6 ms·
That's too bad since Israel runs a repressive apartheid regime.
by guelo 15y ago
That's too bad since Israel runs a repressive apartheid regime.
- xenophanes 15y agoflagged
- mishmax 15y agoNot sure why. What he says is true. Too bad these corps are supporting apartheid regimes such as Israel.
- xenophanes 15y agoYou're bringing up nasty and controversial politics in a thread where it's basically irrelevant. Flagged.
- shortlived 15y agoIf the title was "Apple opens dev center in milwaukee", there would be no headline. Israel, by it's nature, is a political topic.
- guelo 15y agoIf Apple was doing business with North Korea would you flag any comments about the regime? Meta: When you flag something you're not supposed to also comment on it since it is better to shun and ignore spam or offtopic material than it is to try to bring attention to it, according to the site guidelines: If you think something is spam or offtopic, flag it by going to its page and clicking on the "flag" link. (Not all users will see this; there is a karma threshold.) If you flag something, please don't also comment that you did. Also, since I'm making a comment on the actual story it is not spam or offtopic.
- cynest 15y ago> If Apple was doing business with North Korea would you flag any comments about the regime? Israel is not closed to Western investment. Apple getting this through did not require significant action on the part of local government. In the North Korean case, the regime has to be talked about.
- guelo 15y agoFair enough. The reason I brought it up is because the Israel issue affects me personally since I try to maintain an Israel boycott. There is a growing group of boycotters around the world. Things are already hard enough with Intel having a big facility over there. This new facility by Apple is big news to us.
- tkahn6 15y agoInteresting fact: Omar Barghouti, founder of the BDS movement, is getting his masters degree at Tel Aviv University.
- xenophanes 15y agoComparing Israel to North Korea is a nasty, partisan political statement, not a reasonable part of an HN discussion about Apple.
- guelo 15y agoIt might be nasty and political but it is not partisan since both major parties in the US support Israel.
- tkahn6 15y agoThe definition of partisan has nothing to do with the US political system.
- guelo 15y agoOK, but I still don't see how my comment could be viewed as advocating for any political party.
- xenophanes 15y agopartisan, noun, "a strong supporter of a party, cause, or person" I meant strong supporter of a controversial cause, not of a particular political party.
- coolestuk 15y agoIt is truly offensive to what black africans endured under apartheid, to compare Israel with South Africa. My guess is that the people who say such things have never visited Israel and never visited South Africa under apartheid. 'African-American student leaders from a variety of historically black colleges and universities took out full page ads in numerous American college newspapers Thursday, displaying an “Open Letter to Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP),” to convey that they were offended by SJP’s use of the term “apartheid” at recent Israel Apartheid Week events at campuses across the country.' http://www.jpost.com/International/Article.aspx?id=215811 http://www.jpost.com/International/Article.aspx?id=215811 Ever wonder where a millenium of European anti-semtism disappeared to following 1945? It transmogrified itself into prejudice against Israel. There are countries that truly are comparable to apartheid (e.g. Saudi Arabia, where non-muslims are not permitted to enter Mecca). But it is always democratic Israel that gets equated with apartheid, not undemocratic, discriminatory Saudi Arabia.
- guelo 15y agoPalestinians aren't allowed to enter huge portions of the West Bank, including big sections of Hebron where only 500 Jewish settlers live among 300,000 Palestinians. There are whole highways that are Israeli only. Jewish settlers steal private land and then are defended by the IDF as has happened in Nabi Saleh. One set of rules is enforced on Palestinians and another for Israelis living in the same area. That is the definition of apartheid.
- tkahn6 15y ago'Palestinian' denoting citizenship rather than race. I can 100% assure you that there are Druze and Bedouin checkpoint soldiers. South African apartheid discriminated based on the race of South African citizens. Israeli only roads because Palestinians are not Israeli. They are Palestinian. The word youre looking for is occupation.
- guelo 15y agoThe only requirement to become an Israeli citizen is a religious claim. Apartheid based on religion vs race is not much better. I consider the occupation terminology BS because there has been no progress on the two state solution for 50 years. It is one country defacto ruled by Israel. Israel tries to claim the Palestinian territories as a weird hybrid state, not independent but not part of Israel, just so they can claim to be democratic, but they are not.
- electromagnetic 15y agoStop trolling racist crap around HN. If your brain can't comprehend outside racial and religious barriers then I'm sure we can get you pointed to a popular phpbb forum for your particular brand of anti-Semitism.
- guelo 15y agoI'm trying hard and failing to think how "racial and religious barriers" are not, by definition, racism and religious discrimination. BTW, do you consider Jews that make these same arguments to also be anti-semitic?
- electromagnetic 15y agoThere are no racial or religious barriers to naturalized citizenship in Israel. Also it would be moronic for a country set up by all the western powers as a home for Judaism to not permit Jews based on religion. This is as absurd as claiming its racist that Immigration in the US allows separate lines for US citizens and for non-citizens. When you claim all Jews are citizens of Israel, you kind of have to make it easy for them to get in, because you kind of aren't a citizen if you have to wait 3 years and get naturalized like everyone else. Yes you can be racist against your own people. That's like saying a black landlord isn't racist because he thinks all black people are unemployed and won't pay their rent. Of course its racist. Anti-Semitic speech is speech against Semitism. I don't get how that's hard to understand.