Is there a dichotomy between 1 and 2? The tendency of assumptions in these regards is that someone willing to act contrary to the norm in one way is willing to

Is there a dichotomy between 1 and 2? The tendency of assumptions in these regards is that someone willing to act contrary to the norm in one way is willing to also be so in other ways. Neither convicted shoplifters or convicted drug dealers will get hired for positions that require trust, even though only the shoplifter can be shown to be a thief.