3 ms·
I don't understand why certain skeptics take it upon themselves to be such nasty people. For example: "Then the site jumps into other crackpot ideas, like Tom
by cynicalkane 15y ago
I don't understand why certain skeptics take it upon themselves to be such nasty people. For example:
"Then the site jumps into other crackpot ideas, like Tom Gold’s abiogenic origin of petroleum (long ago falsified), and presents a list of 19th century naturalists who talked about dinosaurs because they allegedly made up their discoveries in order to promote evolution! Once again, this doofus is so ignorant of history that he has no idea that half that list consisted of devout individuals who were “creationists” and most of them worked on dinosaurs in a religious context. Not only that, but they were not trying to “prove evolution”—their work was done decades before Darwin’s book came out in 1859. Give this guy an “F” in history…."
The primary point of this paragraph appears to insult the person being talked about. The paragraph doesn't actually say anything, it's just a summary peppered with insults. Furthermore, it's very unlikely to convince anyone that doesn't already agree with the author.
It seems like there's a large part of the skeptic community that doesn't understand you can't be so purposelessly condescending and yet convince the unconvinced--especially when you're pretending to be some rational authority whilst being so foaming-at-the-mouth. Which is a shame, because skepticism is a fine cause.
- burgerbrain 15y agoIt is a form of release. Articles like these are not really about convincing believers, they are meant to be consumed by fellow skeptics. Downvoters: I'm explaining it, not defending it.
- ugh 15y agoI think ridicule is perfectly appropriate once the beliefs you are talking about get batshit insane. Ridicule is a powerful tool, not so much to convince those who already believe, rather to convince those thinking about believing or on the fence about whether to no longer believe. It’s also a powerful tool to remind everyone that batshit insane beliefs are still around and that it’s apparently easy for humans to believe in them. More specifically, I think it’s great to have both: People who painstakingly taken even the most batshit insane ideas serious and engage them on the same level and people who ridicule. That’s not a contradiction for me.