13 ms·
Trolls (2008)
- chrishenn 15y agoI hope that trolling can be kept out of HN by the simple goodwill of the people using the site. I can't think of many forum systems that can effectively remove the incentive to troll. I put up a forum online for people in my journalism class. They're nice people, but something about the fact that the conversation was online turned the discussion into something pretty dumb. My hope is that people who grow up with the internet their whole lives will realize that you still have to be civil online. It's no different than real life, yet no one is teaching you manners online.
- watmough 15y agoI've seen some relatives' kids accounts on Facebook. I'm not sure I can be as optimistic as your last paragraph. If anything, I'm pessimistic that many kids are writing utter utter trollish garbage online that may never ever go away. Of course, there will be kids that are smart and don't do this, but kids that want to 'fit in' or 'be popular' may well end up rolling with the crowd and posting things that will hurt them later on. As parents, we should be looking out for our kids, both in real life, and online.
- chrishenn 15y agoThis may fit into the same category of way too optimistic, but I think it should be something that's in school, from an early age. My high school has a mandatory computer literacy test, but it only tests a few skills like MS Office or "What is an ethernet port?" It'd be nice if it taught stuff like "how not to be an idiot on the internet."
- oacgnol 15y agoWhen it comes down to it, many trolls feel the need to bash another language, OS, etc. because it's a form of self-validation: your choice says something about you. You'll see the same kind of thing with the "wars" over PC/Mac, Xbox/PS3, Emacs/vim, etc., even if the person doesn't really understand the differences: picking sides just seems to be natural. Unfortunately, as the article says, the anonymity of the Internet allows these thoughts to rapidly bubble to the surface, where in most cases there's little repercussions for posting whatever the hell you want. I've encountered very little of this attitude when it comes to meeting people in real life. For most people, it's hard to be a dick in front of a real life person.
- ericingram 15y agoI would say "fortunately" rather than "unfortunately", because it is the very mechanism that allows these ideas to bubble up that also allow very good ideas to bubble up rapidly. We don't need repercussions for posting bad content, as we will evolve powerful judgment to filter it. This is a natural market mechanism I think.
- mindstab 15y agoDo we have any more recent stats about the viewership of HN now for 2011? How big is it, and more subjectively, how do people feel we are doing with trolls? I for one think on the whole conversation is still good and worthwhile checking out :)
- karlzt 15y agohttp://ycombinator.com/newsnews.html#5oct2011 http://ycombinator.com/newsnews.html#5oct2011 "Also, a traffic update: HN now gets over 120k unique ips on a weekday, and serves over 1.3 million page views."
- libraryatnight 15y agoI'd love to read something like "Trolls: A followup" and hear PG's thoughts and stats three years later :)
- sambeau 15y agoI wonder how much worse road etiquette would be if we had no license plates? I suspect there is a reasonable argument against net anonymity hidden in the history of the motor car. Does anyone know what the tipping point for license plates was?
- cobrausn 15y agoLicense plates came into existence in the early 1900s in Massachusetts when they needed a way to tax people to repair and maintain their roadways, and vehicle registration was the way they decided to accomplish it. It was also proposed as a way of linking drivers with actions, as there was a rapid increase in the number of roadway accidents about that time. http://www.mass.gov/rmv/history/ http://www.mass.gov/rmv/history/
- sambeau 15y agoThe French had them long before that (in fact they had them before the automobile). But I suspect you are right: it was tax to maintain the roads that required each automobile to be numbered and registered.
- imgabe 15y agoI think license plates are roughly equivalent to an IP address. It gives you no incentive to be polite, but authorities can use it to track you down if you break the law.
- omarchowdhury 15y agoRoad etiquette would be worse if it weren't for the chance of death for messing up.
- tikhonj 15y agoI doubt it would be any different. Do you remember the license (gah, for some reason I hate spelling that word) plate of the last car that cut you off? If so, you are in the minority. Even if you knew the number, how would you correlate it with a face? I don't think the license plate number gives much in the way of identity. In fact, it gives less identity than your average username--it is usually completely random, created with no input on the part of the driver.
- oscilloscope 15y agoThat's 8,000 unique visitors per day? Didn't realize HN readership was so small. I catch people in San Francisco scanning new articles, but it must be location bias. http://www.google.com/trends?q=hacker+news%2C+reddit http://www.google.com/trends?q=hacker+news%2C+reddit Edit: That number was from 2008
- fferen 15y agoKeep in mind that this was in 2008.
- bennyfreshness 15y agoThat number is from 2008, when PG wrote the post. Today I bet its much higher, although still far below reddit. But like PG said, much better quality.
- Abundnce10 15y agoI wonder how many unique visitors per day HN is getting now. Is there any place I can find this info?
- memset 15y agoThis essay was written 3 years ago; readership has soared tremendously since then, to the point that sometimes PG's innocuous comments on the site are spun into Techcrunch headlines.
- jdp23 15y agoIn October, there were 120,000 unique IPs/day.
- Roedou 15y agoAs well as just search volume, Google has a surprisingly good handle on unique visitors to websites: http://trends.google.com/websites?q=reddit.com%2C+news.ycombinator.com&geo=all&date=all&sort=0 http://trends.google.com/websites?q=reddit.com%2C+news.ycomb...
- angersock 15y agoGood post, but as someone who dabbles in trolling as a hobby, I'd like to suggest the following: Trolls are important. Trolling, especially as seen on places like slashdot/4chan/somethingawful/etc., can oftentimes be a mechanism of critique for ideas and rhetorical styles. One of the best things about the 'net is that, frankly, none of this really matters. None of it. It's a big joke. My twitters and my wikis and my posts don't mean anything. They're bits in the stream. My karma is an int on a server somewhere, incremented and decremented by the whims of my fellow users. Trolls can help remind all of us that hey, this is all light-hearted. They say outrageous things, they stir up trouble, they cause annoyance, they sully the pristine conditions of these high-minded realms of discourse. In short, folks, they keep us all honest. They call us on our bullshit. And when a community takes itself so seriously that it becomes a habitat for trolls, it usually is a sign that that community needs to be dispersed, cleaned, and reformed elsewhere. HN is a pretty cool place, and I hope it lasts a long while before ossifying and becoming infested with trolls.
- kghose 15y agoBut how do we know the real trolls from the assholes? Emoticons help, but we can't see their FACE, so it's hard to tell.
- cobrausn 15y agoI'd imagine that those two are not a mutually exclusive set. Besides, if a troll makes a reasonable point, does it matter that he was actually trolling? Truthfully it's snark that bothers me most - I can deal with someone being playful or contrary for the sake of it, but too much snark just triggers a very primal part of my brain that makes we want to start cracking skulls, and that's not very conducive to continuing the discussion.
- angersock 15y agoThat's part of being a human, right? I am presented with another person's responses to my inputs in the form of communications, and I build a model of the person. Sometimes this model is correct, sometimes this model is incorrect. I might misjudge a person who is kind to my face as being decent, when behind my back they spread rumors and gossip. Similarly, I might have a coworker who always criticizes my approaches to problems, but is the first to stick up for me in meetings. Sometimes you judge rightly, other times wrongly, and in either event life goes on (real or virtual). This is just part of the human condition--and trolls remind us of this fact and the fact that sometimes you can't tell.
- sukuriant 15y agoPersonally, I "troll" in real life. It's usually among friends and just taunting them, lying to them, etc, for the purpose of teasing them. They're trolls too, and it's a bit of a game between us. Really, in communities I frequent, there are so many trolls, we troll them back. Perhaps we're using the term differently from how pg is?
- re_todd 15y agoI went camping with a group of lawyers once, and they were a lot like this too. They wanted to constantly argue and debate. They would even assert things that I knew they personally disagreed with, just to start an argument. If nobody was arguing, they'd get kind of tense and nervous as if some calamity was about to happen, and then starting a debate seemed to relieve everyone's tension. Seemed strange to me.
- ericingram 15y agoThat sounds like fun, I love debating
- shasta 15y agoI bet you're a master.
- ericingram 15y agoI'm OK at it, but it's the practice I enjoy.
- nickik 15y agoAgree, I hate nothing more then ChitChat. Sometimes I hear people talking in the train or something and the say nothing of substence.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- peter_l_downs 15y agoTop sentence according to bookshrink [1]: > There's a sort of Gresham's Law of trolls: trolls are willing to use a forum with a lot of thoughtful people in it, but thoughtful people aren't willing to use a forum with a lot of trolls in it. I think that pretty much sums it up. Trolls are attracted to the forums with the most interesting/intelligent users (the "best" forums). I think that news.yc has been very successful in terms of the amount of trolling that takes place, especially since: > The core users of News.YC are mostly refugees from other sites that were overrun by trolls. [1] http://bookshrink.com http://bookshrink.com
- rafedb 15y agoHonestly the hn community has degenerated into nothing more than a bunch of snobbish behavior that up/downvote things needlessly based upon that person's likes or dislikes, rather than on the validity of the content. Don't get me wrong, every site similar to this with voting eventually gets there, but lately it has started getting worse and worse. Which is why I am posting with this account because I am sure this comment will get plenty more downvotes! lol As I saw in another comment here I agree that trolls usually help make a community better. The voting system being used on comments rather than just the initial post to rank listing is much more of a hindrance to a community than trolls imo.
- mcrittenden 15y agoOP, you might want to change the title to show that this article is from 2008. That was confusing to me, and a few other people in this thread.
- fupeegee 15y agohey go fuck yourself pg. trolls will infest this site just as they will infest all sites. also, you are worthless. in 25 years after your death, almost nobody will remember you, or care if someone who does brings it to their attention, and in 50 absolutely no one will. you'll be remembered the same as the founder of ibm is today, which is, you won't be.
- scrrr 15y agoInteresting post. I find unsubstantial / uninteresting / obvious / superfluous comments (like "I love it!" <send>) worse than very controversial or insulting comments. As long as the general information in the forum stay interesting and enjoyable. Also isn't the "naughtiness" (some pg essay used that word I think) part of what some of the best contributors here have in common? And aren't entrepreneurs trolls, too, according to the OP's definition? They disagree with something, they choose a path that is more fun than an ordinary life, they want to leave a mark.
- scott_s 15y agoTrolls try to undermine a working system solely for their own enjoyment. That has only a superficial relationship to entrepreneurs, who try to create a new business.
- r00fus 15y agoThat is, until you realize that some of the biggest trolls are employed by the establishment media like John Dvorak, Rob Enderle, etc. These folks make a good living by essentially trolling. It's a well-known media business model.
- joelhaus 15y ago> Trolls try to undermine a working system solely for their own enjoyment. This is the most concise and accurate description of a troll on this thread (so far), thank you! As you state, this can result in undermining a working system, but more specifically, this selfishness and lack of empathy inevitably leads to: poor communication -> negative emotions -> unconstructive conflicts Selfish enjoyment really does get at the root of a trolls motivation, otherwise, "controversial" comments supported by sound logic, factual evidence and a genuine desire to get closer to the truth actually do add to the discussion. The real problem for a moderation system is determining if the motivation of the contributor is in line with the values of the community[1]. HN's rise in popularity and decline in quality commentary demonstrates how difficult it is to maintain the values of a community in the face of fast population growth (this just began to sound a bit too similar to arguments you hear in the immigration debate). If it's important to maintain your values, then it might also be important to mandate some level of assimilation in order to acquire certain privileges. The stackexchange sites have a fairly complex system for this and I rarely see trolls there, maybe HN should implement something similar? [1] http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html, HN's Values
- anonymoustrolol 15y agoWith the recent adoption of voting systems in forums (like this one) we are seeing troll comments often buried, and this will perhaps continue to discourage that behavior. On a bigger note, articles that draw clicks with bold conclusions or headlines (like that nerd baiting article we saw on Gizmodo) are still grabbing eyeball share and thus will continue to propagate instead of real news/information. How that fight for eyeballs is resolved is one that I don't really see a solution to yet.
- hansy 15y agoThis is an interesting article that sort of answers a question I've had for a while: would the quality of Hacker News remain the same without the novelty of individual karma points? PG mentions that people seeing "...their reputation in the eyes of their peers drain away..." is motivation enough to keep delivering high-quality content.
- larrys 15y ago'PG mentions that people seeing "...their reputation in the eyes of their peers drain away..."' I think part of the lure of karma is simply getting affirmation that what you are saying is accepted by others. In this case the "others" are not people you know but people you respect in many ways because of the intelligent way they write or some other power they have. Or how they appear at least to be accepted by the group. In a sense it becomes a challenging game to write something striking a balance between sharing some knowledge or opinion and not ticking off others by going to far out of bounds with what you are saying. "quality of Hacker News remain the same without the novelty of individual karma " I don't think it would at this scale. On a smaller scale though it might. There is a wide range of topics and people here. On a smaller site (AVC.com comes to mind with usually 1 idea a day posted) it is a core of users and while there is karma and likes it is far less important than on HN.
- robbrown451 15y agoI think the fact that you don't allow downvoting posts contributes to this. I get that you want to keep things positive. But when you don't provide an outlet for people who want to simply disagree without forcing them to come out of the woodwork and defend their position, it is inevitable that some people will come out with a lot of ugliness. I think there are a whole lot of reasons internet forums are different than real life communication. I think there are technical solutions that can change the balance. We all know there is a big difference between, say, the comments on YouTube and the comments on Slashdot. Do you think it is all "culture"? I don't. I think it is mostly that Slashdot has technical solutions that discourage trolling (and substanceless posts, etc), while YouTube doesn't. If the culture is different, it mostly because of the karma system (or lack thereof).
- scott_s 15y agoUsers can downvote posts, but only users with karma above a certain threshold. No user can downvote a submission, though - you can only flag them.
- robbrown451 15y agoYeah, well probably most trolls don't ever get that karma, so they troll instead. Also karma doesn't count for a lot here (that being one exception). Ultimately, a good karma system should simulate the what happens in the best real world environments....where there is a very complex feedback loop that reinforces the sort of behavior we want and suppresses that which we don't want. In my opinion Slashdot comes kind of close, but it has huge flaws itself.
- wpeterson 15y agoTrolling is the spice or salt that keeps things interesting. Too much can definitely turn everything brackish. But seeing some humor/sarcasm even if it's pointed mixed in with all of the serious discourse keeps it all manageable.
- Tomis 15y agoYou shouldn't have posted something positive about trolling. Now mind the downvotes. This reminds me of an old phrase - "fish swimming against the current gets electrocuted".
- _pius 15y agoPlease add (2008) to the headline.
- biznickman 15y agoReally only 8,000 a day? I've received 10,000 visitors from a single post on hacker news ... am I missing something? I definitely do agree however that the conversation on this site is top notch.
- chris_gogreen 15y agoDoes PG see trolls today in the same light as he did in '98?
- eric-hu 15y agoAlmost every day I use HN, I wonder why it hasn't implemented collapse-able comments, comment sorting by rank, and auto-collapsing comments. I understand this could introduce agreement bias, but I feel like that's something that could be fixed by tweaking the numbers (i.e. only auto-collapse comments with -20 votes). As it is now, it's easy to game the comments thread by piggybacking off the top comment of a post. This can be abused for trolling or just plain discussion visibility (unfairly, IMO).
- rjd 15y agoThere is a couple more cases which add to the mix. 1) Devils advocate. People that interject with an opposing view, even one they don't believe. I often do this one myself cause another poster to go into deeper description. Often just asking for an deeper response will be ignored, but opposing a view will always bring out an argument. 2) Denial and Righteousness. Essentially nasty fan boys. People who have brought into a belief and refuse to acknowledge any second point of view at all. I had this explained at a trolling seminar at a hacking conference quite well and they picked on the audience themselves to explain how to manipulate IT people. With most IT people they have the myers-briggs archetype finishing with --TJ. This means they are thinkers and judgmental. They will look at a problem, find the evidence, evaluate it, and make a judgmental decision on what is correct. The facts don't lie. However the facts can be like quantum variables, you chang angles and then entire structure changes. Making judgmental calls leads to obvious one set of true factual analysis being completely wrong in another setting. Challenging a judgmental person is challenging there core makeup. Saying they are wrong undermines there very basic personality, drawing on the opposing variable to "thinking" on the myers-briggs scale "feeling". So intelligent people do not react with intelligence first. Instead of reacting with an "oh ok I didn't realize that was the case in your area" they respond with a protective "I don't think so Tim" and things go down hill from there, especially if the second person is also judgmental. 3) Tribalism. This is the us vs them mentality. Either you are with us or against us. A non ordained view/comment against a group of people who maybe self validating can be seen as a extremely contrasting. Becomes the group has created a false sense of security it can draw out primal responses (like feeling over thinking mentioned above) when that sense of security is threatened. Many groups become polarising and when confronted with opposing views become more and more fundamental, close ranks. This often forms tight knit groups but also leads to a side effect of making everyone an enemy, including people with in the group who aren't are right as they should be, or people with neutral opinions. There was an article I read a week or two go about how to talk skeptically to people. If I can find it I'll post it. It addresses how to oppose a view and avoid the bottom two responses.
- 3pt14159 15y agoSort of meta-related (in that I'm disagreeing with your facts, and therefore the judgement changes): I disagree that most hackers are --TJ types. They are more likely to be -NT- with a bend towards INT-. The N is _the_ trait that tends to abstractionism, so it would make little sense for a hacker to be -S-- at all. If you look at the polls here it comes out in spades: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=943722 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=943722 The reason that we argue is that as Rationalists, the truth is more important than anything except for the fact that there is a truth. It is why Rationalists are likely to pick up an Aristotelian view of the word (though that might be a tautology since I think it is an axiom of that worldview). There is a reason why people are not usually grouped in the --TJ category (the broad categories being -NT-, -NF-, -S-J, -S-P). The reason is that the most important variable, the one that correlates to income, happiness, intelligence is the second letter. It fundamentally effects how you approach the world.
- scottmcleod 15y agoTrolls can play an important role in discussion but often only when they play devils advocate. I think 75% of trolling is bruised ego's lashing out.
- guscost 15y agoThere are few feelings on this Internet better than the one you get while "spending" points on something that needs to be said.
- hooande 15y agoI think the reason that troll behavior seems so much worse online is because most of us spend our time in environments where trolls are self-selected out. Assuming that most of us don't regularly deal with assholes in our work and home life, the place we're most likely to interact with them is online forums. I'm not sure that anonymity or distance are the driving factors in online trolling. Most of the assholes I know have no problem saying mean spirited things when they're standing right next to me. I think the bigger issue is that it's easy for me to avoid those assholes in real life. In an online setting, I can't see them coming and they are Legion...for every one that we vote down, two more will rise up to take its place. I understand Paul's frustration, but I don't know if we'll be able to find a technical solution. I think this is just one of the drawbacks (balanced by many benefits) of unfiltered communication.
- troll24601 15y agoI've trolled. I blame two things: frustration, and myself. I would get frustrated that there was no reward (and often there was punishment) for correcting errors in others posts. It's incredibly rare to see a rebuttal followed by the original poster simply saying "I was wrong about that, thanks for the information." It's far more common for the OP to simply insult you, or mischaracterize your argument, or otherwise engage in nonsense as their response. I would get frustrated that comments and posts are promoted on style, not substance. I would get frustrated that substance was judged inaccurately; often resulting in people whose knowledge was either entirely absent, or only Google deep arguing fiercely with people who'd worked and studied the topic for years. I would get frustrated at the general lack of respect for truth, for civility, and for each other. I would get frustrated at pedantry. I would get frustrated at double-standards and hypocrisy, with people posting uncited nonsense, but demanding citations from their opponents. I would get frustrated at debate opponents who would willfully misrepresent their opponents side in the argument. I would get frustrated that semi-plausibly-deniable passive-aggressiveness was accepted by moderators, but direct responses to that aggression were not. I would get frustrated that sticky lies beat dry truth every time, in votes and moderation. And once I got frustrated, I lost respect for the forums, but I didn't leave them. I liked what they could be, but not what they were. So I trolled. I disrespected people who, I felt, were being assholes in one way or another and thus "had it coming". This wasn't a great response, and for this I blame myself. I should've done something more constructive with my time. The forums are going to revert to the mean with or without my help; there's no need for me to accelerate the reversion.
- int3rnaut 15y agoI wonder if there's an age and cultural divide when assessing trolls on the internet. I say this in that reading the post, and then the comments from you all-- I see a bit of disparity between philosophies. I mean, for the most part I think from it's very root, trolls are trouble makers, and we can all sort of agree on that. But, there are people here who revel in that, see a symbiotic nature (good needs evil), people who think trolls are important, and that they keep things interesting--people who've even been trolls (full disclosure, when I was younger and immature I partook in such acts...nothing malicious, but acts none the less). When I read things like this I wonder where and at what time these people were introduced to the internet and forums and the like. A lot of younger people (at least the ones I know) are familiar with the trolling culture, and share many of the same previously mentioned opinions, however when I think of my Dad who was introduced to things much earlier when the internet was much more "pure", he loathes such things, "there's no place for that". As a non-formal study, purely for my curiousity would anyone interested write down their age, the time when they were introduced (ballpark it) to the internet and forums, and their stance on trolls.
- boredguy8 15y agoI think one particular line got me thinking: Graffiti happens at the intersection of ambition and incompetence: people want to make their mark on the world, but have no other way to do it than literally making a mark on the world. Paul Graham has to make a caveat because it's too easy for someone to say, "WELL, sir, you have clearly missed that some graffiti is amazing. Banksy!" But there's a very important filter that should kick in: "Can I trivially amend his point in such a way that his argument still holds?" It turns out that I can, and PG should never have need to caveat his statement. Let me propose, for what it's worth, that a "Banksy!" reply to a statement like the one above is the sort of accidental troll that invites the slow degradation into real trolls. Whether or not Banksy is graffiti or whether or not graffiti is art: these aren't the question of the submission. This isn't to say that tangents are always bad. It's rather that these sorts of discussions quickly turn in to "what color should we paint the dog house?"* That is: lots of firmly-held beliefs with little that can dissuade someone. So: when posting why someone is wrong, first see if there's a small or trivial way in which you can 'fix' their point. If you can, their point wasn't really broken in the first place. *I've long been trying to find the original 'why meetings go bad when you're talking about something everyone has an opinion on', but I can't. If anyone can help me out: much appreciated.
- kd5bjo 15y agohttp://bikeshed.com/ http://bikeshed.com/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson%27s_Law_of_Triviality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson%27s_Law_of_Trivialit...
- benvanderbeek 15y agoI'm truly impressed at how you stated the point about Graffiti / Banksy while simultaneously explaining why it doesn't really have any bearing on the topic at hand.
- jpd 15y agoI'd argue that broken analogies are worth mentioning. They do not change the caliber of the point being made by the orginal author, but it is worthwhile to bring it to their attention so that they may fix it later.
- joejohnson 15y ago>> I've thought a lot over the last couple years about the problem of trolls. It's an old one, as old as forums, but we're still just learning what the causes are and how to address them. That's crazy. We still don't know what causes Trolls?
- joejohnson 15y agoAh, never mind: this article is 3 years old.
- finnw 15y agoDoes that make a significant difference? What have we learned about trolling in the last 3 years that we had not already learned in the previous 15 years?
- joejohnson 15y agoI don't know. I'm not sure if there have been any break throughs recently determining where the trolls came from.
- cwilson 15y agoI'm curious if anyone else is seeing a trend of passive aggressive, or light hearted, "trolling" on social networks with family and friends. For example, on Facebook, a troll might play out like this: Sarah posts "Having the worst day ever, ugh!" David "likes" this post. Link baiting, tagging people places they are not actually at, and other forms of this exist as well. At least in a few of my friend circles they do. In fact, at one point, one of my friends and co-founders created a Facebook group called "Operation Troll Cullen". He invited around 20 of our mutual friends, and the idea was to respond to anything I said or posted with extremely positive messages. "You're doing so great Cullen! Well done!" or "This was the MOST insightful, amazing, article I have ever read. Thank you so much for sharing Cullen, you're amazing!" would be two examples. I of course had no idea this was going on, but suspected something was amiss. It was quite the week for me, to say the least (and I did find it quite funny, after the fact).
- chris_gogreen 15y agoSometimes the trollish comments on articles/threads/posts are more entertaining and enjoyable that the content itself.
- interlagos 15y agoI've been hellbanned here on HN on at least three different IP addresses and accounts...that I am aware of. Probably more. In each case nothing I'd ever said would be considered trolling by any rational observer. Here on HN, however, as with most communities where you start to recognize the regulars (tptacek, raganwald, etc), "trolling" is redefined to simply mean "going against the grain". There was one discussion that I participated where I predicted that Apple would see declining profit margins due to increased competition. Remarkably this completely benign, seemingly obvious observation saw me declared a troll, and shortly thereafter yet another account was hellbanned from HN (whatever the mechanism -- is this the verdict of a bored PG, or has he anointed some particularly under-employed members to apply it? -- it is horribly broken). Troll is, more often than not, a term used to circle the wagons.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- vaksel 15y agowhat does hellbanned look like on HN? Can't login? Can't post? Can post, but noone can see it?
- tshtf 15y agoYou can post, but by default no one besides you can see it. To the poster, it just appears as a normal comment. Turn on "showdead" to see posts from hellbanned users.
- Sukotto 15y agoMy go-to commentary on this general topic is the classic penny-arcade comic "John Gabriel's Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory" (Normal Person) + (Anonymity) + (Audience) = (Total Fuckwad) http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/3/19/ http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/3/19/
- psn 15y agoI hate this cartoon. it leads real name requirements on sites, in the hope of removing anonymity. This hurts all sorts of groups (see the google+ real names saga for a long list) but doesn't really slow down trolling. You can and do see people making racist / sexist / whatever comments with their real name. Possibly the trolls know that there are many John Smiths in the world. Its a "theory" thats been disproven by this point.
- billswift 15y agoMore generally: (Normal Person) + (Wrong Situation) = (Oops) See: Banality of Evil http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banality_of_evil http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banality_of_evil and, http://www.radioopensource.org/hannah-arendt-and-the-banality-of-evil/ http://www.radioopensource.org/hannah-arendt-and-the-banalit...
- billpatrianakos 15y agoI like the measures HN has in place to combat trolling. Karma, up/down votes, the downvote threshold, dead links, etc. are all really good and seem to work. The biggest thing though is just making sure everyone understands the kind of unspoken spirit of the site. I'd also argue that we want to keep this place kind of hushed as not to attract too broad of an audience. What I don't like that I have seen a lot of, is what I like to call "karma police". People who abuse the downvote button to silence perfectly valid comments that they just happen to disagree with. That's a problem. I think we need to be more judicious about the up and down votes. It's easy to just up vote something with a title we agree with but does it really call for it? I liken it to how easy it is to press the Facebook like button everywhere. As for downvotes, that button should be reserved for off-topic, vulgar, or otherwise obvious trolling cases and not just because "I didn't like what he said, he's stupid, or whatever".
- JoshTriplett 15y agoThe downvote button means, literally, "this comment should appear less prominently, and its author should get a very small penalty for having written it". Similarly, upvote means, literally, "this comment should appear more prominently, and its author should get a very small reward for having written it". With that in mind, "perfectly valid" takes on a different light. While sometimes downvoting does get used to reinforce groupthink, sometimes it just thwacks a comment with incorrect but authoritative-sounding information, or an off-topic comment, or a rehash of an well-known unresolvable debate (valid or otherwise), or in general a comment which will produce more heat than light. In this case, I disagree with your comment, but I've upvoted it because I think it deserves more prominence and more discussion. Can you give an example of the kind of comment which you think received unwarranted downvotes?
- billpatrianakos 15y agoSure, the examples I remember usually come up whenever there's a discussion over copyright and piracy. What I'll see is a discussion about whether piracy really hurts anyone with people arguing that it's free marketing and people who pirate wouldn't buy anyway. Then someone comes along and the subject moves on to open source vs free software. Someone says piracy is good because all software should be free. Then a bunch of people pile on and agree. Then one guy comes along saying that software companies aren't evil and developers should be able to charge for their work and piracy is bad. He is then downvoted to hell not because he said something off topic but because he held an unpopular opinion. I actually totally agree with you and the other responder to my comment. Now that you guys have said something I feel like I should rhrase and simply say that sometimes I feel like the up and down vote buttons are sometimes abused. I hate to see group think win the day. I really think the downvote button is a great way to show people that what they're saying isn't okay around here. Downvoted comments get frayed out and are almost unreadable. That's a signal that the comment isn't worth reading at all more so than "it deserves less prominence". So instead if we just up vote the good stuff, ignore mediocre stuff, and downvote bad stuff, then I think we'd be helping to show participants what kind of community this is in a better way. The real trolls get punished. The guys who are boring won't be offended and will be more apt to contribute better stuff next time if you just give them no points at all.
- metachris 15y agoWhich means that once trolling takes hold, it tends to become the dominant culture. That had already happened to Slashdot and Digg by the time I paid attention to comment threads there, but I watched it happen to Reddit. Reddit actually has a fascinating, rich culture. Trolling is just a part of it, but the community seems to be managing.
- iambvk 15y agoYes, I think reddit is not as bad as many think. Given the huge size of reddit community, I guess, reddit has managed to retain a high quality humor and knowledge (eg: r/askscience). Their fu is one of the best source of innovative comics I ever found.
- daenz 15y agoThe fact that official moderators (read: people with super-user powers) are needed on a forum indicates that the regulating powers are broken by design. Back in late 2009 I built a forum that allowed every user to temporarily ban any other user. There were restrictions... bans lengths were temporary (and voted on democratically), expiring after the voted time limit, you could only ban a person you replied to, and everyone would be able to see that you were the person who banned the parent post. Other than that, the forum was completely anonymous, and it was able to regulate large numbers of trolls (mostly from 4chan). They seemed to appreciate the equality and the natural regulation.
- firefoxman1 15y agoI was thinking along the same lines yesterday about why there are so many negative comments online and not offline. I think one of the main reasons (that PG didn't cover) is that in the real world, people associate together in groups. Nobody wants to be around a negative person, so not only does the negative person have a minimal negative impact on the people around him (since no one will listen), but the main problem arises when he gets online. Not only is this troll frustrated that no real people will listen to his negativity, but when he jumps online he's equal to everyone else. There are no groups. Nobody looks at his username like they would his face in the real-world and says "oh he's an ass, don't listen to him." I think it's partially because faces are easier to remember than usernames, and partially because we associate a whole personality with a face so we can avoid this person next time. When everyone's equal they each have the same impact. This would be a beautiful system if there was 0 negativity online because the new guy with great ideas would be heard just as well as a 10-year online veteran. But in the online social world its strength seems to be its weakness. How am I supposed to know if the person commenting is a really cynical person or a constructive criticism-type person until I've fully read his comment, and by then he's already made his impact on me. I don't think modern social networks have this problem as much though. I only socialize with my real friends on FB, Twitter, and G+.
- phzbOx 15y agoThere is a difference between trolling, making a funny statement and saying a contrived opinion. On HN, all of these get down-voted equally. Often time, I find something funny, say it as a comment, and get down-voted. It's not a stupid joke or something inappropriate, just a comment that'd make the reader smile. And I know it's hard to judge because I keep saying the score of these comments oscillating (I.e. people upvote it because it's funny, and people downvote it because it's funny (or they don't find it funny.)) About contrived opinion, that one is sad. There's a difference between something wrong and saying your opinion. For instance, someone saying "I don't like Backbone.js because x, y, z" will get on average a really small or negative score. Why? People who agree with this statement in small minority +x, people who disagree with this statement but agree that it was some good arguments and points: +y, majority of people who disagree with the statement -z. It just so happen that z>(x+y) with controversial statements. Lastly, trolling is more about searching for trouble or pissing of people. For instance, they'll say "Wtf, stop wasting your time with perl. It's a DEAD LANGUAGE, WAKE UP". This kind of posts should just get deleted and the user warned and then banned from HN imo. Note that there're a couple of wrong things with this statement. First, it's extremely aggressive and provocative. Personally, I hate this but some well known people act like that and are really appreciated so I won't judge. Secondly, there's no argument or fact.. it's just trash talking without ground to base yourself on. Lastly, there's usually lots of words in caps and 'wtf' 'lol' 'trololol' which make it look unprofessional for readers of HN used to read well written text. (Ironically, I know this current text isn't well written but it's because english is not my main language, not because I'm trying to skip words or be unprofessional). Anyway, what I'd suggest is to have a way to differentiate between theses. 1- A 'flag as spam/troll/non-respectful'. 2- A +1 (like what we have) to say this is an interesting post/comment. 3- A Agree/Disagree button to express your opinion. So basically, someone saying "You guys are fucking stupid; 1+1=2" would be flagged as unrespectful but could still be valid and agreed by the majority. But in the end, is it worth it? As they say in engineering, it it works, don't fix it. HN is not perfect, but I still enjoy reading the comments and I learn quite a lot.. is it worth trying to fix it for a minority of trolls or disrespectful people?
- skybrian 15y agoEven if they're funny, posts that consist only of a joke generally aren't allowed. They'd be more appropriate for Reddit. Hacker News posts are supposed to have some substance to them. (You're seeing fluctuations because not everyone knows this.)
- alexcharlie 15y agoFacebook has an interesting solution to the content quality problem, and trolling is a very specific type of content quality problem. Positively reinforce good content and HIDE everything else. The "Like" button accomplishes this well. If you've used facebook for a few years, you might remember the introduction of the "Like" button. Facebook before the "Like" button was very different from a UGC perspective. People did a lot more bitching and moaning. People posted much more inane ramblings about what they ate for lunch lunch or random happenings in their day. The "Like" button created a positive reinforcement loop and consciously or not people started to try to post content that would get more likes. Someone being emo about their shitty boyfriend or girlfriend is probably not going to get likes, probably wont get surfaced in the news feed and will never be heard. Eventually when people stop seeing those posts they are less compelled to post those things themselves. Facebook describes this as the virtuous cycle of sharing. Someone posts something, they get patted on the back. YOU see their post and their pats on the back and you tend to want to do the same thing. If you have friends on twitter and friends on facebook, just put the two feeds up next to eachother. You'll see a HUGE difference in the types of updates that people post.
- zerostar07 15y agoDownvoting is a sort of trolling too. People don't like unconventional opinions here. Say something bad about the late S. Jobs and you re certain to be buried. Even scientifically proven facts get buried sometimes. The problem is not solved. Let's try something radical, like, ban all adjectives.
- efsavage 15y ago"The conversations on Reddit were good when it was that small." When reddit was small, it was full of, and dominated by, crackpots. It was barely even at the level of being entertaining, and I'd hesitate to call it a community at all. Intentional trolls generally don't mess with crackpots, for some reason. I don't know if it's because it's too easy or unsatisfying, but the trolls usually come with mainstreaming. (There are still lots of crackpots there, but it's gelled to a far more coherent community that is much more fun to incite).
- jvandenbroeck 15y agoWell because down voting influences karma I'm probably posting 70% less than I would. I see HN more like a news site in which I sometimes share my view on something but not to comment or to discuss something (sadly). First I saw HN as something to have an intelligent discussion, but after a few "controversial" posts, and having negative karma, I don't bother. I only post something when I think it's "safe" to post, or when I have time to write a detailed essay. I think some people can have an intelligent discussion on HN, not for me, maybe because of my dyslexia I'm bad with words. But then again, maybe that's the price to pay to keep the trolls away.
- nickik 15y agoWell I think on a blog post with the title 'php suckx!' there want be an intelligent discussion but when there is something about a cool project you sometimes get good discussions. For example the resent post about the Facebook Jit: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3348853 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3348853
- edw519 15y agoDiscussions like this remind me of my favorite scene from "Roadhouse", the best bad movie ever. Discussion forums are kinda like bars and hackers are kinda like coolers... All you have to do is follow three simple rules. One: never underestimate your opponent. Expect the unexpected. Two: take it outside. Never start anything inside the bar unless it's absolutely necessary. And three: be nice. Come on. If somebody gets in your face and calls you a cocksucker, I want you to be nice. OK. Ask him to walk, be nice. If he won't walk, walk him. But be nice. If you can't walk him, one of the others will help you. And you'll both be nice. I want you to remember that it's a job. - It's nothing personal. - Uh-huh. Being called a cocksucker isn't personal? No. It's two nouns combined to elicit a prescribed response. What if somebody calls my mama a whore? Is she? (laughter) I want you to be nice... ..until it's time to not be nice. Well, how're we supposed to know when that is? You won't. I'll let you know. Sometimes we hackers work too hard to make things more complicated than they need to be. Be nice. (Oh, and by the way, I'm letting you know now when it's time to not be nice here: never.)
- jshen 15y ago"Sometimes we hackers work too hard to make things more complicated than they need to be." tl;dr: maintaining an online community is anything but simple. I'm not sure exactly what you mean. One possibility is that you're referring to the hackers that build communities online who try to establish some sort of guidelines for behavior. If this is what you meant then I think I disagree. I've tried a very similar experiment to pg's with HN. I run a small community site http://yakkstr.com http://yakkstr.com and most of the users came from an older site called soulcast. soulcast had no rules and it degenerated exactly as expected and was full of trolls in no time. My entire goal was to recreate that site minus the trolls, and I ruthlessly enforced one simple rule. Do not directly insult other users of the site. (actually two rules: no porn, illegal stuff, or spam) Simple right? Not really. I loved pg's child metaphor, and just like a child the trolls from the old site, who are smarter than actual children, do everything they can to find the limits to what is allowed, and they hover right around that line. As soon as they think you're going easy they push it farther. One example, people like to argue about politics on yakkstr and one of the trolls uses a pattern of associating a label like "liberal" to someone then they insult the label. Moronic ideas for liberals, liberals are morons, etc, etc. Technically he's not violating my rule, but it's very hard to define an explicit rule to deal with such instances because you want to allow people to sometimes say controversial things about generic groups. The problem arises when someone gets offended and reacts by directly insulting the savy troll. How do you deal with it? Not so easy. And occasionally a good user gets made at something and calls someone a moron. It leaves a bad taste in their mouth if you come down with an iron fist on them. I don't have good answers to these problems, but I think the hard work is working out pretty well for my little community. But it is complicated and requires constant vigilance.
- sytelus 15y agoCurrency in the economy of trolls is attention. When forums are small, trolling is much less rewarding and vice versa. Troll economy also feeds on to itself and upvoting/downvoting/karma mechanisms would be less and less effective as forum membership grows. To boost the attention economy, trolls would resort to upvote each other more frequently eventually outweighing votes of others. From theoretical perspective this is very similar problem to links and webpages. A troll is equivalent to a spammy web page. Upvotes/downvotes are equivalent to traffic you get on your web page. When UserA upvotes UserB, a link is created between two. The goal of a troll is to get as much traffic as possible. They are incentivised to give each other upvotes in the hope of return favor, or in other words, create as many links to each other as possible. It would be mistake to think that few "good guys" can be used as gate keeper to protect the system against these trolls. In nutshell that is the hope and approach many early search engines had and they failed as the size grew out of their hands. The solution has to be technical and automated. Algorithms like PageRank or machine learning models is highly applicable to trolling issue. For instance, the real value of karma should not be a naïve count of upvotes (in the same way that real important of the page is not how many other pages points to it) but rather who has upvoted it. I think algorithms like PageRank can be easily applied to calculate the value of karma. If trolls upvotes each other 1000 times, their net karma would be much less than 1000 de- incentivising them for putting in the efforts for upvoting. Of course, there are many ways to fool PageRank and but I think algos like this should be sufficient for forums were you don't have to deal with more sophisticated folks like search marketers.
- adnam 15y agoI used to be able to "flag" posts on HN, but a few weeks ago that right appears to have been revoked. No idea what I may have done wrong; perhaps I'm a "troll" and I don't know it?
- seiji 15y agoSame thing happened to my account a few months ago. I recall having a few bad days where I was, perhaps, overzealous in flagging what I considered inane or wrong or groupthink or low quality self-promotional drivel. Having your features pared down is a fine line between "we're doing this for your own good to save you from yourself" and "we think your input is less valuable than everybody else here."
- burgerbrain 15y agoI flagged every single steve jobs article the day after his death... which happened to be every article.... My ability to flag articles has since been revoked. To be honest, it felt good. Made me feel like I had been heard. Shot down, sure, but still heard.
- adnam 15y agoActually, I think this is exactly what happened to me!
- TomGullen 15y agoI'm quite a big fan of a well placed witty troll. It's one of the most delicate, subtle and hilarious forms of humour. That's when it's done well however, not all trolls are like that. Some of the heartiest laughs I've ever had are sourced from trolls. My troll spotting ability is falling at the wayside though. I used to be really good at spotting trolls, nowadays I come across something every now and think, "Is he trolling?". And that's the beauty of the best trolls, they border on insanity but keep it just within the realms of believability.
- switz 15y agoHN is great because you can say controversial things and still get voted up. Most comment voting systems are often: agree (vote up) or disagree (vote down). HN seems to be more along the lines of: Does this comment make empirical sense or is this person talking out of their ass.
- zhazam 15y agoWhat about HN voting specifically prevents the first case (agree/disagree) from happening?
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoOne might worry this would prevent people from expressing controversial ideas, but empirically that doesn't seem to be what happens. When people say something substantial that gets modded down, they stubbornly leave it up. What people delete are wisecracks, because they have less invested in them. I am not seeing this any more on HN. This is the second time I read this essay, and my concerns are still the same: people who have minority opinions might not be able to express them in such a polite way as to be considered "thoughtful" by the majority. I'm a bit of a contrarian commenter. That's because forums such as this one naturally gravitate to extremes. The programmer who lost his dog, and suddenly everybody is looking for him. The news story that causes us to be concerned about an intrusive government, and suddenly everybody sees Nazis everywhere. People in groups naturally gravitate towards extremes. Whether they are right or wrong, other people may choose to try to persuade them of their error (and most times, the crowd is wrong because it takes things too far). In a highly-emotional discussion, it is almost impossible to convince the crowd that they might be wrong, no matter how you phrase it. People who try this are called trolls by the definition I see here, and they don't belong in the same category as folks who aren't part of the group but drop in to throw rhetorical hand-grenades at the rest of us. Quick test: if there were topic on HN titled "Final proof that the Earth is Still Flat" that linked to a reputable source and all the commenters were in agreement (stretch your imagination a bit) could you comment in such a fashion to show thoughtful consideration of the majority's opinion yet ask for people to really think this over? If you can follow along in my thought experiment, you'll find this is not a very easy thing to do at all. Most folks would just throw out a snarky rejoinder. In my opinion a bit of nuance is required in this essay which is not present. EDIT: J.S. Mill, is on the money here: "...He argued that even if an opinion is false, the truth can be better understood by refuting the error..." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Stuart_Mill#Views_on_freedom_of_speech http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Stuart_Mill#Views_on_freed... Note the conflict between how the real world has to act, and how the online community is desired to act by the site owner (and the majority opinion) The short-term interest of the site, perhaps "a happy majority pushing forward to a new understanding in a specific field of study" and the strategic interest of a well-functioning society are very much in conflict here. This is a hugely important point, and in my opinion PG does not recognize this except in passing.
- 15y ago
- pg 15y ago"But we still only have about 8,000 uniques a day." Wow, now it's more like 120,000. If I was already worried about the problem then (which I must have been if I took the time to write about it), I'm surprised the site is even usable now.
- pgsucks3 15y agointeresting...
- TechboyUK 15y agoThis reminds me of the Gardening Trolls of Pennadomo, Italy http://blog.techboy.co.uk/the-gardening-trolls-of-pennadomo-italy/ http://blog.techboy.co.uk/the-gardening-trolls-of-pennadomo-...
- angus77 15y agoI hate it when I don't know why I'm being downvoted---did I make some kind of error? did I word things wrong? or do people just disagree with me? What if there were a separate "flag" that people could click for trolls and spam, but when you downvoted someone, you were forced to post a reply explaining why?
- zedshaw 15y agoI normally find that, unless an essay is about mathematics, if it is based on a binary argument then it's just false because it's too simplistic to be based in reality. In this case saying there's only "trolls" and "super awesome people!" is childish. There's a much more interesting spectrum of human behavior online that doesn't fit into these convenient categories. To then say there's only two types of "trolls" is again to reduce the argument to just two boolean options. For example: I know for a fact that the various people who run HN use it to selectively market what they want, but maintain that it is some trust worthy news source for hackers. Since there's no way to distinguish between the astroturfed "top stories" advertising for YC companies and a real news story the entire forum becomes suspect. I consider this just as bad as trolling, except the leadership does it so people don't comment on it. I've also seen huge double standards on here, again because people in charge can do whatever they want. They'll yell about ad hominem attacks and then do them two comments down. They'll post one-liner attack comments and call that "enlightened discourse", then call someone else's similar comment a "troll". Shit, people on here have outright called me a cocksucker and posted whole presentations vilifying me personally and nobody bats a wee little eyelash at it. All of you are heavily manipulated on this forum and yet, here you are complaining about trolls? At least trolls can't hellban you to defend their little astroturf empire.
- lmbe 15y agoSo Hackernews is the new slash-dot yawn. I'm all about lamernews. You can't change a community you can only leave it.
- DiabloD3 15y agoAlthough I'm pretty sure you made this comment to be troll bait, I'm upvoting it. >You can't change a community you can only leave it. This is very very true. I've quit many communities because they devolved into noise and spam. I've publicly said that I came to HN merely because I wanted a good list of links worth reading, and somehow I ended up with an account and almost 1000 karma. I suspect in the next 2-3 years I'll leave HN because it really will have jumped the shark by then. Although, I think the discussion of the slashdotification of HN is off-topic according to the rules.
- DiabloD3 15y agoBeing a recent "victim"[1] of trolling here on HN, I understand pg's sentiment. However, the question is, has HN (since 2008, anyways) fallen into the pit with the trolls? For example, recently there was the thing with Rob Malda's resume. The entire thread on that was rather derailed into either sucking up to Rob, or saying Slashdot is full of trolls. Or rather, it had a rather unfavorable signal to noise ratio. I tried to vote comments accordingly, but it didn't really seem to help. [1] Tried to stick up for FOSS and expose Microsoft/Mono for what it really is, got downvoted for doing the right thing. Oh well, the trolls got me, not really a big deal.
- burgerbrain 15y agoIn that discussion they were not trolling you, at least not intentionally. Instead you were seeing what happens when you combine a strong dose of cognitive dissonance with the ability to downvote. This is a common effect in HN and other so called "enlightened" communities because they do have higher concentrations of honestly intelligent people, people particularly susceptible to cognitive dissonance. When you say something truthful that a "normal" person thinks is wrong, 9 times out of 10 they will ignore you, because they "know" you are wrong. Not so with intelligent populations.
- eropple 15y agoAlternatively, he was saying things that were out-and-out factually untrue. Which, you know. He was. HN voters have this tendency to downvote posts that sound like crazy-person conspiracy theorizing, for some strange reason. (I downvoted him because he was maliciously inaccurate--mistakes happen, but that wasn't a mistake. That was fabrication.)
- nodesocket 15y agoLove what Ryan Dahl has to say about being humble. http://youtu.be/SAc0vQCC6UQ?t=55m58s http://youtu.be/SAc0vQCC6UQ?t=55m58s Honestly, happens almost daily, especially in SF. We meet awesome developers, but they are frankly arrogant assholes. This sort of entitlement results in those people trolling and flaming. Be humble, there are many smart people in the world; you're not that awesome.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- sockpup 15y agoI don't always troll, but when I do, I use a sock puppet.
- mixmax 15y agoTechnical tweaks may also help. On Reddit, votes on your comments don't affect your karma score, but they do on News.YC. And it does seem to influence people when they can see their reputation in the eyes of their peers drain away after making an asshole remark. After points stopped being shown on comments this point seems ironically moot. Any chance of getting them back? Personally I think it's the worst decision in the history of HN.
- kin 15y agoI definitely feel like the term isn't used correctly in the context of the article but in any case there is definitely a certain attitude of nastiness on HN that I experience all the time. I always find myself carefully choosing words and being incredibly specific because any amount of vagueness can lead to flags on my comment. Sometimes I just delete everything and say "I agree" or "Congrats!" or "Good work" and I get a few points. Toss in a "but..." and I get flagged. How about reply to my comment and ask my why I said what I said? And actually most of the time I say something I say why I say it and I still get a backlash. Anyway, it doesn't happen all the time but it's definitely out there.
- zobzu 15y agoThe issue with votes is that they don't fix all that much. People often downvote other people they simply disagree with. In fact, most often do that. So it does not just shut off the "trolls" as in the "assholes". It also shuts off any unpopular opinion. That is sad, because unpopular opinions are generally interesting by nature, and sometimes insightful. That is because popular ones are well-known, thus cannot be "interesting". For example, if you bash a popular company by saying what they do is wrong (whichever it is, Google, Apple, you name it), you will get down voted a lot. No matter how insightful and righteous you were.
- billpatrianakos 15y agoI was trying to say the same thing in my previous comment above. Thank you for being able to put it this way. I think the downvote button should be reserved for off topic/trolling posts. If you downvote out of disagreement or boredom you risk actually turning that person into a troll later on. The newbie who writes a sincere but boring comment and gets downvoted doesn't learn how to better contribute. He just gets alienated. On the other hand, the newbie who writes a few boring comments, gets no up votes and then finally gets an up vote or two for a good contribution learns more about how to be a better contributor than if he had just gotten downvoted for what may seem to him or her, no reason at all.
- einhverfr 15y agoI agree with you. It's far better to upvote than downvote. I dunno about others but I am willing to upvote people I disagree with. those who just repeat stock they have been told by others I don't downvote. It's only those who entirely detract from conversation.... I find the downvoting due to disagreement to be amusing here. Sometimes I read downvoted comments just to get a different viewpoint. What I do find disturbing in this discussion are people with substantially high karma who have been hellbanned. That strikes me as dangerous. I have seen at least 4 hellbanned people on this forum and I would have disagreed with the banning of two of them (the other two were clearly trolls by any definition).
- rjurney 15y agoHacker News lacks a feature that would 'close entire thread,' and so the top troll comment is disproportionately rewarded with attention. You could fix this with a simple feature.
- VonGuard 15y agoI dunno guys, there seems to be a big worry here about HN degrading, or trolling being more prevalent and mods banning non-troll entities... If you've been to Reddit recently and tried to engage that community, you might not be so worried about things here at HN. It's like hot and cold running compassion/rape over there. They either flood you with love, or ransack your house and ruin your life. Dangerous stuff, that Reddit Hive Mind. It's just something that happens on the Internet: more people = more trolls and perceived-but-not-really tolls. I wonder if someone could do a paper on the average parts per million for trolls in any mass of words on the Internet.
- baby 15y agoI feel like some people here are going to say that it went downhills. I personally find HN to be the one of the most civilized and the most interesting (in terms of discussions generated) place I visit.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- theviciousfish 15y agoexamples of trolls in teh wild: http://animalsbeingdicks.com/post/12195340657/troll-cat http://animalsbeingdicks.com/post/12195340657/troll-cat
- pvillega 15y agoSomeone should send the first part to stephen colebourne, as an explanation on why spreading Scala FUD and acting like a victim will only spread hate about his behaviour. Yes, I should write this, but I'm not smart enought to stop myself to type it. After reading the definition my mind instantly draw his face...
- gtani 15y agoAny PL that is widely adopted is going to have a lot of critics, including some from the angry agenda school. The compiler writers need to weight all the inputs so they know what to focus their copious spare time on. This was entertaining: "He's like Goldilocks, scala's too complicated, fantom's too simple" http://www.scala-lang.org/node/7698 http://www.scala-lang.org/node/7698
- tle9 15y agoI love reading Graham's essays. Wealth and Why to not not start a start up
- antirez 15y agoThere are much better trolls than the one described here, that are guys using trolling to show a point about a controversial subject. For instance the flying spaghetti monster thing is a form of trolling, and it is a good one. I think that in programming forums the biggest source of trolling is due to clueless people that still want to say something... in the real world they would be put at the door, but you can't do this in a forum, and even after a ban it is too simple to re-enter. The simplest form of protection about this is to associate a cost to username creation in a forum. Even 5$ is enough. This time the ban is a real cost for the troller that will likely stop after the first 5$ rounds. Another widely used form of "cost" is badges, that is, you start with an account that can do very little and it takes time (and a good comportment) to grow in features. However there is the risk of trolls opening N accounts in parallel just to have reserves of usernames, so it is also very important to penalize non used accounts.
- realschool 15y agoThere is something about the hacker news community, people here are a little less 'cordial' sometimes. It probably has something to do with the way people who are technological have to deal with regular people (when it comes to technology) and then how they feel they can deal with people who are peers. This is good when it allows honest feedback about an idea and products, but can also come across as coarse sometimes.
- tripzilch 15y agoThis article sounds like someone that doesn't understand trolls, trolling, or how to deal with them. Which is strange because he does mention the origins of trolling on Usenet in his footnote. Anyway, he's wrong on several accounts: > Trolling tends to be particularly bad in forums related to computers This really makes me wonder what other forums that aren't related to computers PG frequented, probably not very many. Let's see, there's forums related to wicca, libertarians (the nutty kind), religion/spirituality, failed startups, "magick", seduction, conspiracy freaks ... all those topics attract significantly more trolls than computer related forums. Both of the "broader" definition ("assholes") and the sports trolling type. > There's a sort of Gresham's Law of trolls: trolls are willing to use a forum with a lot of thoughtful people in it, but thoughtful people aren't willing to use a forum with a lot of trolls in it. This is just false. Of all the forums I've seen, the two most thoughtful and intelligent communities just happened to be largely made up of trolls and people very familiar with trolling. It's because they won't stand bullshit and call people on it. Regular forums or forums that can't really deal with trolls always tend to plateau on a certain level of intelligence and thoughtfulness, which can be high, but limited. This is not at all a rule btw, most trolls anyone is going to find will be forums filled with screaming kids, obscenities and bug porn. I just mean to say this "Gresham's Law" thing is false, sometimes the trolls are the thoughtful people and the ones that get driven away are good riddance.
- cq 15y agoTrolls are an important part of anonymous communities. They prevent people from having their heads so far up their asses that the community becomes an echo chamber. Too much moderation will contribute to echo chambers, as well.