3 ms·
This might be a cultural difference. I'm from India. But 'poor' people have cars in America(From the photos)? You guys get $600 per month for doing nothing(Soc
by kamaal 15y ago
This might be a cultural difference. I'm from India.
But 'poor' people have cars in America(From the photos)? You guys get $600 per month for doing nothing(Social security)? Don't pay taxes and yet infrastructure benefits must reach you?
I don't really know what more the country can do for you guys. I mean paying individuals $600 per month for doing nothing, with which they can afford home, cars, food and clothing all this when the individual isn't even working.
I mean if this isn't sufficient, what is?
You really must come out of US and check the definition of 'poor' in other countries.
Here is a reason why you guys can never beat China. Because there people tend to be happy with ever little they get. But here in this case you have people complaining for stuff which is offered to them free at the first place.
P.S : I am software engineer here, who can barely afford a motorcycle and fuel. Let alone a car.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoBut 'poor' people have cars in America(From the photos)? About 70% of them. 25% actually have two or more cars. http://www.census.gov/prod/2008pubs/h150-07.pdf http://www.census.gov/prod/2008pubs/h150-07.pdf Forget learning what poor is in India, most Americans should come to India and see how the top 5-10% lives. Someone on welfare in the US probably has a nicer house than most people in Bandra or Koregoan Park. Sad but true.
- kamaal 15y agoSomeone on welfare in the US probably has a nicer house than most people in Bandra or Koregoan Park. Sad but true. I always think about this. That life in India and countries alike is so difficult, merely meeting the ends meet and getting yourself food, clothing and shelter requires you fight daily battles. I mean with farmers committing suicide, crores of people below poverty line. Hunger and Malnutrition in one part of country. Children starving to death. And middle class earning barely enough to survive. We still consider ourselves fortunate if we can get the basic stuff right. Now here some one is giving you $600 for doing nothing in a wonderful residence, food, clothing and shelter with a car to drive. And all the time in the world to spare. And people are complaining? I agree there is some corruption and scam going on in here, but really if you can buy a car you are anything but poor.
- mkr-hn 15y agoAre you seriously begrudging us for our country being able to afford a higher minimum standard? My family was briefly on SSI decades ago, but my parents worked hard to get to a point where we didn't need it to survive. No one wants to have to rely on the social safety net, but I'm glad it's there. And I really hope that some day your country will be able to provide basic protections against destitution to its poor.
- kamaal 15y agoNo I'm not. Seriously. I would hope some day my country has such a thing too! But I talking on the lines of gratitude. Gratitude is important. You can't really complain about stuff you got for free.
- mkr-hn 15y agoIt's not free. It's an insurance pool. People pay a little bit of their paycheck into it so they're not screwed if their life hits a speed bump and they have no money either due to poor planning or things outside their control.
- infinite8s 15y agoThe difference is you can still collect welfare (although not social security) even if you've never worked a day in your life (and you get even more if you have lots of kids). India and most other poor countries have no such social safety net. The point kamaal is making is that most poor people in the US live better than 70-80% of the population in India (even those considered "middle-class"). This is slowly changing as India's economy is modernizing, but there's still a long way to go before the standards of living between both countries will be anything close to par. As an aside, when I was in grad school in the US, my lab mate and I (both of us of indian descent, although born in the US) used to joke that for half our yearly stipend (about 25K) we could afford to hire a full time Ph.D. chemist in India to do our experiments while we slept. 10K USD in the India is considered middle/upper middle class.
- mkr-hn 15y agoSocial security is paid for by payroll taxes (making it closer to insurance than a handout). And those cars are old and not worth much. You could buy one after a few weeks of donating blood. Sewers and water are usually paid for by a fee or taxes. I could go and dispel more misconceptions for you, but I think you've read enough to know that you have a few things wrong and will wisely avoid judging the entirety of a nation's poor based on a single photograph. ETA: Most poor people have cars because most poor neighborhoods don't have any reasonably priced grocery store. It's cheaper to own a car (with all the potential it brings) than to shop locally.
- kamaal 15y agoI don't know much about America, but if you could afford a car by doing as simple a thing you mentioned than my friend you are in heaven. You have no clue how bad this part of the world is. Just come to Mumbai or any urban metro in India and see for yourself how people travel. Majority of them are herded like sheep in busy trains and buses. That is why I said, it might be just a cultural thing. Here too, we need to pay for water and sewers. But I understand that your barrier for entry when it comes to measuring poverty is very different than ours. By your definition 95% of whole India may fall into poverty.
- mkr-hn 15y agoIt's best not to assume people have no clue, even if it seems like they don't. Because I do have a clue. Many of them. I am laden with clues. I don't know the transportation situation in most poor places here, but I doubt it's good if people are choosing a car over a bus or train. I know the poorest places in this suburban town are a mile or more from the grocery store across dangerous roads, and the nearest mass transit option is 20 miles away.
- kamaal 15y agoI know the poorest places in this suburban town are a mile or more from the grocery store across dangerous roads, and the nearest mass transit option is 20 miles away. That doesn't even begin to describe poor according to my definitions of poor. But I agree, we have different yard sticks to measuring what exactly poor is.