4 ms·
> This is an attempt to internalize some of those externalities to make the system more economically efficient. What specific externalities are being internali
by gruez 4y ago
> This is an attempt to internalize some of those externalities to make the system more economically efficient.
What specific externalities are being internalized by solar panels? Or is this just a pigovian tax by forcing businesses to make money-losing investments?
- stardenburden 4y agoUrban Heat Island effect for one. The dark pavement stores heat and raises the temperature of the surrounding area
- stonemetal12 4y agoConcrete accounts for something like 5% of CO2 emissions. So They want to use green energy reduce CO2 produced elsewhere in the system as an offset.
- gruez 4y agoIf you think the problem is carbon emissions, you should tax carbon emissions (ie. carbon tax). That way it covers everything, not just the ones that receive enough public attention, and there's an incentive to come up with greener paving materials. Right now you're forced to pay the same costs (ie. solar panel coverings) regardless if you're using concrete (max co2) or bricks (minimum co2?)
- stonemetal12 4y agoI agree, law should be direct in what it is trying to do.
- Tiktaalik 4y agoreminder this is a country where there were weekly riots in the streets when gas prices went up. (yellow vest movement) A carbon tax would make sense. Let's not pretend this is easy and viable to implement.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoYes, this is a pigovian tax, using Pigou's definition. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax Not the right wing hijack: https://taxfoundation.org/tax-basics/pigouvian-tax/ https://taxfoundation.org/tax-basics/pigouvian-tax/
- prottog 4y agoWhat's right-wing about the Tax Foundation's definition? It's basically the same as the Wikipedia definition.
- ohgodplsno 4y agoIt pretends that the costs will be borne by people outside of the transaction at all times, therefore continuing the right wing myth that any government intervention will increase costs for the final consumer.
- prottog 4y agoHere is their definition: "A Pigouvian tax [...] is a tax on a market transaction that creates a negative externality, or an additional cost, borne by individuals not directly involved in the transaction." The "additional cost" is a clarification of the "negative externality", not a condemnation of the "tax on a market transaction". I suppose it's ambiguously constructed as a sentence and we can read into it what we will.
- csours 4y ago> forcing businesses to make money-losing investments? Please be patient with this comment, I do not mean it as a personal accusation. I do not think that the point of taxes and legislation is to make more money for businesses. The point of the economy is not to make money for people or businesses. The point of the economy and government is whatever we make it. We SHOULD use government and the economy to make things better for people. There are certainly disagreements about what this means. "Forcing businesses to make money-losing investments" sounds like an accusation, like a sin, or like an evil thing to impose. Regulating business is not socialist or communist or evil.
- gruez 4y ago>We SHOULD use government and the economy to make things better for people. There are certainly disagreements about what this means. >"Forcing businesses to make money-losing investments" sounds like an accusation, like a sin, or like an evil thing to impose. If you want businesses to pay more taxes (because of "their fair share" or whatever), that's fine. My only request is to call a spade a spade. If you think that businesses should be paying 1 billion euros more for climate change mitigation, enact a 1 billion euros tax. Raise corporate tax rates. Impose a levy on parking lots. Don't enact measures sound like not-taxes but are really taxes, like the legislation mentioned in the OP, or forcing them to donate to climate charities.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoSolar panels generally have a positive ROI. Except it is lower or even negative right now over parking lots because of legislative barriers and because the process hasn't been streamlined. If it is legally mandated rather than legally difficult, and everyone is doing it, these costs reduce. By forcing everyone to do it you break the first-mover disadvantage. The lot owner (or whoever they want to license the space to) benefits. Cities get 25% lower heat-island effect. Customers get cooler cars. Less productive land is used. Everyone wins, and the law has an 'economically untenable' clause for people in the shade of a highrise or with trees or existing shade sails or similar.
- csours 4y ago