2 ms·
I do not believe that it is acceptable to consider as equivalent actions the search through a house or other property, or a body search, with reading the memory
by adrian_b 4y ago
I do not believe that it is acceptable to consider as equivalent actions the search through a house or other property, or a body search, with reading the memory of a computer or of a smartphone or even with the reading of a (possibly encrypted) notebook.
Any external memory, regardless whether it is a flash memory, a magnetic disk, an optical disc, or just a piece of paper, is just an extension of the memory from your brain.
Admitting that there is a reason for anyone else but the owner to read a memory device is the same with admitting that they have the right to obtain any information that is stored inside your brain.
Even if for now the only technical means for obtaining the information stored in the brain is torture, that may change any time, if someone will ever discover how the biological memories are stored.
When that will happen, it will be too late to claim that physical search is not the same thing with reading memories, if this is not already established now.
Even this French court decision is just a method of using torture for obtaining the information stored in the brain memory of a person.
Because they can no longer use a good beating with "nerf de boeuf" for obtaining the information from the suspect, the beating is replaced as a torture method with the threat of imprisonment and of a huge fine, this being supposedly a more civilized technique.
- simonh 4y agoThe logical conclusion from that would be that destroying a persons notebook would be equivalent to violence causing brain damage, and so assault on a person. I’m aware of the theory of extended mind this notion is based on, and that’s not going to fly in any real world legal system any time soon. Even Clark and Chalmers that came up with the concept of extended mind don’t think that actually makes practical sense.