2 ms·
> physically forcing someone to incriminate themselves is self incrimination. You can't physically force someone to testify. It's not a thing that is possible,
by pessimizer 4y ago
> physically forcing someone to incriminate themselves is self incrimination.
You can't physically force someone to testify. It's not a thing that is possible, unless you kill them and attach electrodes to the muscles of their mouth, throat, and diaphragm. The testimony that results from that method will not be convincing.
> The whole point of laws regarding self incrimination is not to stop people from being electively able to incriminate themselves, but to stop the government from being able to force them to incriminate themselves.
Again, the government cannot force people to incriminate themselves. It can threaten people in order to convince them to incriminate themselves, it can punish people if they refuse to incriminate themselves, but it can't force people to incriminate themselves. It can put their finger on a phone. You can put their finger on a phone, if you're bigger than them, or they are asleep.
The point of laws about self-incrimination is to declare that refusal to self-incriminate cannot be punished.