5 ms·
The fall of Microsoft's Andy Lees: inside the Windows Phone power shift
- 9oliYQjP 15y agoBallmer can play as much musical chairs as he wants. The problem is him. Despite a massive Microsoft talent drain, there are still smart, capable people at Microsoft. What Microsoft lacks is a cohesive vision about where they are headed. Bill Gates' vision was a PC running Windows on every desktop. Everything Microsoft did had to be reconciled against this. What is Ballmer's vision? That's his responsibility as CEO. In fact, it's pretty much his most critical one. At this point, he's too high level to do much else. All I see from him is somebody that installs a really smart person in some new vertical that Microsoft all of a sudden deems super important only to let this person take the flack for things not going properly a couple of years after they start.
- freehunter 15y ago>What is Ballmer's vision? Something about developers.
- outside1234 15y agoand "securing the app" to "secure the platform". seems to be working great.
- signa11 15y agohere is his vision from 2k6 on zune: Have you squirted a song yet? That’s the question Microsoft hopes your friends will ask you as you ponder which digital music player to acquire. Although you are more likely to buy an iPod this season — something even Microsoft admits — the software giant from Redmond is running a huge marketing campaign that it hopes will plant some seeds of doubt. After all, iPods don’t squirt songs. And Microsoft’s new player, Zune, does.
- freehunter 15y agoI actually bought a Zune. I had an iPod before that, but iTunes on Windows was awful. I bought a WP7 phone for the same reason, I wanted a managed music experience but iTunes wasn't an option for me. Really, I think that could be a marketing campaign for Microsoft. "Our downsides average out to be slightly better for a small minority of the market! Spend weeks agonizing over the tough decision then settle for us!" I love my Windows Phone, but I'd likely be on iOS if Zune wasn't a better piece of software.
- yequalsx 15y agoYes, the problem is Ballmer. He is extremely shortsighted. Witness his scoffing at the iPhone when it was introduced [1]. Then watch his claim that the iPad is just another PC form factor [2]. He also laughed about the Macbook Air [3]. Of course, now there is a push for ultrabooks from Intel. I saw a Microsoft commercial not too long ago and the lost shot showed a PC and it was a Samsung laptop that looked just like a Macbook Pro. It's a good thing that Metro is not just a copy of iOS. The sooner they fire Ballmer the better. [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eywi0h_Y5_U http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eywi0h_Y5_U [2] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VWkRgNTJZuM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VWkRgNTJZuM [3] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XYcxvEfUikg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XYcxvEfUikg
- smackfu 15y agoWhen you have a universally well reviewed product and it's not selling, you have to change something. Usually the person on top.
- fpgeek 15y agoIn my opinion, the top that needs to change first is Ballmer. I think the first thing holding back Windows Phone in the markeplace is the name. "Windows Phone" inherits the baggage of desktop Windows and of Windows Mobile, neither of which is that positive. Something like "Metro Phone" or whatever would inherit less baggage and would be doing at least a bit better. The naming decision was and is Ballmer's, so...
- smackfu 15y agoOTOH, is it not selling because of the name, or because the local AT&T store has one model, and will never recommend it?
- potatolicious 15y agoOr because they are completely not marketing it? When it launched they did some incredibly poorly thought out TV ads that looked more like some art-house feature than a television commercial. Only a notch above the completely ioncomprehensible campaign Palm ran for the Pre. Look where that landed them. And since then the marketing has been nearly invisible. Yeah sure, you'll see the Windows Phone Facebook page push some promotions and token events, but where is the real force of marketing? When Motorola first made its maneuver into Android-land, I remember every bus shelter, subway platform, billboard, everything plastered in Droid ads, with clever (if slightly unimaginative) slogans. Microsoft's marketing in everything has been utterly incompetent. They've gotten so used to owning products that require no marketing that they're not incapable of doing it. Just think at the "major" marketing moves MS has made in recent years. Seinfeld? WTF? The Lumia is an absolute gem of a device. It's beautifully integrated and has industrial design that screams elegance. And nobody I know has heard of it.
- outside1234 15y agoIts officially criminal that Ballmer hasn't been removed yet.
- saturdaysaint 15y agoI don't get it. I thought this was the Windows Phone playbook - release as early as possible (2010), gain something like feature parity in fall 2011 (i.e. the Mango release) and team up with Nokia to make some great hardware (the Lumia). This is what Windows Phone people have been telling me since the beginning of the year. The virtues, logic and shortcomings of this have been evident from the beginning so I don't see how Ballmer can point at anyone but himself. It's a problem that anyone stretching the definition of "early adopter" already had a phone that did everything a Windows Phone does in 2009. Buying into a phone ecosystem sounds mundane to mildly entertaining to us, but it's a terrifying leap for most of the market - the vast majority of people will buy what their more technically inclined friends and family use. Think of how long it's taken for the iPhone to approach the prevalence of the Blackberry - how bizarre, then, that MS expected WP to bloom while two competent competitors are taking the market by storm. WP7's biggest fault has nothing to do with Andy Lees - it's too late to market.
- wnight 15y agoThe single-greatest reason to avoid Microsoft is that they're willing to sacrifice any and all partners (customers, retailers, developers, employees, etc) to attract more of the others. As a customer you can count on Microsoft adding DRM to the product if anyone else in their development chain asks for it. As a developer you can count on Microsoft making uncomfortable changes without ensuring the devs can work with it. As an employer it's better than EA... mostly. As a retailer, Microsoft is desperately trying to cut you out of all extended revenue streams while still dependent on you to sell the lock-in to the customer in the first place. You're pretty much guaranteed to be screwed with one way or another - to help MS, to help a favored partner, or just as they reposition a project (often in the trash). WP7 could come with a free gold bar and would still be overpriced.