7 ms·
The Milky Way's black hole may spring to life in 2013
- AznHisoka 15y agoCould someone explain the implications of all this in laymen terms? Are we in deep shit?
- ethanpoole 15y agoNo. From what I understand, any material caught in the accretion disk is merely funnelling down into the black hole's event horizon, i.e. the centre. It will not affect any orbiting bodies, such as our solar system, but it will make the black hole pseudo-visible to astronomers because the material in the accretion disk will admit some light.
- michaelcampbell 15y agoIt will add mass to the black hole though, right? So that will affect orbits, no? Or is that just so infinitesimally small that it can reasonably be ignored?
- ceejayoz 15y agoAll that mass is already orbiting (on a galactic scale) right on top of the mass. It'll affect our solar system's orbits in the same way that the sun moving a few microns affects them, I'd imagine.
- kenj0418 15y agoThe black hole is estimated around 4 million solar masses, the gas cloud around 3 earth masses.
- stephth 15y agoSo by "spring to life" the writer meant "we may, if we're lucky, finally see a glint of something". It's very exciting, yet the writer put it in terms that will scare the living hell of any uneducated person like me. Glad there's always HN.
- dhkl 15y agoI was thinking of the exact same thing. It's ironic when a piece of writing tries to present you with factual information begins with a deceiving title, all in the name of attention grabbing.
- 46Bit 15y agoThe mass is already roughly there. One thing to bear in mind - if you replaced the Sun with a black hole of equal mass, planets wouldn't change orbits. It's the same gravity and centre of mass, just a different density/volume.
- TheEzEzz 15y agoThis is true for Newtonian gravity, but only approximately true for general relativity (or so I understand it).
- dakr 15y agoThis includes the effects of general relativity. As long as the mass is the same, the orbits of planets will remain the same.
- TheEzEzz 15y agoAccording to wikipedia[1] the converse of the Shell Theorem is (nearly) true: Suppose there is a force F between masses M and m, separated by a distance r of the form F = Mmf(r) such that any spherically symmetric body affects external bodies as if its mass were concentrated at its centre. Then what form can the function f take? The form of f allows Newtonian gravity but not Einsteinian. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shell_theorem#Converses_and_generalisations http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shell_theorem#Converses_and_gen...
- 46Bit 15y agoInteresting. However, I would have thought that planets are far out enough that classical is accurate enough. This sort of thing is why I specified planets as opposed to orbits in general.
- T-hawk 15y agoThe key point there is "spherically symmetric". The Sun isn't. It bulges around its equator thanks to rotation, as does everything. That does have effects on planetary motion; an object in an inclined orbit spends a bit more time a bit farther away from a bit of the Sun's mass. Replace the Sun with a black hole of equal mass and you don't have that oblateness. The effect on planetary orbits would be very small, so macroscopically the Solar System would still be the same, just with very slight differences in orbital speeds and periods.
- polyfractal 15y agoIn addition to the other explanations given, it won't affect us presently because it already happened a long time ago.
- awj 15y agoIf I send a slow, waddling mobster to go break your kneecaps, are you affected when I give the order or two weeks later when Guido knocks on your door?
- polyfractal 15y agoGood point, I retract my comment :)
- bakedbeing 15y agoOnly if gravity moves at the same speed as light, right? It sounds like we've been observing energy emissions (light) rather than directly observing it's gravitational impact on us.
- ars 15y agoGravity has to move at the same speed as light. If it didn't it would cause time paradoxes.
- bakedbeing 15y agoAh of course, a theoretical graviton being a massless particle. That's what I get for not having a wee Google first.
- awj 15y agoMy understanding (note: I am not a physicist, this is not a physics lesson) agrees with ars, gravity has to move at the same speed as light. In either case, the energy emissions potentially are enough, if they're directed at us and strong enough.
- Florin_Andrei 15y agoNo. But the accretion disk might appear visible to various instruments. Basically, we will see the exact location of the black hole for the first time directly. Not the collapsar itself, of course, but the swirling disk surrounding it.
- william42 15y agoConsidering the lightyears involved, I assume this means we'll see it in 2013?
- hendler 15y agoWas thinking the same thing. Depending on how you think about space-time it "is" happening 27,000 years go. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milky_Way#Galactic_Center http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milky_Way#Galactic_Center
- swombat 15y agoOr rather, it is happening now 27k light-years away.
- sephlietz 15y agoPresumably, yes. It would be odd for the astronomers to use two different temporal points of reference; time of observation is the only time that matters. Plus, any excitement on the part of astronomers would be super pointless if they had to wait another 24824 years to observe it.
- jarin 15y agoFrom the point of view of a photon originating in that gas cloud, it was emitted by an electron in the gas cloud and absorbed by an electron in the telescope sensor at the exact same instant.
- finnw 15y agoOn the other hand it would be impressive if they correctly predicted it from 24-millenia-old data.
- rbanffy 15y agoThat's correct. But never forget the idea of a "now" is deeply tied to a "here".
- 15y ago
- davidhansen 15y agoThat may be about to change, however. Astronomers have spotted a cloud of gas with a mass about three times that of Earth that's on a trajectory that will have it pass close to Sgr A in 2013* If this is for real, I am ridiculously humbled by the power of modern astronomy. It's pretty damned amazing to me that we have the ability to detect the location, dimension, and trajectory of a mere 3 earth-masses of thin, amorphous gas 27k light years away, in the noisiest and densest part of the galaxy.
- johno215 15y agoBased on the Nature article abstract images it appears they were able to image the cloud using the VLT telescope. I got confused about L'-band for a second. Thought they were talking about L-band. Feel free to correct me if someone has read the article. [1] http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/nature10652.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/natu... [2] http://www.eso.org/public/teles-instr/vlt.html http://www.eso.org/public/teles-instr/vlt.html [edited for mistake]
- Tuna-Fish 15y agoThis is the public webcast of the ESO VLT on the issue. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFLkewQIzoA&feature=youtu.be http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFLkewQIzoA&feature=youtu... I'd just like to point out that seeing that cloud isn't actually nearly as hard as getting direct observations of planets around other stars. The cloud is very brightly lit by all the stars around it, and is far enough from other light sources that you can just point a telescope at it without needing any tricks. Contrast this to looking at much dimmer planets that are very close to very bright stars. And we've been able to do that for big enough planets since 2008.
- tikhonj 15y agoCan somebody explain why the black hole at the center of our galaxy is called "Sgr A*"? Is there some system behind the name or are astronomers just like programmers in naming stuff (it took me a while to figure out how to pronounce nginx >:().
- gruturo 15y agoThat stands for Sagittarius A* http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sagittarius_A* http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sagittarius_A*
- walexander 15y agoSgr is short for Sagitarrius, a constellation. If you mark off the boundary of Sagitarrius, Sgr A* would be in that region. The black hole itself does not have the name, but rather the radio source associated with it. (conjecture alert)I'm not sure where the * comes from, but I believe the A is associated with the fact that Sgr A is a super nova remnant. Supernova are typically named "SN [year] [alpha]" where [year] is the year discovered and [alpha] is an alphabetical character in order of discovery. A supernova remant wouldnt have a year associated, so i'm guessing it's given a constellation and then alphabetical marking. Typically, astronomers have a mix of common names and many systematic naming schemes, but they get obsoleted when better instruments find darker objects. There was once a catalog of nebula called Messier with about 130 objects (M1,M2,..). We still use these designations, but suddely they found thousands more of these objects and had to rename using the New General Catalog, (NGC1,NGC2,NGC496). Even further the IC goes into many thousands. For constellations, stars in each constellation are usually named alphabetically with greek chars in terms of their apparent brightness. Alpha Centauri is the brightest star, for example, in Centarus. Then there are common names like Polaris, the north star, whch is alpha ursa minoris.
- nknight 15y ago> There was once a catalog of nebula called Messier Hah, I'd sort of known what the Messier catalog was, but you inspired me to look at its Wikipedia page[1]. Apparently Charles Messier was looking for comets, and was tired of getting distracted by things that weren't comets. M1 is the Crab Nebula[2]. This amuses me. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messier_object http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messier_object [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Messier_objects http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Messier_objects
- ars 15y agoI wonder if they took time dilation into account when calculating the arrival date.
- ypcx 15y agoThis is absolutely shockingly awesome. (No I don't use these words often at all.) Based on the non-mainstream scientific evidence, the coming radiation has the power to completely reconfigure our DNA, and in fact all DNA/RNA on Earth's surface. This is what had been predicted by numerous ancient cultures including Mayans, and badly misinterpreted as the end of the world, or end of the times. If you don't happen to be a hardline mainstream scientist, I really recommend picking up this book, if for nothing else, then for all the absolutely shocking scientific research it references: http://www.amazon.com/dp/0525952047/ http://www.amazon.com/dp/0525952047/