3 ms·
> The Supreme Court is set to hear a case that says that states have zero requirement to follow their citizens wishes and that the ruling executive can cast tha
by AnimalMuppet 4y ago
> The Supreme Court is set to hear a case that says that states have zero requirement to follow their citizens wishes and that the ruling executive can cast that states electoral votes any way they want, without any consequence.
Yes, they are. Good thing, too. We need a clear ruling that this kind of nonsense is illegal before 2024.
In fact, I think the Supreme Court is violating normal rules to take this case. Normally, they only will take a case after the actions have occurred, rather than rule on a hypothetical. This one is likely enough under current circumstances that they went ahead and took it.
> And the current Supreme Court has all but telegraphed that it will rule in favor of the state, saying that that Governor is perfectly allowed to do so.
That's where I'm calling BS. One, I've not seen anything that indicates that they have telegraphed any such thing. Two, even legal experts routinely are wrong when they say which way the court is "leaning".
- FireBeyond 4y ago> That's where I'm calling BS. One, I've not seen anything that indicates that they have telegraphed any such thing Maybe telegraphed is a strong word. That being said, the "independent state legislature" theory is one strongly evangelized by the Federalist Society. Six of the nine Justices are or were members, and several have only ever voted consistently with the Federalist Society's stated positions. I think there's a real risk there.
- AnimalMuppet 4y ago> several have only ever voted consistently with the Federalist Society's stated positions. Yeah, I'm calling BS on that claim, too.
- FireBeyond 4y agoClarence Thomas has only ruled in an originalist manner on the constitutional cases he has heard. Likewise, Alito and Gorsuch. The only deviation from this that I could locate was in Citizens United. Alito talked of "practical originalism" as opposed to textbook. But if you can name cases where at least those three have significantly deviated from the Federalist Society, please do.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoDo you define the Federalist Society position as only originalism? Is the "independent state legislature" position purely justified on the grounds of originalism, or is there more to it than that? I mean, you could justify no vote for women on "originalism", too. So I think that saying "Thomas only rules in an originalist manner" is too simplistic. Yes, he clearly bases his reasoning on originalism. But you can use originalism to justify many things, not all of which Thomas supports. Post 17th Amendment, I'm not sure you can build a valid originalist argument for independent state legislature appointment of electors.