7 ms·
When selecting a price for your product, you have three choices: 1. lower than the competition - unfair competition, dumping, predatory pricing 2. same as the
by WalterBright 4y ago
When selecting a price for your product, you have three choices:
1. lower than the competition - unfair competition, dumping, predatory pricing
2. same as the competition - collusion, price fixing
3. higher than the competition - gouging, profiteering
All three price points are illegal.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dheera 4y agoClearly the answer is a price that isn't disclosed online, and requires the customer to fill out a form disclosing their name ("ethnicity"), address ("socioeconomic status"), and title/company ("education level") before they can receive a quote on the item. /s
- lesuorac 4y agoExcept they're not. 1) If your costs are legitimately less than the competition then charging less is not illegal. If you're taking a loss to gain market share and then upping the price once the competitors go out of business that's a problem. 2) Have you seen gas stations? If setting your price to be the same was illegal there'd be so many convicted people. 3) I don't remember profiteering being illegal. Literally a ton of companies have been recording record profit and certainly people have been complaining but who was fined/imprisoned? Martin Shkreli wasn't convicted of profiteering cause it's not a crime.
- WalterBright 4y ago> are legitimately less Cost accounting is not a rigorous discipline. It involves a lot of assumptions, guesswork, and handwaving. > taking a loss to gain market share and then upping the price once the competitors go out of business that's a problem. Present a case history of this. > If setting your price to be the same They rarely seem to be at the same price > I don't remember profiteering being illegal Remember all those anti-gouging laws? Warren wants to extend them. https://fee.org/articles/why-elizabeth-warrens-proposed-anti-price-gouging-law-would-be-a-national-disaster/ https://fee.org/articles/why-elizabeth-warrens-proposed-anti...
- enragedcacti 4y ago> Present a case history of this. Amazon versus Diapers.com https://slate.com/technology/2013/10/amazon-book-how-jeff-bezos-went-thermonuclear-on-diapers-com.html https://slate.com/technology/2013/10/amazon-book-how-jeff-be...
- WalterBright 4y agoNot really, diapers.com sold their business to Amazon, and nobody demonstrated that Amazon sold diapers below cost.
- enragedcacti 4y agoSold after they were practically run out of business by Amazon's pricing. > Quidsi could now taste its own blood. At one point, Quidsi executives took what they knew about shipping rates, factored in Procter & Gamble’s (PG) wholesale prices, and calculated that Amazon was on track to lose $100 million over three months in the diaper category alone. You're right it has not been demonstrated. Maybe some governing body should investigate and come to a conclusion about whether Amazon engages in unfair methods of competition such as what is purported by Quidsi.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoIs a retailer now obliged to run every single product they sell at a profit? So Costco can't do their chicken deal (which costs them millions and customers love), nobody is allowed loss leaders?
- enragedcacti 4y agoGenerally speaking, no. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predatory_pricing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predatory_pricing
- danielmarkbruce 4y ago
- vineyardmike 4y agoFirst of all, the article (and original source [1]) doesn't actually discuss pricing. Page 12 starts a list of historic examples, none mention pricing. Important quote (page 8): > "The method of competition must be unfair, meaning that the conduct goes beyond competition on the merits. Competition on the merits may include, for example, superior products or services, superior business acumen, truthful marketing and advertising practices, investment in research and development that leads to innovative outputs, or attracting employees and workers through the offering of better employment terms." Second of all, this is intentionally one-sided perspective to say all are illegal (its not). Personally, I say screw the giant corps, do what's best for people in society, even at the expense of profit margins. Why do we sympathize with giant corporations? With inflation rising, IMO we should expect that business take smaller profit margins to keep prices from inflating higher. What is the harm in shareholders missing out on profits a bit in 2022? Surely less to society than all the lower-income folks missing out on buying food. To address the "all three prices are illegal" point (which, again, is not true) 1. If you price your product at a loss in the attempt to drive your competition out of business, then maybe this applies, but only maybe. 2. Only if you actually collude/price fix. You can find the same natural market price as competition without collusion. Coffee shops sell coffee at similar prices because the all the businesses have similar costs, and consumers have a limit to their willingness to spend. 3. Only if you do it under limited circumstances. Price gouging is rare. BMW doesn't price gouge for selling more expensive cars than Toyota, but buying 100% of the supply of a drug and 100x'ing the price just to make more money is bad for society, and more likely to be price gouging. [1] https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/P221202Section5PolicyStatement.pdf https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/P221202Section5...
- WalterBright 4y ago> Personally, I say screw the giant corps Giant corps are the engines that drive the economy. Take them away, and you've got an economy in the dumpster. (Small businesses are the future. A healthy economy requires both.) > we should expect that business take smaller profit margins to keep prices from inflating higher Businesses neither aid nor retard inflation. Inflation is a monetary phenomenon caused by deficit spending. If you want less inflation, vote against the deficit spenders. > which, again, is not true Amusingly, your exposition admits they are all illegal, although selectively applied. Mostly for BS reasons, like Microsoft being charged with giving away a browser for free (no harm to consumers was ever established).
- enragedcacti 4y ago> 2. same as the competition - collusion, price fixing Only true if you arrived at those prices via collusion > 3. higher than the competition - gouging, profiteering In the US gouging is pretty much always legally defined as "raising prices by [xx%] in the immediate aftermath of a civil emergency on necessary items". People might use the terms colloquially but that doesn't make it illegal.
- WalterBright 4y ago> Only true if you arrived at those prices via collusion The same prices is evidence enough of collusion to file charges. > In the US gouging is pretty much always legally defined as "raising prices by [xx%] in the immediate aftermath of a civil emergency on necessary items" I.e. they can file such charges whenever they like. Note that this does not take into account the cost of supplying these goods.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- notacoward 4y ago> All three price points are illegal. All potentially illegal, but more often legal and not even controversial. The important distinction is whether the prices were set to maintain or exploit a non-competitive situation, vs. to compete in a still fair/open market. There's no issue with undercutting competitors if they exist. There's no issue with charging a brand premium. In either case, competitors can respond as they see fit. It's only when there are no competitors that these choices deserve scrutiny.