3 ms·
This was a common refrain when the verdict was first announced, and I think it absolutely misses the point. Legal outcomes are about what you can prove. It was
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
This was a common refrain when the verdict was first announced, and I think it absolutely misses the point.
Legal outcomes are about what you can prove. It was very clear that Holmes said "Our product can do x, y, z" to investors, and it's also totally clear she knew this to be false at the time, and it was material.
The evidence that she, personally, was guilty of defrauding patients directly was always reaching in my opinion. I followed the trial closely, and were I on the jury I would have voted for the same outcome.
The thing I really don't like about the line of reasoning is that it's essentially emotional at its heart: investors are rich and knew they were taking a risk, while patients are the ones who need protection. That may very well be true, but you don't get to just make up outcomes because one group is more powerful than another. The prosecution just failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that she was guilty of defrauding patients.
- ryanisnan 4y agoHow is saying to investors "Our product can do x, y, z" to investors not ok, but saying it to say Walgreens (and thus customers) is ok?
- naasking 4y ago> That may very well be true, but you don't get to just make up outcomes because one group is more powerful than another. The prosecution just failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that she was guilty of defrauding patients. Arguably, court procedures and standards of evidence are also made up and prioritize certain powerful groups over others. Which isn't to say that we shouldn't have rules, I'm just not sure appealing to the rules invalidates a claim that the outcome was unjust.
- origin_path 4y agoWhich powerful groups do court rules and standard of evidence prioritize?
- naasking 4y agoThose with finances and influence. Or do you think that public defenders and private attorneys yield comparable outcomes? As but one example.
- origin_path 4y agoThe whole point of standards of evidence and court rules is to diminish the importance of influence. Those rules and standards also don't "prioritize" people with finances: there is nothing in any rule or standard that says "give priority to people with more money". The exacting nature of the system does mean expertise is worth money, but that's not an explicit design goal of that system.
- lovich 4y agoIf that’s the bar for emotional then all laws are emotional once you get down to it. The poster has the implicit value statement that the least powerful need the most legal protection, which is certainly a common cultural value in the modern West. I mean, even the idea that a third party needs to come in and administer punishment when one group defrauds the other is an emotional statement. You could just as easily argue that they all should have vetted theranos’s statements and not taken their word on it
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoWell, we disagree on what would qualify as "emotional statements", but I don't think that's the central point. If one wants to argue it was unfair that she was guilty of a crime against investors but not patients, that's a fine and good discussion to have. I'm just pushing back against the comment I was replying to, "I'll always be shocked that she was guilty of deceiving investors and not patients." I think the evidence showed their was clear deceit against investors in a way there wasn't against patients.
- lovich 4y agoI can’t see how being fraudulent about the product working at all isn’t clear deceipt against the patients paying for a product that worked as described. Her fraud wasn’t centered solely around investor specific facts like the financial health of the company
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI posted this comment in response to a similar question: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33524399 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33524399 People are speaking in broad strokes without bothering to look at the specifics of what was presented at the trial.
- lovich 4y agoI see what you’re saying and the juries opinion there. I just do not agree with their assessment > Though they initially were divided, jurors soon agreed to acquit Ms. Holmes on the one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud and three counts of wire fraud tied to patients, Ms. Stefanek said. She said the jury concluded that prosecutors didn’t present enough evidence to show that Ms. Holmes knowingly pitched a faulty product to induce patients to pay for tests. I don’t know the word for it, but this fits a type of behavior I’ve observed where people will break a behavior into a series of actions and since each action on its own is not a problem, then the behavior represented by the set of actions is deemed not problematic. Her company sold a product alleging X performance when she knew that this was false. Her product was then sold to people looking for a product that had X performance specifically because it was so beyond what any competitors had come up with. It was not a commodity good that they just happened to have purchased from this one vendor and didn’t care about the fraudulent performance claims. There is no way I could not see this as fraud. I don’t disagree with the facts you’ve presented, I’m making a value judgement
- FireBeyond 4y ago> The evidence that she, personally, was guilty of defrauding patients directly was always reaching in my opinion. "It was totally clear she knew her products could not do x, y and z. She facilitated and approved and enabled sales of these products that could not do x, y and z, to providers who were going to use them to perform x, y and z tests on patients, tests that they could not do." How do you see that she didn't defraud patients?
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThis WSJ interview with a juror gives a very good explanation in my opinion. Again, verdicts are about what can be proven: > Though they initially were divided, jurors soon agreed to acquit Ms. Holmes on the one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud and three counts of wire fraud tied to patients, Ms. Stefanek said. She said the jury concluded that prosecutors didn’t present enough evidence to show that Ms. Holmes knowingly pitched a faulty product to induce patients to pay for tests. > The jury was in agreement, Ms. Stefanek said, that the Theranos lab was run shoddily and not in the way to be expected from a company setting out to achieve the highest quality in medical care. But jurors thought the burden of proof on defrauding patients was higher. > “If all we’d had to prove was that she knew there might be problems in the lab and that might end up harming patients, that would be one thing,” Ms. Stefanek said. https://www.wsj.com/articles/jury-in-elizabeth-holmes-trial-seized-on-two-smoking-guns-to-convict-theranos-founder-juror-says-11641503502 https://www.wsj.com/articles/jury-in-elizabeth-holmes-trial-...
- FireBeyond 4y agoI get it. But I admit I'm also on the side of healthy skepticism when it comes to anything around her. Have not followed the trial closely (which is on me), but read a lot of the articles and books and such. To me it's direct correlation. "If she knew there might be problems in the lab" - the only problem in the lab was the machines themselves! The blood work is known science - the issue was getting to a point where accurate blood work could be done. Which involved the machines, the machines that they separately demonstrated she knew did not and could not do 'x, y and z'. And to be clear, in your example, x, y and z are "extract sufficient blood for an accurate test", "extract blood in a way that allows for an accurate test (i.e. absent over-dilution, contamination)". To also be clear, this can be entirely a failing of the prosecution too - but it seems there's this sense of "there's this missing -glue- that we couldn't prove", but the lab IS the machine, and if she knows the machine can't do x, y, z, then it follows that the lab can't do x, y and z. There are only two outcomes from the machine, and lab, an accurate result, or an inaccurate result (or inability to provide any result). And then if you say "My machine cannot do x, y and z", then it cannot provide accurate results (at least not by design, stopped clocks and all that). Then you get to a conclusion that her argument would be that "an inaccurate result doesn't inherently harm a patient", and convoluted logical leaps of "because the result would lead to further testing and interventions", but there was presented at trial concrete evidence that unnecessary, and harmful, interventions were ordered/performed, on the basis of the lab results from those machines.