6 ms·
As BTC likely goes back to 3k, more exchanges will fail. I'll stick with boring index funds. People are always looking for lifehacks or shortcuts to get rich. A
by paulpauper 4y ago
As BTC likely goes back to 3k, more exchanges will fail. I'll stick with boring index funds. People are always looking for lifehacks or shortcuts to get rich. Almost never works unless you're early. Odds are you are not.
- agleason 4y agoUntil someone comes up with a better solution for cross border payments ($150T market), I don't think bitcoin/crypto will go away
- jboy55 4y agoAren't the vast majority of that 150T market in cross border payments already done outside of crypto?
- lovich 4y agoCross border payments are 50% bigger than the total planets gdp?
- darig 4y ago
- SgtBastard 4y agoI mean technically it could. For example, to buy goods from China in AU, I need to pay in USD./ For 100 USD in goods, I could have to send AUD cross border to receive 100 USD and then definitely have to send 100 USD cross border to China - nominally triggering 200 USD in payment volume for 100 USD in GDP. And then for companies using a Double Irish, Dutch Sandwich... well, the volume adds up. Crypto still isn't the answer though.
- lovich 4y agoI asked because it seems logically impossible since cross border payments are included in the aggregate of the world gdp. The same mechanism you are describing for the velocity of money also works inside national borders
- adaml_623 4y agoThe current fiat/fx cross border payment mechanisms are better than crypto. Faster, cheaper and more secure.
- kevinak 4y agoNo they are not, in what world can you transfer money instantly and settle it across borders in seconds? I'd love to see an insecure bitcoin transaction as well.
- it_citizen 4y agoI don't know much about crypto or cross-border payments. Is there current crypto solutions that work better than something like transferwise if i wanted to transfer USD to EUR for instance? (cheaper?, faster?, simpler?, reliable?)
- knorker 4y agoNo, none of the above. Except in one aspect: Because cryptocurrency for these purposes at best use a loophole in AML/KYC laws, at worst just plain break them, if you do it right there's less risk of getting caught (guilty or innocently) in mandated money laundering tripwires. I've had banks call me about source of funds, and sometimes require proof, for large "unusual" transactions. I was an innocent victim of these audits. It delayed my transactions by maybe minutes. Yes, probably some percentage of people who've lost money, through no fault of their own, to these extra checks. But for every single one of those there are at least thousands who've lost cryptocurrency due to them not having these checks and audits. And on top of that of course cryptocurrency transactions are much fewer and move less value.
- kevinak 4y agoYes. Bitcoin - It's cheaper, faster, simpler and more reliable. It's not just faster on the front end. It settles pretty much instantly on the back end as well, so no counter party risk like in the case of using banks.
- aketchum 4y agoyou still have currency risk and exchange rate slippage, but even worse because you are introducing a third currency. Any "innovation" crypto does in cross border payments is skirting regulation which clearly will not scale well. Regulators will just crack down when the market is sufficiently large for their attention.
- knorker 4y agoHow are the standard solutions for cross border payments worse than bitcoin/cryptocurrency? I regularly ship 5-6 digits between countries. It's not even hard. And I do it without gas fees (there's paying the spread, but if I'd use cryptocurrency then I'd have to pay the spread twice). And I can do it without the fear of a mistake, or a hack (of me or the bank), taking away the deposit on my house. The proposed cure is worse than the disease.
- kevinak 4y agoNot everyone has this privilege. In fact, most people in the world can't do what you're doing. For them it is immensely hard in comparison.
- knorker 4y agoMost people in the world can definitely not use cryptocurrencies. Maybe the average nonprivileged will succeed once or twice, but this is like going to Vegas and using the martingale system: It'll make you win consistently, right up to the point where you lose everything you have. I've always found the "what about the third world" arguments bizarre. As if villages and huts are filled with technical geniuses who will never lose their passwords. And if not wallet keys, then all the blockchain mini-banks who give you no recourse if you lose your second factor, and don't have to because they're not regulated. And that's the mini-banks who aren't plain rugpulls, or get hacked. The people who are privileged enough to successfully be able to use cryptocurrencies are also privileged enough to even more successfully use proper banking.
- kevinak 4y agoAre you insinuating folks in the developing world are incapable of understanding and handling their own keys? Wow.
- knorker 4y agoPeople in rich countries can't either. Please review the HN guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html I will not engage further.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoIt works. You just don't have to hold forever.
- kjreact 4y agoSo did tulips. But yeah, holding those forever would have been a bad idea…
- spaceman_2020 4y agoIf you want to buy any crypto, you should either buy it as an entertaining gambling habit, or you should buy it because you believe in the core philosophy behind it. If you buy it as an "investment", you were missold.
- sshine 4y agoOr because you want to buy drugs online.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoEvading sanctions and the law still the best use case for crypto.
- Kathula 4y agoAnd where does the "likely" part come from?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> where does the "likely" part come from? It’s a zero-yield risk asset in a world of rising rates and economic uncertainty.
- lavventura 4y agoPeople still can get rich when BTC drops, if they shorted the market.
- JamesBarney 4y agoDepending on your counterparty risk.
- wollsmoth 4y agoyou can lose a lot of money trying to time options trades like that.
- nannal 4y agoIs shorting an option?
- thewataccount 4y agoShorting is different from an option. They are often confused because you can say you have a "short position" or a "long position" with either (long position would be buying shares). Most people are more familiar with buying puts or selling call options are superficially similar - you make money if the price goes down. Options give the holder the right to buy/sell a share at a specific price before a specific date. They expire worthless after that date. Shorts are immediately borrowing shares - not just the right to buy/sell shares. They do not generally expire, although they do have interest. GP said " if they shorted the market." which is a bit ambiguous, it sounds like they are talking about a literal short, but in this context they likely mean either. tl;dr - no they're different
- vasco 4y ago> boring index funds Ah yes the FIRE lifehack that absolutely cannot go wrong and will allow everyone to sip margaritas by the beach at 45. Still way safer than any crypto, but I hope you see how that's just another cult at this point.
- chowchowchow 4y agoIf there are going to be media/influencers pushing tips to achieve a FIRE lifestyle, I can’t imagine what I’d prefer they encourage besides low cost broad market index funds. Don’t really see the problem there: investing like that really is most likely the best use of excess capital in the long term.
- arcticbull 4y agoThe S&P 500 has yielded like a 9% return for almost 65 years - since your grandpappy was knee-high to a grasshopper. The nice thing about index funds is they track indices that are curated. Only the 500 best companies (according to a metric) are included and the companies are rotated in and out as that changes. It's not really a cult, what matters is your time horizon.
- rightbyte 4y ago> Only the 500 best companies (according to a metric) are included and the companies are rotated in and out as that changes. That is the thing. What would the return have been if my grandpappy bought SAP500 65 years ago and kept those stocks he bought at the time until today? I have never seem such a number. I mean if the loser stocks are rotated out it is hard to keep up with the index due to losses and transaction costs.
- chowchowchow 4y agoYou are correct. Grandpappy’s portfolio would have lots of defunct businesses and no Apple, Google, or Microsoft, to name a few.
- mister_tee 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]