2 ms·
Scarcity is a major part of gold's value. Gold's value comes from being scarce and easily divisible. It means I can pay for something in an exact small bit of g
by pessimizer 4y ago
Scarcity is a major part of gold's value. Gold's value comes from being scarce and easily divisible. It means I can pay for something in an exact small bit of gold.
It doesn't have to be useful or pretty to do either of those things. That's the case for bitcoin being digital gold.
The problem with bitcoin is that it isn't significantly better than gold at doing either of those things, and obviously isn't any better than any other random unit in another distributed crypto ledger. You can create new crypto tokens so fast that people went from trading particular to issuing single instances of new tokens with NFTs.
Being useful and pretty just provides a baseline value; gold is never going to fall to zero. But the important part is that nobody is about to invent a new gold to compete with the old gold on the merits of scarcity and divisibility. Even though bitcoin when considered alone is a nice try, every other cryptocoin destroys its scarcity.
- nailer 4y agoIt’s really difficult to send gold or cash around the world in seconds for a fraction of a cent. They’re also hard to store.
- benj111 4y ago>Scarcity is a major part of gold's value. I'm not sure if you're conflating value and worth or missing my point. If there was only 1 Oz of gold and Mr X was willing to pay $1bn for it. Gold would be worth $1bn. But there's more than one ounce and the market clearing price is much lower than that. Mr X may still value an ounce $1bn, but he doesn't have to pay that, he gets a relative bargain. If no-one valued gold at $1 an ounce today, you shouldn't be willing to pay $1 if there was only 1oz. Supply just creams of the top people who value gold most highly. Scarcity just means you're creaming off a smaller higher valuing population. So scarcity doesn't give something value per se. Id agree in certain edge cases that scarcity does increase value. I'm not sure if gold is an example of not. There are other rarer elements that don't have the same cachet. But in general I don't think scarcity itself adds value.