3 ms·
As many others have pointed out, this is only true as a purchaser who has no contractual relationship outside of the sale. If Apple comes to you and says "paxy
by brookst 4y ago
As many others have pointed out, this is only true as a purchaser who has no contractual relationship outside of the sale.
If Apple comes to you and says "paxys, we just love you, we'll sell you everything for 50% off... but you have to sign a contract that you will only dispose of products by firing them into space", and you sign that contract, and they live up to the discount... surprise, you're on the hook for your part of the contact.
Apple has contracts with these resellers. It's called minimum advertised price (MAP) or retail price support. There is a long history of MAP/RPS being litigated in the US, and there are lots of twists and turns and valid opinions to be had.
But "first sale doctrine supersedes any contracts" is NOT correct.
- paxys 4y agoYes except this lawsuit has nothing to do with Apple authorized resellers. It is about "third-party merchants" on Amazon, who can be literally anyone. If I – having no prior agreement with Apple – decided to sell my iPad on Amazon, they would remove my listing because Apple didn't approve of it.
- TheHappyOddish 4y agoThey would remove it because it's incredibly likely to be stolen or a grey import, both of which cause big issues to Apple, Amazon and the consumer.