3 ms·
Your example, to me, falls more in the category of "downvoted for retreading an old and tired discussion" than "downvoted for going against groupthink". Or, qu
by JoshTriplett 15y ago
Your example, to me, falls more in the category of "downvoted for retreading an old and tired discussion" than "downvoted for going against groupthink". Or, quite frequently, "downvoted for using HN as a soapbox rather than trying to contribute to the discussion". I find that the best comments in a discussion typically have at least some connection to the posted article, beyond simply discussing the same topic. The old and tired comments would work equally well in any number of other threads on different articles.
I don't tend to see groupthink as a problem in a community like HN. Sure, we tend to think about many things in the same ways (the ways we'd consider obviously right beyond any need for discussion, of course), but those tend to represent the boring topics anyway.
I do tend to follow the model you mention, ignoring mediocre stuff, rather than voting on everything. When I downvote things, I do indeed intend to suggest that people shouldn't bother reading it.
- billpatrianakos 15y agoFair enough. I'm not exactly an old hat myself. My account's less than a year old so maybe I'm totally off on this and it's me who should keep my mouth shut and learn a bit more. That said, I still think there's enough people who are karma police in that they hoard points and use the up/down vote system in not-so-honorable ways to merit some discussion about that. I also think there's enough group-think going on to merit mentioning too. I'll admit my example wasn't really solid but, hey, now that I said it maybe you'll be able to spot it next time and be able to come back and say I was right. Or wrong. But I'm decently confident it's prevalent enough to spot easily and quickly.