3 ms·
> Lets say you borrowed 1BTC from FTX exchange so that you can short BTC. Congrats, you're correct! You're technically worth a lot more US-dollars now. > You g
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
> Lets say you borrowed 1BTC from FTX exchange so that you can short BTC. Congrats, you're correct! You're technically worth a lot more US-dollars now.
> You go to FTX, and it stopped existing today. So you don't get your money.
What? That's not how shorting works. If you borrow 1BTC from FTX so that you can short BTC, you then actually perform the short by selling the 1BTC to some other party. Now you have two things: (1) cash; and (2) an obligation denominated in bitcoin. That is what it means to be short.
As soon as FTX stops existing, that's great for you, because it means you don't need to give them their 1BTC back. You got your money a long time ago.
- dragontamer 4y agoThat's probably not what happens in practice. 1. You never got the BTC to begin with. Its on FTX's platform, with a little database entry that says "User Bob has -1 BTC on margin on the books". 2. The cash never leaves FTX platform either. Because FTX needs to "margin call" (aka: grab your assets somehow) if the market moves against the short position. 3. So really, you're trusting that FTX is going to give you the money back eventually when you zero out all your position entirely. 4. Also remember: exchanges regularly grab the assets. So its not really FTX's bitcoin either. They probably took it from Alice to lend to you. 5. If you wanna say "Well, why doesn't Bob go to Alice directly for this transaction??", its because Alice doesn't trust Bob, and Bob has no trust of Alice, so the entire scheme would never work.