3 ms·
In my opinion, one of the most fundamental human rights, maybe even the most important human right, is the right to refuse to answer to a question. Any law tha
by adrian_b 4y ago
In my opinion, one of the most fundamental human rights, maybe even the most important human right, is the right to refuse to answer to a question.
Any law that says that there are circumstances when humans must answer to a question otherwise they will be punished is wrong and abusive.
Obviously, when people are suspected to have done something illegal, but they refuse to give answers that might dis-incriminate them, then that can be used in conjunction with evidence that makes probable that they are guilty to conclude that they are indeed guilty and sentence them accordingly.
However, in such cases any punishment should be for the crime whose authors they are believed to be and not for refusing to answer any question.
I do not care if a bunch of mean or stupid people claim to "represent the will of the people" and they make Draconian laws that punish those who do not answer questions. I will never recognize that they have any right to make such laws and I pity the people that are so naive that they accept the existence of such laws.
I have been born and I have grown up in a country which was governed by a criminal organization which had received the political power from a foreign invading army, even if they also claimed that they have been elected democratically and they "represent the will of the people".
To maintain their power, the government imprisoned and killed any opponents, which were identified through mass surveillance.
Any honest citizen did not have any greater wish than to get rid of the government, but it was impossible to organize any kind of opposition, due to the mass surveillance and due to the confidential informers who infiltrated any institution or company.
In such a country, answering the truth to any question of a law enforcement officer could lead to grave consequences for other innocent people, from destroying their professional careers, up to even death.
A similar history was shared by all the countries in the Eastern Europe, but there are also many other such countries.
It worries me that after a decade when it seemed that the political conditions have greatly improved in many countries, after 2000 the actions of the governments from North America, Western Europe and Australia have become each year more and more similar to the actions of the former communist governments that they previously loved to criticize for their disregard of human rights, and the legal rights of the citizens of these countries have become more and more restricted, under various pretexts, such as "war on terror" or "save the children".
- bombolo 4y agoPerhaps you're not familiar with this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE
- FpUser 4y ago>"In my opinion, one of the most fundamental human rights, maybe even the most important human right, is the right to refuse to answer to a question" I agree 100%. Not respecting / recognizing the right of being silent and jailing people for that in my opinion is a crime itself.