3 ms·
> it's a slow death unless the US gets more competitive It's a slow death no matter what. China has 3x the population of the US, and Chinese people are both ju
by pessimizer 4y ago
> it's a slow death unless the US gets more competitive
It's a slow death no matter what. China has 3x the population of the US, and Chinese people are both just as smart as Americans, and likely better educated. If the US has lost its lead, it's not getting it back.
- astrange 4y agoChina has a much worse demographic outlook than the US. https://www.axios.com/2019/07/03/demographics-decide-us-china-rivalry https://www.axios.com/2019/07/03/demographics-decide-us-chin...
- toomuchtodo 4y agoWe’re all racing to be last in population heat death.
- pessimizer 4y agoThere's no scenario in which an aging population reduces the size of the Chinese workforce to less than 3-4x the size of the US workforce.
- astrange 4y agoThe working/retired population ratio also matters; supporting your family might also make you less productive as a worker. (Speaking heartlessly and capitalistically.)
- dirtyid 4y ago>less productive as a worker SKR/JP/TW all have extreme work cultures relative to west for highend sectors that are globally competitive, society structuring labour to work 100% harder to be 10% better than your lax competitors is not "efficient" but still viable way to brute force into leadership. Heartless capitalism works. As for work/retirement dependency ratios - some considerations (and blame Zeihan for popularizing spasming over demographic pyramid and neglecting the politics in geoPOLITICs) there's a reason Chinese households have some of the highest house hold savings rate, most don't expect retiring with comprehensive safety net. CCP + citizens know they're not going to transition into developed high-income country with comprehensive welfare state anytime soon. Culturally and structurally PRC is relatively well calibrated to to weather a demographic decline, with likely a reversal in demographics when multiple inheritances starts concentrating into single children households once deaths > births in coming years. I'd expect baby & consumption boom especially among more affluent/educated regions with spare wealth. TBH I'd be more worried over developed west ALREADY breaking down from being unable to support onerous welfare obligations that's been getting worse with immigration. There's a reason protests over generational QoL decline is happening in west not PRC. IMO implementing these trial [0] community centers for elders is pretty much enough to keep Chinese seniors content - cheap meals is enough to bribe people who rememeber hunger - old people who can't vote nor have energy to protest. Combine with recent focus on building out pharma & medsci sectors with automation [1] and ability to negotiate cheap bulk med acquistions = CCP should be able to take care of elder on a pareto budget. Few are going to complain CCP won't be spending magnitude more resources to stretch life expectancy from already above average of 78 to "high" level of 80-84. Nor would CCP want that burden if speaking heartlessly and strategically. [0] http://sh.people.com.cn/n2/2021/1204/c134768-35035843.html http://sh.people.com.cn/n2/2021/1204/c134768-35035843.html [1] http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2021-08/12/c_1310123218.htm http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2021-08/12/c_1310123218.htm
- readthenotes1 4y agoYou are speaking realistically. I know several people trying to take care of elderly parents in different ways and it absolutely does take time just for the logistics. Taking care of an elderly parent is a massive undertaking to do in your own home and is still an effort if you hand them over to the state in a nursing home.
- legitster 4y agoI might really encourage you to read some Peter Zeihan. The Chinese economy has aged drastically the last decade, is coasting on fumes by manipulating its own currency, and is entirely dependent on whims of the global market for important commodity prices. To the extent that they pose any sort of economic threat to the US, it's because we let them by ensuring safe shipping lanes to the middle east for oil and letting them trade in dollars.
- yogthos 4y agoPeople like Zeihan have been saying this literally for decades. It's amazing anybody still listens to them.