5 ms·
Apple has always been known to protect their MSRPs so that authorized sellers can't "steal" business from other sellers by offering lower advertised rates and u
by dylan604 4y ago
Apple has always been known to protect their MSRPs so that authorized sellers can't "steal" business from other sellers by offering lower advertised rates and undercutting other stores in the hopes of less margins more sales.
Is that anti-competitive forcing all sellers to sell your product at the price you want it sold?
- vkou 4y agoUS anti-trust law mostly focuses on harm to consumers, not competitors. I'd daresay that backroom deals that prevent prices from dropping are the poster child for harm to consumers. I can't think of a more blatant example of it, actually - can you?
- goosedragons 4y agoYes? Unless Apple goods are sold on consignment or something didn't the store buy their inventory from Apple? And so then it's not Apple's but the store's?
- dylan604 4y agoThey bought their inventory from Apple within the provisions of the contract they signed to be allowed to sell Apple products. These companies are entering into a valid contract voluntarily. They can chose not to sign the contract, but then they don't get to sell Apple products.
- lapetitejort 4y ago> Is that anti-competitive forcing all sellers to sell your product at the price you want it sold? Emphasis on suggested in MSRP. Retailers can take a hit on a loss leader to get people to buy cases, earphones, etc. Unless businesses collude to not allow that.
- dylan604 4y agoJust like those places with no prices, just donations. Suggested donations are prices.
- rat9988 4y agoThey are not the sellers, so they don't decide the price. They can force sellers through their market advantage. And this is why, in my guess, it's anti-competitive.
- contravariant 4y agoHow is preventing your competitors from undercutting your price not anti-competitive? It's preventing the one thing that causes competition to lower prices. You're literally explaining how Apple is using this to avoid resellers competing against apple stores. Besides they're no longer their products, Apple lost ownership of them after they sold them. If someone chooses to resell them that's their business, Apple is not involved in that sale at all. Technology companies have too much control over what people can and can't do with their products as is, let's not give them even more control. Of course just because it's anticompetitive does not mean that competition is always desirable, with concert tickets for example it's quite clear that competition is hurting more than it helps. Though I find "artists should get a say who can see their concert" much more reasonable than "Apple gets final say over all sales of Apple-manufactured products".
- mwint 4y ago> Besides they're no longer their products This is correct for used devices, or course, but people in the wholesale chain will have signed contracts agreeing not to sell below MSRP. It’s called “undercutting the channel”, and it’s very frowned on in the physical goods distribution industry.
- whimsicalism 4y agoThose aren't "third party resellers" which is what is being discussed.
- rootusrootus 4y agoHow does a third party get an iPhone at wholesale price, then? They're not going to undercut the channel if they have to buy at retail prices.
- jtbayly 4y agoThey don't have to get it at wholesale price. They could have gotten one as a prize, but not want it. They could have gotten a great deal on one from AT&T or Verizon or T-Mobile, but just want to turn the deal into more cash by keeping their old phone and selling the new one. They might have gotten cash back by buying it on a credit card and be willing to sell it for slightly under MSRP to arbitrage the difference. All of these could lead to lower than MSRP prices.
- postalrat 4y agoWhat do you mean by "all sellers"? Does that include people selling used devices?
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> Is that anti-competitive forcing all sellers to sell your product at the price you want it sold? Yes. And it's not supposed to be ""your"" product after you sell it to a retailer.
- judge2020 4y agoThis is actually shifting, from what I've heard; if you're a small physical product seller and want to get your stuff on retailer shelves, you essentially pay Best Buy a shelf space & inventory fee instead of selling your product to them. This means Best Buy can take a chance putting garbage (or not) products on their shelves without having to take a loss (in the form of a discount) on any unsold inventory.
- dylan604 4y agoBig Box retailers will give you shelf space, but if product isn't moving, they can force you to buy it back from them. That's part of the agreement signed between the parties. Just like Apple putting in as part of the contract that you sell at stated price, it's something agreed between parties.
- crooked-v 4y ago> And it's not supposed to be ""your"" product after you sell it to a retailer. ...unless you have a contract with that retailer around the conditions of the sale, which Apple and lots of other big companies do with their bulk retailers.
- dahfizz 4y agoYes. That is like the definition of anti-competitive. Apple is abusing its power as a manufacturer to gain an anti-competitive edge in the retail side of its business.
- nojito 4y agoThis isn’t true at all. Numerous sellers reduce prices for apple devices. It’s gotten so consumer friendly that I almost never go to the Apple Store anymore. I know this because I fully utilize Best Buy’s price matching to get lower prices on my purchases.
- lupire 4y agoPrice matching pretty much only works on Apple devices because every other consumer electronic/appliance gets a different model # for each store that sells it.
- ouid 4y agoyes
- paxys 4y agoOnce I buy something it is my product, not Apple's. I can then resell it at whatever price I want. That's why the concept of maximum suggested retail price exists. Apple blocking me from selling something I own is 100% illegal.
- sokoloff 4y agoThe "M" in MSRP is Manufacturer's, not Maximum.
- brookst 4y agoAs many others have pointed out, this is only true as a purchaser who has no contractual relationship outside of the sale. If Apple comes to you and says "paxys, we just love you, we'll sell you everything for 50% off... but you have to sign a contract that you will only dispose of products by firing them into space", and you sign that contract, and they live up to the discount... surprise, you're on the hook for your part of the contact. Apple has contracts with these resellers. It's called minimum advertised price (MAP) or retail price support. There is a long history of MAP/RPS being litigated in the US, and there are lots of twists and turns and valid opinions to be had. But "first sale doctrine supersedes any contracts" is NOT correct.
- paxys 4y agoYes except this lawsuit has nothing to do with Apple authorized resellers. It is about "third-party merchants" on Amazon, who can be literally anyone. If I – having no prior agreement with Apple – decided to sell my iPad on Amazon, they would remove my listing because Apple didn't approve of it.
- TheHappyOddish 4y agoThey would remove it because it's incredibly likely to be stolen or a grey import, both of which cause big issues to Apple, Amazon and the consumer.
- tick_tock_tick 4y ago> Is that anti-competitive forcing all sellers to sell your product at the price you want it sold? Yes
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> Is that anti-competitive forcing all sellers to sell your product at the price you want it sold Is restrictiong competition antimcompetitive? Is taking someone else's money stealing? Is putting people in chains and selling them slavery? Do words mean anything?