It is really hard to judge a situation with so little and one sided information. But the person got useful advice specific to german phd processes and whom to c

It is really hard to judge a situation with so little and one sided information. But the person got useful advice specific to german phd processes and whom to contact for advice with some insight. Retelling of emails and conversations always makes me sceptical, especially about the followups. The professor suddenly wrote > that I would not be graduating anymore For sure, this must have had a followup question from the PhD student of what to do next then. Or some form of discussion.