3 ms·
Good article. Self was a research language; its output was papers and talks. Nobody ever tried to make it a "real" language in any sense. It's like Carl Hewe
by gumby 4y ago
Good article. Self was a research language; its output was papers and talks. Nobody ever tried to make it a "real" language in any sense. It's like Carl Hewett's development of Actors -- nobody tried to use his codebase other than him AFAIK, but the work was very influential.
Honestly these experimental languages are crucial for science and better off being left alone. C++ has suffered in being both a research language and a production* language, and the people in the latter camp are frustrated by the people in the former camp.
* I mean "production" in the sense of shipping code, not in the computer science sense.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoI don't think they tried to make a product from Self, really, but it was definitely a real language with an extremely optimized runtime and a quite complete user interface. Many many hours of intense engineering went into that. I remember being excited when it was open sourced, finally.. but nothing ever came of it. It was actually quite readable, the C++ VM implementation.
- kragen 4y agoi tried getting it to compile with current c++ compilers for a few days but without great success. i understand others have now bridged that gap
- gumby 4y ago> I don't think they tried to make a product from Self, really, but it was definitely a real language with an extremely optimized runtime and a quite complete user interface. Many many hours of intense engineering went into that. Well, the performance and the runtime were the point of the experiment, right? I didn't mean to denigrate the effort that went into it, I just meant that I don't think anyone tried to make it anything beyond a research effort (in the sense that, say, the rust, clojure, or ruby folks have tried to do). In our current world things that aren't been trumpeted widely are often not considered worthwhile. But I remember Self being incredibly influential, including on my own work. As in, how science actually works.