2 ms·
> You don't have to build a search engine that is better than Google's… You're right, of course — most companies would be happy with a "perfectly fine" DDG-lik
by CharlesW 4y ago
> You don't have to build a search engine that is better than Google's…
You're right, of course — most companies would be happy with a "perfectly fine" DDG-like offering. I'm presupposing that "best" is Apple's bar for an M1-like slam dunk launch, since an underwhelming launch (think Apple Maps 1.0) can be hard to recover from.
> And working for years on a project that may never see the light of day can be hard.
For sure! Moonshots require a level of faith that I'm not sure could maintain for a decade either.
- AdamJacobMuller 4y agoI think, much like maps, a search engine requires an iterative development process. I don't think you can reasonably launch either product (search nor maps) and surpass the quality of Google on day 1 because there is so much user feedback on both products which you can not capture without actual users. Apple, with Maps, has shown an ability to stick with things and iteratively grow them to be really great (Apple maps IMO now far surpasses google maps and except for some specific data layers it's far and above OSM).
- CydeWeys 4y agoIt's a great point. Apple Maps was pretty rough when it launched but they've stuck with it and iteratively improved it. It's not like this is a self-driving car where you have to get it right and any mistake from the get-go can be fatal, so there's no reason not to apply the same iterative approach to search.
- user_named 4y agoTesla certainly didn't feel the need to get their Fake Self-Driving right from the get go.
- saimiam 4y agoA colleague who trusted Apple Maps 1.0 a bit too much once found himself driving towards the edge of a cliff because his actual destination was at the bottom of that cliff down a mountain road. So yeah, maybe not at the same level as self driving cars but Apple Maps 1.0 could have been fatal for people less situationally aware than my colleague.
- vbezhenar 4y agoApple Maps are plain useless. Google Maps are bad but bearable. OSM is miles ahead Apple Maps which is surprising because they could just pull data from OSM and not being that bad.
- ghqst 4y agoIs this because of your area? Apple Maps has been tangibly improving over the last few years.
- vbezhenar 4y agoI assume that's because of my area. Doesn't make it any better for me. It doesn't even have names of villages around (which OSM does have).
- AdamJacobMuller 4y agoThat's very interesting, where are you located? I'm in north NJ in the US.
- vbezhenar 4y agoI'm in Kazakhstan, Astana. City itself is not that bad, but surroundings are bad.
- ksidudwbw 4y agoNobody's tried Brave Search?
- BirAdam 4y agoI pretty much only use brave. It seems to give me more relevant results.
- ksec 4y ago> I'm presupposing that "best" is Apple's bar for an M1-like slam dunk launch Well Apple has been iterating Ax Series Chips, M1 is no different to previous A(n)X Chip. i.e M1 wasn't really a "launch" for the M Chip. And Search could easily have been something else in the mean time before a "Google" launch. Apple already does a lot of "Searching" with Siri Suggestions. And arguably it is the 2nd largest search engine on the planet.
- CharlesW 4y ago> Well Apple has been iterating Ax Series Chips, M1 is no different to previous A(n)X Chip. i.e M1 wasn't really a "launch" for the M Chip. Through an engineering lens, yes — one can look at the M1 SoC in a vacuum and characterize it as a logical evolutionary step in Apple's 20 years of silicon design. What made its introduction shocking (and its launch a slam dunk) is that Apple leveraged its experience in silicon design, OS design, hardware design, emulation, etc. to create new products, based on a completely new architecture for the desktop/laptop market, that definitively trounced their Intel-based predecessors. You may have seen the clues before the M1 launched (which are crystal clear in retrospect), but for most people the unveiling of the M1 was as much a surprise as learning the identity of Keyser Söze. > Apple already does a lot of "Searching" with Siri Suggestions. And arguably it is the 2nd largest search engine on the planet. Exactly! What will be "Apple Search" exists in a nascent state today, making its eventual launch as a branded product very analogous to the "develop secretly in plain sight" strategy Apple used for the M1.