9 ms·
Antitrust lawsuit says Apple and Amazon colluded to raise iPhone, iPad prices
- adamsmark 4y agoSellers like Mercate Group are a solid reason why the Apple/Amazon agreement took place. Look at the seller feedback - I’m not sure I understand why they’re still allowed to list product for smartphones/electronics. https://www.amazon.com/sp?ie=UTF8&seller=A389ML6MNB3VQK&asin=B09HJZPFDD&ref_=dp_merchant_link&isAmazonFulfilled=1 https://www.amazon.com/sp?ie=UTF8&seller=A389ML6MNB3VQK&asin...
- thirdsun 4y agoAs a consumer I hope this lawsuit fails. Since the agreement between Amazon and Apple it was finally possible to reliably buy genuine Apple hardware and accessories from Amazon, often significantly cheaper than from Apple.com. Before it was wild west. I don't want to buy used or counterfeit iPhones from random marketplace sellers and Apple preventing just that is a good thing. I don't see why a company shouldn't be able to decide who can sell its products. Of course pricing is a different discussion but from what I can tell Amazon is free to (and does) set their own prices for Apple products.
- judge2020 4y agocomplaint: https://www.hbsslaw.com/sites/default/files/case-downloads/apple-amazon-price-fixing/2022-11-09-class-action-complaint.pdf https://www.hbsslaw.com/sites/default/files/case-downloads/a... Basically alleging Apple disallowing third-party resellers from appearing on their Amazon pages is anticompetitive and caused consumers to pay more than if they had the option to purchase the devices from 3p sellers (page 41).
- judge2020 4y agoI wonder what happened to the other comment thread that was here? I have showdead on and now it's not here @dang .
- adrr 4y agoBe interesting to see how this case shakes out. Amazon has a huge fraud issue and intermingling inventory won't help a claim that it was to prevent counterfeits. https://www.reddit.com/r/airpods/comments/ekmuyd/beware_these_airpods_pro_shipped_to_me_via_amazon/ https://www.reddit.com/r/airpods/comments/ekmuyd/beware_thes...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwntoday 4y agoThe counterfeit issue basically didn't exist before they started allowing chinese sellers. I don't know why they didn't bother to track the origin of individual items before mixing.
- sokoloff 4y agoCounterfeiting of clothing (particularly Nike and other branded sportswear) was rampant on Amazon for years before the six-letter Chinese sellers of electronics showed up. Some of it was actually quite well-done, but still easy to demonstrate by cross-referencing tag information.
- HappySweeney 4y agoIt would have cost them plenty of money, which I guess was not worth their (at the time) reputation for authenticity.
- tchalla 4y ago> The lawsuit says the parties’ illegal agreement brought the number of third-party sellers of Apple products on Amazon Marketplace from roughly 600 to just seven sellers – a loss of 98%, and by doing so, Amazon, which was formerly a marginal seller of Apple products, became the dominant seller of Apple products on Amazon Marketplace. Apple (future argument) - “We regularly review our sellers for counterfeit goods. During this review, we found indications of non-original Apple products. We regularly co-operate with our industry partners to maintain high standards for our products” ^ that’s my version not Apple’s.
- jaywalk 4y agoThat hypothetical argument doesn't even make sense. Apple could (and still can) have counterfeits taken down. This has nothing to do with that.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThe counterfeiters can create accounts faster than you can shut them down, which is likely what led them to the next step, asking Amazon to only permit certain vetted resellers.
- zdragnar 4y agoI'm not sure that I buy it either, but I don't think it is out of the realm of possibility that Apple would take more proactive steps than merely waiting to find counterfeits and report them, especially when a marketplace like Amazon is so poorly curated that the counterfeiters will just pop back up again.
- RajT88 4y agoIt makes a great deal of sense if you get into the wording. Non-original doesn't necessarily mean counterfeit. It could refer to "not sold by Apple or an authorized retailer", i.e. used / refurbs. I don't think they'd go down that path. Risk of ending up in the pile of corporations who have lost the fight against the law of first sale.
- 4y ago
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Where consumers used to be able to find discounted prices of upwards of 20% for iPhones and iPads for sale on Amazon Marketplace, now they get locked into Apple’s premium pricing. How were these resellers selling iPhones and iPads for 20% off?
- threeseed 4y agoYou can exploit currency differences to get a discount. For example, in Australia Apple locks the exchange rate at certain points in order to maintain a consistent price. When the rate moves against say the USD you can import phones at a cheaper price. Never seen it be as high as 20% though.
- wodenokoto 4y agoAt the end of life of an apple item, Apple still hasn't discounted their price, but other sellers have started to do so. I got my airpods pro at more than 20% off of Apple price 3 weeks before the announcement of the airpod pro II
- boplicity 4y agoIt used to be quite easy to find used Apple products on Amazon. For example, I bought a used 2013 Macbook Pro with Applecare included at a decent discount. When it came time to replace it, similar options weren't available on Amazon, unfortunately.
- dylan604 4y agoThere's a difference from selling used as an individual vs selling used as store. There are authorized used Mac sellers, but I'd imagine they'd be under the same Apple mandates on what is allowed. If some of these sellers on Amazon "fucked around and found out" what happens when you break an Apple contract, then whoops! A contract is there for a reason.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- dylan604 4y agoApple has always been known to protect their MSRPs so that authorized sellers can't "steal" business from other sellers by offering lower advertised rates and undercutting other stores in the hopes of less margins more sales. Is that anti-competitive forcing all sellers to sell your product at the price you want it sold?
- vkou 4y agoUS anti-trust law mostly focuses on harm to consumers, not competitors. I'd daresay that backroom deals that prevent prices from dropping are the poster child for harm to consumers. I can't think of a more blatant example of it, actually - can you?
- goosedragons 4y agoYes? Unless Apple goods are sold on consignment or something didn't the store buy their inventory from Apple? And so then it's not Apple's but the store's?
- dylan604 4y agoThey bought their inventory from Apple within the provisions of the contract they signed to be allowed to sell Apple products. These companies are entering into a valid contract voluntarily. They can chose not to sign the contract, but then they don't get to sell Apple products.
- lapetitejort 4y ago> Is that anti-competitive forcing all sellers to sell your product at the price you want it sold? Emphasis on suggested in MSRP. Retailers can take a hit on a loss leader to get people to buy cases, earphones, etc. Unless businesses collude to not allow that.
- dylan604 4y agoJust like those places with no prices, just donations. Suggested donations are prices.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIt is always funny to me to see a claim that Amazon has some type of outsize pricing power in the marketplace, when switching to a different business involves typing in a different URL. As opposed to every other merchant/marketplace in the physical space where switching to a different business involves expending leagues more energy and time. If these people are able to source and sell Apple products for considerably less than Amazon, then it should be trivial for them to advertise their website. Just spamming Reddit comments would do the trick. People will surely be willing to type in a different URL if they can save tens or hundreds of dollars.
- barbariangrunge 4y agoIirc, Amazon prevents you from charging a lower price on a non-Amazon site. It drives up prices across the board and artificially makes non-Amazon retailers seem more expensive than they would be, because Amazon prices often hide part of the shipping costs. There’s no such thing as free shipping after all I forget what the penalty is but it was all over the news a few years ago. Let’s see… https://www.inc.com/guadalupe-gonzalez/amazon-removes-price-parity-not-fair-price-rule-third-party-sellers-antitrust-violations.html https://www.inc.com/guadalupe-gonzalez/amazon-removes-price-...
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> artificially makes non-Amazon retailers seem more expensive than they would be, because Amazon prices often hide part of the shipping costs. I presume there would not be anything stopping the other websites from including the shipping prices? Regardless, my point is if Amazon was not offering a seller a reasonable deal, they should just start their own website. The barrier to entry has never been lower in all of history.
- barbariangrunge 4y agoThat sounds so easy. I wonder why so few of them thought of that
- paulryanrogers 4y ago
- smm11 4y agoApple stuff has always cost what Apple stuff cost. At one point you could shop around at places such as Best Buy and get an Apple device with a "free" printer or something, but you were still paying what Apple charged for the Apple device. I guess I don't follow what's going on here.
- jjtheblunt 4y agois what's going on here class action attorneys targeting companies with big savings accounts, hoping anything might stick? I mean, Apple and Amazon don't make competing products wrt the lawsuit, so they can't collude to price fix their separate products and defeat the market? I keep trying to see what i'm overlooking...presuming somehow it makes sense.
- danaris 4y agoI mean...that is what's going on here. That's not supposed to be possible. (And I say this as an unapologetic Apple fan.) When Apple's products are never available (barring certain rare sales) for significantly less than Apple themselves retails them, that's an indication that some kind of price fixing is going on. Yes, it's price fixing for the products of a single supplier, which means that there's a lot less to do, and a lot less benefit to be gained (ie, the least you're going to be able to sell it for without taking a loss is Apple's wholesale price), but it's still illegal.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> That's not supposed to be possible. It happens to me all the time with non-Apple products. Always the same price, down to the penny. Pricing agreements between the manufacturer and their resellers seem to be pretty common. If we're suddenly going to decide that's illegal, it will have a huge impact on the market.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> That's not supposed to be possible. Why not? Apple isn't under any obligation to sell to anyone at a wholesale price, and can apply conditions via a contract when they do so. Arizona iced tea even prints the price on the cans to prevent people from fucking with it.
- gausswho 4y agoI've sometimes wondered why it's legal for markets to be coerced not to price items below MSRP. The acronym includes the word suggested right? Not mandated?
- jcampbell1 4y agoIt isn’t a mandate. It is a condition for resupply. High end sporting good brands are known for enforcing MSRP so the high end retailers have budget for sales people and demos. They cutoff supply to discount retailers to maintain good relationships with retailers. REI would drop North Face in a second if North Face clothing was available at the TJMaxx next door. The relationship cuts both ways.
- gausswho 4y agoI understand the chain of incentives, but I see room for it being legislated away as anti-consumer.
- midoridensha 4y agoThere's no shortage of brands of outdoor clothing. If you don't like North Face's high prices (enforced by contract to be only sold at MSRP), you're free to buy from countless other brands, some high-end, others not. The same is true for Apple: there's dozens of competing phone brands. I don't see why mfgrs shouldn't be allowed to have sales and pricing agreements (contracts) with retailers so that their goods are sold in ways the mfgr approves of.
- TillE 4y agoThat would effectively mean a law requiring companies to wholesale to anyone at the same price. That's a rather extreme intervention in a market for no clear benefit. We're really not talking about anything that can be construed as monopolistic behavior.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoThe argument in this case seems all kinds of weird. Basically, it seems to be that Amazon, by restricting third party sellers of Apple products from its marketplace, is somehow engaged in a horizontal price-fixing agreement with Apple. This is despite the fact that the only products whose produced by Apple are affected, are involved - which is sort of the definition of vertical price-fixing - and neither Amazon nor Apple control the prices of other vendors, only whether or not they're allowed on Amazon's platform - which is not in any case an exclusive channel for Apple products.
- 6stringmerc 4y agoOh the ghost of Steve Clinical-Sociopath Jobs lives on. I remember that price fixing suit very well. Also the employee poaching one. And his paternity case. Sucks that the only reason the iPod case lost was because nobody showed up in time with an affected device. I think I have one sitting on a shelf that I picked up along the way. Oh well, that's the law process for ya. It happened but Apple got to skate.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoI helped build the online division for a major consumer product that had market force to force retailers to price at msrp. It was fascinating the extent they went to build the appearance they weren’t being anticompetitive when in reality everyone knew they were and their pricing was uniform across all retailers. They also bought all excess inventory back at cost and destroyed it to ensure no grey market could exist. They even went so far as requiring retailer websites to essentially #include our website components embedded in their framing and branding to ensure total compliance and to ensure competitors products wouldn’t be displayed along side. I think these antics are pervasive in high end products as a way of ensuring their exclusivity and to prevent dilution of their brand. But they were extraordinarily sensitive to the anticompetitiveness of their behavior to the extent we weren’t allowed to even say the words “monopoly” let alone write anything like it down.
- GuiltyBystander 4y agoI'm late to this thread but does anyone know where I could find a link to the "Global Tenets Agreement" between Apple/Amazon that was referenced in the class action lawsuit?