4 ms·
What's the point of legislating on parking lots specifically? If all you want is solar capacity, wouldn't roofs be better because you don't need the support str
by gruez 4y ago
What's the point of legislating on parking lots specifically? If all you want is solar capacity, wouldn't roofs be better because you don't need the support structures/lights? The whole thing reeks of "government has a cool idea and mandates it by decree". Is there some additional benefits of solar panels on parking lots that I'm missing, that requires government intervention to work?
- cabaalis 4y agoSeems like targeting businesses. Businesses have this odd existential mandate of having to make more money than they spend, or they would disappear. This doesn't typically happen to humans, so less humans follow that rule and subsidize losses with credit. Therefore people who want to force things that require money to implement go to who they perceive to have the money to burn.
- mschuster91 4y ago> Therefore people who want to force things that require money to implement go to who they perceive to have the money to burn. There exist a number of companies that build out solar on a rent basis, i.e. a supermarket hands over land usage and power sale rights to this company in exchange for a payment, and the company builds and maintains the solar panels.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoCreating a market. Lots of people build big car parks all the time, now all of them are required to have solar. So they've created a market for businesses to serve. Plus presumably, the French have a goal of selling more EVs, so solar on car parks is a nice synergy.
- jbn 4y agohow is it a synergy? the solar panels will necessarily feed into the grid (because electricity must be transported for immediate consumption), and not necessarily into EVs (since it can be sunny when no cars are here to recharge, or EVs need recharging at night when there's no sun). Only rarely will the electricity collected by the panels feed directly into the EVs. So IMHO not a synergy, it is merely co-location of the 2 (which is good, since parking lots are mostly unused space, now this space will in fact do something when not in-use for car parking).
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoCombined PV inverters and EV chargers can be 20% more efficient by staying in DC instead of a double conversion and let you fast charge by using grid power and solar simultaneously.
- jbn 4y agointeresting, so there is a synergy! Of course, it doesn't do anything when you park your car when it rains ;-)
- mschuster91 4y ago> If all you want is solar capacity, wouldn't roofs be better because you don't need the support structures/lights? Roofs are smaller than parking lots, and it's usually cheaper to construct panels on parking lots since you don't need to work at heights and you don't need extensive certifications to make sure the added load from solar panels and their wind exposure doesn't threaten static integrity of the building.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoParking lots have lots of externalities not borne by the parking lot owner. This is an attempt to internalize some of those externalities to make the system more economically efficient. If this causes fewer parking lots to be built the system is more efficient, not less. Marginal parking lots shouldn't be built, only the ones that are truly needed. OTOH, if a law causes fewer buildings to be built that imposes costs on society. It's harder to argue that a building that becomes infeasible due to the extra upfront costs of solar shouldn't be built.
- gruez 4y ago> This is an attempt to internalize some of those externalities to make the system more economically efficient. What specific externalities are being internalized by solar panels? Or is this just a pigovian tax by forcing businesses to make money-losing investments?
- stardenburden 4y agoUrban Heat Island effect for one. The dark pavement stores heat and raises the temperature of the surrounding area
- stonemetal12 4y agoConcrete accounts for something like 5% of CO2 emissions. So They want to use green energy reduce CO2 produced elsewhere in the system as an offset.
- gruez 4y agoIf you think the problem is carbon emissions, you should tax carbon emissions (ie. carbon tax). That way it covers everything, not just the ones that receive enough public attention, and there's an incentive to come up with greener paving materials. Right now you're forced to pay the same costs (ie. solar panel coverings) regardless if you're using concrete (max co2) or bricks (minimum co2?)
- 4y ago
- maeln 4y ago> "government has a cool idea and mandates it by decree" This is not the government. It is in a law made by the parlement, aimed at accelerating the installation of renewable energy. > If all you want is solar capacity, wouldn't roofs be better because you don't need the support structures/lights? While not mandatory, there is already some heavy tax incentive to install solar panel on new buildings. While this is more challenging for housing, you will find that most warehouse are now built with solar panel on the roof. But retrofitting old warehouse, or any building really, with solar panel is more complicated has most of them don't have the structure to support the weight of the solar panel. > Is there some additional benefits of solar panels on parking lots that I'm missing, that requires government intervention to work? Not really but they tend to take a lot of area (compare to most urban building who are more vertical and have a lesser m2 footprint) so they are a good candidate to install solar panel. It also has the benefit of shading the car, reducing the power draw of the A/C when the car start in the summer (although it has the opposite effect in winter I suppose). But also, massive (80+ car park is considered quite big in France) parking are usually the beneficiary (and enabler) of a car centric culture, which create a lot of co2, so they should contribute.
- nebalee 4y agoNew commercial buildings already have to have solar (or plants) on their roofs: https://www.architectmagazine.com/technology/france-mandates-green-roofs-for-all-new-commercial-construction_o https://www.architectmagazine.com/technology/france-mandates...