should be applying the same logic to physical cash. What I'm particularly interested in is regulations around the big exchanges to prevent them from putting all of their clients money somewhere stupid, losing it all, and go illiquid. > At that point, it’s literally cheaper, easier, and safer to just use a normal bank. I mean yes, an FDIC insured bank is absolutely safer than an unregulated crypto exchange. This is the exact reason why the phrase "not your keys, not your coins" exists, and why everyone says you shouldn't keep your keys on an exchange. Done properly, a crypto wallet should be safer than a bank provided you can assure physical safety and redundancy of your keys. Part of the problem IMO is that crypto became this "get rich quick" thing - with "exchanges" advertising double digit returns, people using NFTs for art for some reason, etc. I think the technology has uses, but this "get rich quick" bs has been a massive hinderance. I really think this "the point of crypto is to make money" mentality is missing the actual use of it. tl;dr - a properly used crypto wallet should be safer then a FDIC bank, an FDIC bank is faaar safer then a crypto exchange, there could be more regulation on just the exchanges, and aml/kyc laws are a seperate type of regulation - I was just using these as an example of the US government successfully regulating exchanges.
- ManuelKiessling 4y agoI can pay you in cash without going through a financial institution. That doesn’t make the Euro unregulated.
- lazide 4y agoIt makes spending Euros defacto unregulated, no? Or do you have to fill out a slip and get audited for every transaction?
- potatototoo99 4y agoModern crypto has little to do with bitcoin. Bitcoin was about digital money, out of the reach of central banks as a response to the 2008's financial crisis. Modern crypto is about trying to convince others your altcoin has some intrinsic value by selling rumours, partnerships, governance or some other vaporous dream, so it can be used for gambling. The problem are central exchanges creating monstrous speculation instruments and of course gambling with user funds on top of it by lack of regulation.
- lazide 4y agoThey all use it as support in their value prop, and try to claim some association, near as I can tell. But yeah, it’s mostly semi-transparent grifts, and has been for awhile.