2 ms·
> RE to below: (due to timeout) There's no timeout. It takes a little while for a reply link to appear on the main page, but if you click directly through to t
by pessimizer 4y ago
> RE to below: (due to timeout)
There's no timeout. It takes a little while for a reply link to appear on the main page, but if you click directly through to the comment, you can reply.
> In classic HN autistic pedantry, if someone puts a gun to my head and demands my wallet and I hand it over -- well your honor they were never forced to do it! You see they were just threatened to be convinced to hand the wallet over!
I'm going to take a last run at explaining this to you. I'm not telling you that the government cannot force you to do things. I'm telling you that the government cannot force you to testify against yourself, because that's how justice once worked: you chose somebody you thought did something, then tortured them until they admitted it. This is the beginning and the end of self-incrimination. It doesn't give you the ability to refuse to give your photograph, it doesn't give you the ability to refuse fingerprint or DNA collection. It, in fact, doesn't give you any ability. It restrains the ability of the government to punish you for not testifying against yourself.
> In classic HN autistic pedantry, if someone puts a gun to my head and demands my wallet and I hand it over -- well your honor they were never forced to do it!
I really have to bail, because this is stupid. The government can take your wallet. You are not allowed to keep your wallet because the things inside it can incriminate you. By your own tortured reasoning, self-incrimination would include someone else physically holding you down and taking your wallet.
Nothing can be self-incrimination that doesn't require you to be alive to participate in. Any inability to understand this is willful, and you're only hurting yourself.