4 ms·
Everything is a tradeoff. Efficiency is usually a tradeoff that limits flexibility. If you don't happen to need flexibility, you can have amazing efficiency: a
by nine_k 4y ago
Everything is a tradeoff.
Efficiency is usually a tradeoff that limits flexibility. If you don't happen to need flexibility, you can have amazing efficiency: a wheel of a rail car is so much more efficient than a foot. But only when it stays on a rail.
If we look at a somehow more difficult terrain, a foot suddenly happens to be a better deal, because it adapts to a variety of conditions. Of course, at the expense of efficiency (complexity, energy consumption, need for a much more advanced control circuits, etc).
In business you usually have to have some safety margin for the unexpected. If you squeeze it out in the name of efficiency (and profit), all goes well until it does not, and then it fails much harder, maybe catastrophically.
(Nassim Taleb wrote a whole book about that, "Antifragility", where he gives a ton of fun real life examples to make basically the above point.)
- kqr 4y agoI would argue "efficiency" is the wrong word for what we discuss. Efficiency means optimising resource usage while achieving goals. If we need flexibility to achieve our goals consistently (and you usually do) then flexibility is part of efficiency (and effectiveness and efficacy) rather than opposed to it. Phrased differently: if you define "efficiency" to mean "optimise for a single proxy metric and not what you're actually interested in" then yes, of course efficiency and effectiveness will be opposed other than sometimes by chance. But that's a dumb definition of efficiency!
- phkx 4y agoTo me, efficiency means achieving a desired goal while consuming a minimum of resources (time, energy, space, …). If the goal is defined in a too narrow scope, i.e. your ‚dumb‘ definition of efficiency, the flexibility may be missing. Still, that particular goal may be reached efficiently. So it’s not an issue with the definition of efficiency, but rather with scoping the problem. As the article states, it may not always be possible to scope the problem in an easily measurable way, hence optimizing for proxy targets.
- kqr 4y agoIt seems to me you're making the same terminology mistake, only shifted one layer back! You're expressing yourself as if the "too narrow metrics" were the goal in and of themselves. I would argue the metrics are never the goal -- the fuzzy intention they're proxying for is always the goal.
- legulere 4y agoTrade offs are also optimizations: you are optimizing for the sums of weighted advantages and disadvantages of something: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_function