3 ms·
> This keeps getting rediscovered in new domains. I'm not sure there's a need for a "strong version" of Goodhart's law, or I fail to understand the distinction
by astrobe_ 4y ago
> This keeps getting rediscovered in new domains.
I'm not sure there's a need for a "strong version" of Goodhart's law, or I fail to understand the distinction the author is trying to make.
Goodhart is "so true" precisely because it warns about the fact that the measure is often not the goal itself, just like "the map is not the territory", and is indeed an approximation of the goal.
One finds a similar problem with the word "best": best according to which metric? That's how people have different ideas of what is the best.
- shanusmagnus 4y agoSee footnote 4. I would quote it except it's pretty long and full of links, and an edit, which HN "formatting" would make confusing.