3 ms·
> Besides they're no longer their products, Apple lost ownership of them after they sold them. First sale doctrine is only for retail sales that have no contra
by brookst 4y ago
> Besides they're no longer their products, Apple lost ownership of them after they sold them.
First sale doctrine is only for retail sales that have no contract outside the sale.
In distribution, contracts can absolutely dictate terms. This is a good thing. It lets, for instance, Boeing require purchasers to properly maintain airplanes (it hurts Boeing when they fall out of the sky). It also lets manufacturers offer lower prices on the condition that products be displayed or promoted in certain ways. This is very common in retail ("we'll give you 5% off quantity 100 on the condition they're promoted in ads and an endcap in each store").
The Apple / Amazon example is resale price maintenance. There's some good background on US law in the area: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resale_price_maintenance#United_States_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resale_price_maintenance#Unite...
In this specific example, where the claim is that Amazon and Apple colluded to raise prices by only allowing authorized Apple resellers on amazon.com, I guess I'm kind of sympathetic to Apple. At least inasmuch as they can show that sales from unauthorized resellers generate more warranty/support/other expense, or brand damage from even worse stuff like fraud and counterfeits.
It seems like the real complaint is with the resale price maintenance in Apple's authorized reseller program. Which may be a fair complaint. But why not go after that? If the price maintenance is illegal, it should be illegal everywhere, not just Amazon. And if it's legal, it should be legal on Amazon as well.
- scarier 4y agoTo be fair, even if Boeing's legal team cuts the CYA maintenance clause out of the purchase agreement, absolutely nothing will change in terms of actual maintenance on the aircraft they sell. The FAA requires all certified aircraft flying in US airspace to be maintained in accordance with the manufacturer's approved instructions as a condition of airworthiness. Doesn't seem like a great analogy for consumer electronics sales.
- eptcyka 4y ago> I guess I'm kind of sympathetic to Apple. At least inasmuch as they can show that sales from unauthorized resellers generate more warranty/support/other expense Could you provide some proof for such statements?
- brookst 4y agoProof that I'd be sympathetic if they showed those things? That's a tall ask. But I promise I would be. Proof that authorized resellers in aggregate provide better service and therefore fewer escalations/expense to the manufacturer? I didn't make that claim for Apple specifically, but it seems plausible.
- bombolo 4y ago> but it seems plausible why? People working at apple stores are not more trained or more competent than people working in other stores.
- brookst 4y agoI think there's some confusion here -- "Apple Authorized Reseller" does not mean "Apple Store". B&H is authorized, Amazon is authorized, Walmart, Target, Best Buy, and T-Mobile are authorized resellers. There's a tiny local shop near me that's authorized. There are only ~500 Apple stores in the world. There are probably probably 100,000 authorized reseller locations (Walmart alone has 10,000 locations). Setting aside Apple, the reason companies set up authorized reseller programs is to control the customer experience, from price maintenance (the topic of this HN thread) to brand image to customer satisfaction with returns/refunds. Being authorized for any manufacturer is kind of a big deal; these companies pay for that arrangement, and there are often training requirements for staff, and minimum purchasing requirements, requirements for return/refund policies, and more. In return, the manufacturer steers business to these retailers and provides them with (often free) brand collateral, demo units, etc. So if a customer has a complaint, whether it's user error or defective product or a mistake by the retailer or just the customer deciding this product is not for them, there is a strong incentive for the retailer to do right by the customer to avoid jeopardizing their status as authorized. But if a customer needs help from a no-name reseller who has no direct manufacturer relationship, that reseller has little incentive to fix the issue. It's cheaper to just punt everything to the manufacturer, and there is no reason to do any extra work to protect the manufacturer's brand. And of course unauthorized resellers have a strong incentive to pass off refurbished or even counterfeit products as real. Lower cost, and there's no bridge to burn with the manufacturer. So all of that is why I think it's plausible that Apple, and other manufacturers, see increased costs and more negative brand experiences from companies that don't participate in their authorized reseller programs. I'm sure there are great indie companies that do everything right. But, in aggregate, at the scale of an Amazon.com, it seems reasonable for both Amazon and Apple to use the authorized reseller designation as a filter for sellers more likely to treat the customer well.
- ErikVandeWater 4y ago> In this specific example, where the claim is that Amazon and Apple colluded to raise prices by only allowing authorized Apple resellers on amazon.com, I guess I'm kind of sympathetic to Apple. This is false: “Ultimately Apple proposed, and Amazon agreed, to limit the number of resellers in each country to no more than 20. This arbitrary and purely quantitative threshold excluded even Authorized Resellers of Apple products.” Apple is alleged to have created an Agreement with Amazon that retroactively limited the marketplaces where Apple Authorized Resellers could sell Apple products.